Remarks on Marx (Video 2004) Poster

(2004 Video)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Amusing documentary
Magenta_Bob28 January 2012
For any fan of the Marx brothers' films in general and A Night at the Opera in particular, Remarks on Marx is an entertaining documentary, in which writers, actors and other Marx enthusiasts from the film industry talk about different aspects of the films. Divided into several topics, it covers the creation of the brothers' personas and their career (from the early films with Paramount to the subsequent success at MGM, their vaudeville tours and their relationship with Irving Thalberg), as well as some classic sketches such as the stateroom and contract (i.e. sanity clause) scene.

However, while there are some amusing anecdotes that might not be available elsewhere, anyone looking for a nuanced or particularly incisive film about the works of Marx has come to the wrong place, as most of its entertainment derives from hearing film enthusiasts talk about why they love the franchise. But while it will probably not add to my enjoyment of the films, it will not take away anything either, as might have been the case if the documentary had gone too far down the route of explaining why we are laughing.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
I guess this tunnel-vision view is better than no view
charlytully13 June 2009
Warning: Spoilers
This brief (34-minute) 2004 making-of is an "extra" on that year's NIGHT AT THE OPERA d.v.d. Though several earlier Marx brother films are referred to (such as immediate predecessor DUCK SOUP), the only subsequent comedy mentioned is A DAY AT THE RACES. More pointedly, ALL of the Marx brother clips are from A NIGHT AT THE OPERA. When one of the "talking heads" says Allan Jones (as Ricardo Baroni) replaced Zeppo Marx as the group's "straight man" in OPERA, a clip from an earlier film including Zeppo would have been timely as an illustrative contrast.

P.S.--If copyright law prevents clips from studios competing in the 1930's to be included on the same 21st Century d.v.d., its another good reason to CHANGE such statutes to their ORIGINAL limit of about 20 years. Hollywood has bribed Congress every time STEAMBOAT WILLIE's protection is about to run out to extend this miserly tradition of holding our past hostage, and it is about time film fans grabbed their pitchforks and freed our collective heritage. Otherwise, Santa Claus and Uncle Sam soon will be "grandfathered" into such protection, and NO American images will remain in the public domain!
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Remarks on Marx: A Night at the Opera is a pretty good short doc on the movie's DVD
tavm22 January 2013
Just saw this short doc on the A Night at the Opera DVD. It has various people discussing the impact The Marx Brothers have on comedy and the way it was shaped but it's mostly about the behind the scenes of their first M-G-M movie and their relationship with head of production Irving Thalberg. Among the interviewees are co-star Kitty Carlisle and writer Irving Brecher. There are also nice insights from comedian Dom DeLuise, actor/writer Carl Reiner, and "SNL" writer Anne Beatts. While each brother gets a nice discussion, the most seems to concern Groucho mostly due to his wit. All in all, Remarks on Marx: A Night at the Opera is a worthy extra on the DVD I just mentioned.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed