"American Masters" Richard Rodgers: The Sweetest Sounds (TV Episode 2001) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A complex, unhappy man...and probably the greatest theater composer America has produced
Terrell-46 February 2008
Compare the difference between the gorgeous, witty, romantic songs from a man who probably was America's most outstanding popular songwriter with these quotes about the man himself: "For somebody who gave such incredible pleasure to so many millions of people, not to have had the same kind of joy and contentment and comfort in his own life is just awful," says one of his daughters. She continues, "He was worried about all kinds of things, but he didn't talk about them." Says his other daughter, "He was deeply neurotic, deeply, and very unhappy unless he was writing."

Richard Rodgers was born in 1902. He starting composing when he was 9. He had his first show on Broadway when he was 18. He and his partner Larry Hart became Broadway's song- writing darlings with The Garrick Gaieties in 1925. Between then and the death of his second partner, Oscar Hammerstein II, in 1960 (Hart died in 1943), he had hit after hit on Broadway and an unparalleled catalogue of marvelous songs. When Rodgers died in 1979 at the age of 77, a survivor of jaw cancer, a stroke, a heart attack, depression, a laryngectomy and alcoholism, his latest show had just opened. "He had one interest," said an observer, "and that was to write music to stories for the stage."

Richard Rodgers: The Sweetest Songs is in my view the best of the documentaries on America's great theater composers. During the period from the early Twenties through the Forties, Jerome Kern, George Gershwin, Irving Berlin and Cole Porter were outdoing themselves in creating what later came to be known as The Great American Songbook. With one or two exceptions, most of the shows these men wrote their songs for have been long forgotten. Their songs, however, are still with us. Rodgers, alone among them, steadily moved from songs simply placed into shows to shows with stories which were important and where the songs were integral to telling the story. Alone among them, Rodgers created shows, especially with Hammerstein, that still are produced, from high school drama club presentations to Broadway revivals. This documentary takes us through Rodgers' life, his partners, his shows and his development as one of the most important theater people America has ever produced. Unlike so many cozy, complimentary biographies of admired people, the program faces up to the often uncomfortable conflicts, in Rodgers' case between what he wrote and how he dealt with life, other people and his own needs. He seemed to be so self-isolated a person that he only came alive when he was working. It's startling to realize, for instance, that the man who could write such tender, emotional waltzes as "Out of My Dreams," "Do I Hear a Waltz," "Oh, What a Beautiful Morning" and "Wait 'Til You See Her" was so frozen even his family couldn't get close.

One of the reasons this nearly two-hour documentary is so effective is because it uses shrewdly-chosen pieces of archival material, interviews with family members and theater professionals, excellent current singers such as Mary Clare Haran and a wide variety of contemporary clips from Rodgers' shows. The production is comprehensive but it keeps moving. For anyone who likes the great theater songs from the Twenties, Thirties and Forties and is interested in the men who wrote them, this documentary is essential viewing. To understand Richard Rodgers and just how good he was, I recommend getting a copy of Alec Wilder's incomparable American Popular Song: The Great Innovators, 1900-1950. And for a solid biography of Rodgers, look for Meryle Secrest's Somewhere for Me.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Reliable biography of a major Broadway composer
standardmetal13 September 2006
Yes, Richard Rodgers was one of the most ubiquitous composers in the popular music field who has always been played a great deal. His work spanned 5 decades, more or less and the quality of much of it it is very high. He and his collaborators have often been highly innovative and, by collaborators, I mean mostly Lorenz (Larry) Hart and Oscar Hammerstein both of whom he worked with early on. But the main collaboration with Hammerstein started with "Oklahoma" in 1943 when Hart refused to work any longer with the exception of some new songs for a revival of "A Connecticut Yankee". (Curiously, the songs, at least as played here, were not in the old style that he previously used with Hart, but in the much lusher and more expansive style of the Hammerstein collaborations.)

But the music historian Jonathan Schwartz, especially, makes some rather outrageous claims as, for example, that Rodgers is the most played composer in any field (I'd have thought Mozart or possibly even Irving Berlin, for example, was more often played but what do I know?). Or that Rodgers wrote the greatest waltzes ever, greater than Strauss which I also find questionable. Consider also the contributions of Schubert and Brahms both of which I find greater.

I also find many of Hammerstein's lyrics rather cringe-worthy especially those in "The Sound of Music" ("like a lark who is learning to pray" for example.), I must admit that I've never been able to get through the film of this show.

Rodgers' later bouts of alcoholism and his fight with cancer are given their due and this is a very satisfying and generally otherwise honest account of his life, but it does no one any favors to hype any artist to this extent.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
An historic tribute to stirring musical history
davesf30 July 2007
This is a wonderful documentary. And much more.

There are some films that could be made any time, any place. This isn't one of them. It contains extraordinary archival footage and priceless interviews. The whole is very well put together and really gives you a sense of the personal struggles and monumental achievements of Rodgers and his colleagues Hart and Hammerstein. It is both beautiful and heartbreaking. It's also a tribute to persistence, hard work, and the nature and importance of "good luck". (I think my favorite part of the movie is the vignette of Rodgers and Hart bemoaning their lack of traction early in their career.)

This is a love story to Rodgers, to America, and to the American musical theater as an art form. If you have any interest in musical theater, it is a "must-see".
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed