Symetria (2003) Poster

(2003)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Very interesting
BroadswordCallinDannyBoy24 September 2005
A young man is accused of assault and arrested. He swears that he is innocent, but the fact that an old woman is the one he supposedly beat doesn't make him look good in a anyones eyes. Thus he winds up in jail and is given advice to ask to be jailed with a particular group of prisoners, the career criminals. Frightened to death, ridiculed, and generally looked down upon at first we see the young man change according to the prison's unwritten rules.

This makes for an interesting look at not just prison life, but life in general. There are rules on both sides of the prison walls, and we simply must choose to follow or not to follow them and then face the consequences. For example the prison cell has no door on the bathroom compartment so when going to the bathroom one must announce it to the others and for the time being no one is aloud to eat. A strange rule, but followed with discipline and one is punishable if he breaks it. As the young man learns the ins and outs of prison life he gains respect inside and notoriety on the outside and then we see just what this 'symmetry' in life is and what results, for better or worse on both sides of the prison wall, it can yield. 8/10

No rating, but contains profanity
30 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Good movie 'bout Polish jails.
sfensony27 December 2004
An innocent man goes to jail being charged for beating some old woman (with deathly result). He's got no alibi and the only witness of the incident recognize him and die few days later (very old woman). Now he's trying to live in the new environment.

Will it change him? How can he handle that? What side of prisoners he'll choose (git-men or mug)?

You must see it yourself.

In my opinion: That movie shows polish prison in excellent way. And the young actor should get a medal for playing. You'll got few minutes for thinking 'bout your innocence.
31 out of 47 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
masterpiece Warning: Spoilers
First of all I'd recommend to not allow Canadude's review to make an influence on your decision about buying/renting/downloading "Symetria" or not. The artistic quality of this movie is very very high. I didn't see this "pretending" in even one single scene. All the acts are amazingly good (especially for polish cinema as it stands today), especially that of the main actor, which had some really hard role to play. It really gets you in. When you watch this movie, you're in polish jail, no doubt about it! I've got some friends who have been/are in jail, and they say that except few tiny little mistakes, you want to get the picture of polish jail, watch it. The change of attitude Lukasz shows toward that oldest guy from the cell can be easily understood and is also real. That's jail reality - you keep it with the tough, you're considered tough. You keep with guys who (for this or other reason) don't deserve respect in that reality - what can you expect then? So it was his decision to make and although it can be questionable, he did what was necessary to make his survival easier. That's what any guy with balls would do in such situation. To our pleasure Detmer makes acting of the script psychologically compatible there also, by showing that this is a hard thing to do, yet he's building his strenght, so he does it. If you haven't seen the movie, yet you read this review knowing that it contains spoiler, I can tell you one thing only: get it!
18 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Going through the motions
canadude13 April 2005
There was a time when Polish cinema ranked among the best of the world. Those days, inevitably and indubitably, are over. "Symetria" is a perfect example of why - a failure of a film, a dismal, boring, drawn-out, sentimental mess.

"Symetria" or "Symmetry" for those who haven't yet caught on, tells the story of a man who ends up in prison, entirely without reason, assuring us continuously of his innocence and ends up being corrupted by the system. In a word, true - this happens often, I do not doubt. In a world outside of society, people begin living by their own rules very much a la "Lord of the Flies." But what "Symetria" does is not explore this theme with a new angle, try to shed light on it or even portray the theme realistically. What it does is *attempt* to be art rather than actually *be* art. In other words, it becomes a grotesque, vulgar bore-show of long takes and clichéd dialogue and trivialized psychological analysis. The shift in personality that occurs in the main character I simply do not buy - especially when he turns on a man whom he has consistently, without fail treated as a friend (until this particular moment that I don't want to reveal.) This film is an insult to the intelligence of anyone who takes cinema seriously. It's tragic too because "Symetria" opens with a lot of potential, but it goes through the motions of a story and believable character development rather than actually accomplish these things. At the end of it I felt cheated, empty, unsatisfied - even dissatisfied. It's been a while since I've seen a dramatic film, that takes itself seriously, strewn together from parts of films and books far greater than itself - all to amount to a jumbled mess.

I won't get into specifics, but my main problem is with the corruption of the main character. It doesn't happen realistically, believably and a step at a time. It seems like he's a nice, shy, isolated guy at first and then suddenly, he turns into a prison-life-savvy vigilante. In fact, the film actually seems to imply what it tries to be dead set against: namely that jails, however horrid, actually instill a sense of morality and responsibility in an individual that is far beyond what people outside of jail can comprehend. Jail is good - the tough, who survive, are tough enough to take morality into their own hands and do it justly. Or so the film seems to imply through its final scenes - I don't want to spoil the fun for whoever wants to watch "Symetria" by revealing them.

Needless to say, this is a below-average film and I think I disliked it so much because it pretends to be about so much, while being about nothing, or failing to be about anything well. In that respect it's pretentious, self-involved, simplistic and forced.
13 out of 96 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed