User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Top notch documentary on film
shobill10 June 2006
Every time our annual international film fest hits town, I scan all the offerings, with special attention to Iranian productions. I have seen so many fascinating films from a country that, in recent years, has banned Hollywood and other films foreign to them, and yet their filmmakers, despite having to follow strict guidelines and risking censorship at every turn, produce some of the finest films in world cinema.

This documentary features interviews with several Iranian filmmakers, plus clips from a number of their best films. Among various aspects of Iranian film-making, they talk about how their reflective films differ from the Hollywood action variety, although there is such a role for Iranian film as well. What perhaps is really remarkable is how freely these producer/directors talk in a critical way about the censorship exercised in their country. The clever ways they get around it actually appear to challenge and enhance their creativity (as Duke Ellington once said, in describing how he had to compose his music to fit the talents and limitations of his band members, "It can be good to have limits"). Unusual scenarios between husbands and wives get around the rule that men and women, even when married, can't touch. Children are sometimes used to state in an allegorical or analogous fashion what could not be presented by adult characters. And the role of women is wondrously portrayed in these productions from a country that severely limits women's roles.

This film takes concentration to appreciate, but is every bit worth the effort.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Male Inferiority
westsideschl21 April 2019
Reviewing the current update (included are 2000, 2007, 2013 releases) to this documentary called: "Iranian Cinema Before & After Revolution 2019" Females do not show your hair; do not sing; do not dance; do not kiss; do not touch; do not shake hands; do not embrace between a female & male even if the closest of a family member. Applies to everyday life as well as what is allowed to be shown in movies under the "no contact laws" of Iran. Enforced by the Ministry of Culture. In movies even if sleeping or showering you must be wearing your hijab. If you fall & are injured no males can come to your aid. Thus we see some of the ridiculous effects of behavior control not only from Shia Iran, but even Sunni Saudi Arabia who incidentally uses it's wealth to sponsor it's female slavery Sharia law in many other countries (e.g. Indonesia, & extreme conservatism in Sri Lanka contributing to bombings) of the world by mosque building & monetary enticements. Also imprisonment, and physical torture for not wearing a niqab or burqa in public. As in Saudi Arabia if an Iranian women shows a little hair the police or the Iranian Islamic Religious Police can imprison the female who is then often treated harshly (put mildly). In this documentary Iranian Ministry of Censorship had a difficult time deciding whether to allow a mother helping her paralyzed son to be shown. Joining the two aforementioned countries are Russia, North Korea, China & Turkey in state sponsored censorship to the point of imprisonment & assassination; all to control/stifle individuality.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed