"Play for Today" Just a Boys' Game (TV Episode 1979) Poster

(TV Series)

(1979)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
All in the Rules of the Game
JamesHitchcock12 November 2020
This play was recently aired again on BBC4 as part of a season celebrating the fiftieth anniversary of the BBC's famous "Play for Today" series. In fact, the series actually began life in 1964 as "The Wednesday Play"; all that happened in 1970 is that the series acquired a new title after a change in the BBC schedules which led to Wednesday evenings being given over to sport and drama moved to Thursdays. But we'll let that pass.

The play was written by the Scottish author Peter McDougall and was filmed in and around the town of Greenock near Glasgow. Most of the dialogue is in Scots dialect, but English viewers should not let that put them off. I am a Man of Kent, about as far from the Scottish border as you can get in the UK, and I had no difficulty in understanding it.

The central character, Jake McQuillan, works as a crane operator in Greenock docks, but the play is less about his work life than what he does in his spare time, which largely revolves around drinking and fighting. Jake lives with his maternal grandparents; his father is dead and he is largely alienated from his mother. He looks up to his grandfather, now elderly, sick and dying, but who in his younger days had the reputation of being Greenock's hardest man, a title to which Jake now aspires. His grandfather, however, rather looks down on Jake, believing that he will never be as hard as he himself was.

The title "Just a Boys' Game" refers to Jake's hard-man lifestyle; fighting is seen as a "game" with its own rules. We learn that Jake's grandfather has spent time in prison as a result of an incident in which Jake's father, who was a member of a rival gang, was killed. Jake, however, bears his grandfather no ill-will over this incident, believing that it was "all part of the game".

Many "Plays for Today" were on political themes which can make them seem very dated today. For example, another in the BBC4 season, Colin Welland's "Leeds United!", has its roots in the industrial unrest of the early seventies and today looks like a fossil from another age. Indeed, its black-and-white photography, deliberately harking back to the look of the "kitchen sink" social realist cinema of the late fifties and early sixties, probably made it seem like something of a period piece even when first shown in 1974.

Although it was originally shown in November 1979, "Just a Boys' Game", by contrast, seems much fresher, as relevant to the 2010s and 2020s as it was to the seventies. Unlike some plays in the series, it did not feature any actors who were famous at the time, although Gregor Fisher was later to become a well-known face on British television, especially after he starred in "Rab C Nesbitt". There is, however, an excellent performance from Frankie Miller as Jake, and he receives good support from Ken Hutchison and Fisher as Jake's mates. This is a film with a raw power, not only in its depictions of violence and brawling, which can be graphic, but also in its emotional content, especially the surprisingly poignant scenes between Jake and the old man. It confirms my view that the BBC, and British television in general, should do more to celebrate its heritage of fine drama instead of keeping it locked away in the vaults. 8/10
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
One of the best 'Play For Today' instalments
Red-Barracuda6 June 2022
This is an entry from the BBC 'Play For Today' series which occupies the subgenre known as 'its grim up north'. This one is set in late 70's Greenock which I am hoping - but not certain - is grimmer than present day Greenock. Its rain lashed streets, grey schemes, snooker halls and pints of Tennents all the way in this one. Its about a local tough guy who is newly released from prison and in lodgings with his grandparents, his grandfather being once known as 'Greenock's hardest man'. Its about vicious circles and the way life repeats itself. The grim urban backdrop makes for a great setting and it has a superb turn by Scottish soul singer Frankie Miller in the lead role. Its definitely a very involving bit of telly drama and can be considered yet another winner from the 'Play For Today' strand.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Just a Boys Game
d_m_s27 July 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Very realistic and enjoyable. Great acting, interesting story and characters. I think reading the synopsis let it down for me as I expected this to be more of an exploration into a 'hard man' and why he was like that, what societal pressures he was under and what his life was like but it wasn't really like that. It was more of a section of his life without any real in depth revelations. Had it not been for the dying grandfather this would have seemed like a totally random section of this mans life. Had I not read the synopsis I think I would have enjoyed it more as I would not have had the expectations e.g. It says Jake has to keep up the reputation of being the hardest man in town but at no point was it made clear he was the hardest man or that he had to keep this reputation up. So I kept waiting for that aspect to be delved into but it never was. Also not sure how realistic this portrayal of a hard man was - Jake was very calm, caring and even philosophical. Not exactly the aggressive drug dealing gangster you would expect. Also he had no gang, he just hung around with some loser who was not hard at all and shied away from any kind of confrontation. Jake in fact came across as quite a decent chap who just happens to be in a bad situation and, apparently, super hard.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Masterpiece
simon-11830 June 2004
Take no notice of Dinky Donk, who has put annoyingly silly reviews of Peter McDougall plays on here. If you read his comments you'd get a very misguided idea of what this piece is about.

Just a Boy's Game is a masterpiece, a low-key story of life in a depressed Greenock, when the only ambition for the hard-cases is to be legendary hard-cases. Miller's performance is first-class, and Mackenzie's direction faultless.

This is quite possibly the finest Scottish film ever made with the exception of Just Another Saturday.

Faultless.
27 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Perfect
gilso6815 December 2006
Make no bones about it folks, This masterpiece is the best television drama 'EVER' to come out of bonny Scotland !! Frankie Miller is not only Scotlands greatest ever singer, Given a few more lucky breaks he should have been one of our best ever actors as well. The supporting cast of Ken Huchison (Murphy's mob, The Sweeney) & a youthful Gregor Fisher (Rab C Nesbit, Naked Video) just make this a joy to watch, Its great the BBC have at last released this on DVD as it hasn't been on TV for at least 20 years !! The song that runs over the credits at the end (Rules of the game) can be found on the remastered Frankie Miller CD Once in a blue moon.
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent slice of life.
sebastian_carr8 May 2003
Set in Greenock, in Scotland, this hard hitting drama perfectly captures the hard man culture of the west of Scotland. Strong performances and a spot on script combine to give British TV one of its finest moments. The grim urban decay contrasts with the natural beauty that lies beyond.
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
''I know the rules of the game!''
Rabical-9117 July 2017
Warning: Spoilers
'Just A Boys' Game' is my favourite 'Play For Today' edition of all time. It was written by Peter McDougall for whom this was his third entry into the 'Play For Today' strand, ahead of 'Just Another Saturday' and 'The Elephant's Graveyard'.

It was all about the life of a hardman named Jake McQuillen, who works in the shipyards of Greenock. He fills his nights drinking and larking with his friends Dancer ( a lover and joker rather than a fighter ) and Tanza ( a jack-the-lad with a sharp tongue ). Although he wants nothing more than a quiet life, he often finds himself having to call upon the use of his fists whenever someone tries to challenge him. Playing the impassive Jake was Scottish soul singer Frankie Miller in what was his only acting role. It comes clear that Jake's life is not a happy one. He was rejected by his mother and sent to live with his grandparents as a child.

Jake appears to have a close relationship with grandmother but has no bond whatsoever with his dying grandfather, who was once the town's hardest man. Despite their hatred for each other, Jake wants to get as close as possible to the old man before he dies.

One night, whilst on the town with Tanza and Dancer, a young team of thugs, headed by a young razor wielder named McAfferty, corner the three men and a fight ensues. Unfortunately, whilst Jake and Tanza manage to handle themselves, Dancer draws the short straw of luck and, whilst trying to evade the thugs runs headlong into a mooring cable, killing him. Tanza is openly distraught at Dancer's fate, however Jake conceals his grief, telling Tanza ''That's how it goes, that's the game!''.

Later, Jake is horrified to hear his grandfather's dying words.

As Jake, the monotone voiced Miller was sparkling, giving a natural performance as the cold yet somehow lovable and ruggedly handsome McQuillen. As a result of his outstanding performance, Miller was offered a string of other roles but turned them down as his interests lay more on music than acting. A pity as I believe he could well have been a contender for one of Scotland's greatest actors. Hector Nicol ( a very good stand-up comedian by the way ) likewise was equally fear striking as Jake's grandfather. Alas, his potential as a straight actor was cut prematurely when he died in 1985.

The supporting cast, including Ken Hutchison, a then unknown Gregor Fisher ( sporting a 'Jason King' moustache rather than a string vest and bandage ), Katherine Stark and Jean Taylor Smith all make their time on screen worthwhile and possibly even make the characters more stronger than they were written. McAfferty is played by Billy Greenlees, who originally played Chancer in 'City Lights' before being replaced by Andy Gray. McDougall's script, brought to life by wonderful performances and wonderful production values, was full of many great lines that fizzed like bubbles in a cola.

In 1994, a brain haemorrhage very nearly claimed Frankie Miller's life. He was in a coma for months and for a while after emerging was unable to speak, necessitating the need for rehabilitation. Whilst he is no longer able to perform, his legacy as a singer is still beating strong with fans.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Just a Boys' Game
Prismark1031 October 2020
Warning: Spoilers
If Martin Scorsese was walking the Mean Streets of New York in the 1970s. Scots director John Mackenzie along with writer Peter McDougall were looking at life at the sharp end of Scotland.

Just a Boys' Game features tough violent scenes including blades. It was a time when going to a rough pub or club could end up in a punch up. Football hooliganism was rampant.

Jake McQuillen (Frankie Miller) works in the shipyards of Greenock and has a reputation of a tough guy. He wants nothing more than the approval of his dying grandad who once was the toughest man around. Now he is coughing up blood in his final days.

When Jakes goes drinking with his pals Dancer (Ken Hutchinson) and Tanza (Gregor Fisher.) Trouble seems to follow them and there is a new younger crew, handy with knives who want to teach Jake a lesson.

This is a slice of life urban western set in rundown housing estates with the stench of cheap booze. The bars have shutters that quickly come down when trouble breaks out. The police arrive long after the patrons have calmed down or ran away.

There is a very violent finale with the inevitable tragic ending and not much sentimentality. Dancer was a family man who loses his life. Tanza is upset but Jake just shrugs it off. It is the price you pay for fighting.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed