User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A literary man addresses posterity
wmorrow5916 August 2008
This short film begins with a nicely composed shot of what appears to be the garden of an English manor house, with a gravel path stretching into the foreground. An elderly but spry bearded gentleman dressed in the traditional flannels of a country squire strides towards us. Birds are twittering, a stray moth flits past the lens, and we can hear the gravel crunching as he gets closer. He dabs at his nose with a handkerchief, then abruptly seems to notice the camera (and presumably the crew of technicians) for the first time. "Well, this is a surprise!" he exclaims quite unconvincingly. "Have you all come to see me, ladies and gentlemen?" The gent is George Bernard Shaw, and he's here to improvise a brief address for the unseen cinema audience. He speaks in clipped, perfectly enunciated Henry Higgins-style English, with nary a hint of his native Ireland. His delivery falters a bit here and there, but his air of authority is unmistakable.

By the time he turned 70 in 1926 Shaw had written most of his major works and had been a literary celebrity for over three decades. Now, at the age of 71, he would become something of a movie star, or at least a star of newsreels. Over the next few years Shaw would deliver jovial orations in several sound films (this Fox Movietone short marks his second such appearance) and he was said to be an audience favorite. It's easy to see why: even when he's rambling his way through a series of disjointed remarks, as he does here, he's charming and funny.

Almost as soon as the Fox Studio acquired a sound-on-film system to make newsreels their crews were sent around the world to capture talkie footage of of celebrities, everyone from Charles Lindbergh to Arthur Conan Doyle. Even Benito Mussolini delivered a speech in broken English to the Movietone cameras, and Shaw seems to have been aware of this, for he spends much of his time here poking fun at the Italian dictator. He assumes a formidable pose, lowers his brow, glowers at us in a menacing fashion and even raises his arm in the Fascist salute, then relaxes and remarks that although he himself is able to strike this threatening pose or take it off at will, Signor Mussolini is condemned to go through life looking like this, "though he is a most amiable man." This kind of joshing might make contemporary viewers a bit queasy, but it's important to note, first, that Shaw was most certainly being facetious, and furthermore that the true evil of Fascism was not widely understood at the time this film was made, even by highly intelligent and well-informed persons such as G. B. Shaw. It's also worth adding that in "Buoyant Billions," Shaw's last full-length play, he made clear his disdain for Mussolini and Hitler.

Getting back to the film at hand, our speaker concludes with an anecdote about a little girl who encountered him on a public street in Wales and was urged by her father to ask him for his autograph, even though she had no idea who he was. And then, with a jolly wave, Shaw bids us goodbye. His talk for the camera, barely five minutes in length, is slight in content yet oddly hypnotic. Like those very early motion pictures of ocean waves and passing trains, this brief film gives us a glimpse of a brand new technology and allows us to imagine its impact on audiences when most movies were still silent, while the somewhat frivolous nature of Shaw's off-the-cuff remarks gives us a sense of the man's playful side. This film is a fascinating little treasure.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Shaw as Shaw
max von meyerling16 April 2007
History walks up to a movie camera and unloads. There are so many of the greats of the past whom we can only surmise how they were like in real life. Was Oscar Wilde effeminate? Was Joan of Arc ugly? Did Shakespeare have a sense of humor? Here Shaw pretty much directs himself in a short first person film which he wrote. He starts off feigning surprise long before it became standard practice on Murrow's Person to Person, every late night talk show and unbelievably contrived 'reality' shows. In 1928, when for the first time he could use the medium to express himself using his stock-in-trade, i.e. : words, he goes out of his way to insult Mussolini, at a time when a lot of people, who should have known better, were busy praising him (e.g. He made the trains run on time etc.) We hear his voice and discern only the slightest of Irish lilts but also find that he doesn't wallow in some plumy RP prattle. It is a kind of immortality all the more charming for its deliberately contrived off handedness.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Early talkie with Shaw Talking Constantly
jaynashvil8 November 2004
This short is simply George Bernard Shaw making his talking film debut before the American camera. And talk he does. Shot on the grounds of his home in Ayot St. Lawrence, Hertfordshire, Shaw walks towards the camera, feigns surprise at our visit, and proceeds to deliver a rambling monologue about Mussolini's grouchy look and other totally unrelated subjects. Supposedly Shaw agreed to do this film on the condition he could direct. That makes it all the odder that he seems to be rambling and ill prepared. The film is fascinating for it's historical value, and is included in the DVD set "More Treasures from American Film Archives".
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed