Amazing Grace (2006) Poster

(2006)

User Reviews

Review this title
165 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Decent movie of a great story
rich-46431 January 2007
Most people probably have vaguely heard of William Wilberforce without knowing too much about his life. The power of his story, and the power of the central issue (the abolition of slavery), carries this movie that veers from artful to clumsy.

The movie can be confusing, as it moves back and forth between phases of Wilberforce's life. Often I found myself wondering for a few moments, "When is this?" Also, much of the political intrigue has to be inferred, since the backgrounds of the various players - particularly Wilberforce's adversaries - are not adequately explained.

However, the performances are quite good, some bordering on excellence. Some might argue that the villains are too simplistically presented, but on an issue like slavery, it is expected that the opposition would be completely unsympathetic (just as Nazis are rarely presented with any hint of sympathy).

I am sure the writers took some liberties with history. By the way, the tune we now associate with the hymn "Amazing Grace" did not become the melody for John Newton's famous lyrics until after Wilberforce's death.

I just watched this movie at a private screening for attendees of the National Prayer Breakfast in Washington, DC (clergy are a natural audience for this movie). The reception was favorable, but this was an audience for which the moralizing of the story would naturally resonate. I'm not sure it will attract a very broad audience - this is a movie that may well find its niche on DVD being shown in high school history classes and at church gatherings.

It is a nice, historical, period piece. It is (largely due to subject matter) reminiscent of "Amistad", with similar pacing.

Should you see it? It depends on whether you like this TYPE of movie. If this genre (historical drama) interests you, this is quite well-done. It might even inspire you to read more about Wilberforce. Go see it. If you are in search of movies that teach lessons about good values and perseverance in fighting for what's right, go see it.

But if you have no idea when the French Revolution occurred relative to our War of Independence, and if it doesn't come naturally to you to remember that the newborn U.S. was allied with France against Britain during that period - and if you don't care - this movie might not be your idea of a fun time.

If I were the producers, I would add one of those "scrolling text" historical introductions to the film before final release, though it is probably too late.
60 out of 85 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Touching biography about William Wilberforce responsible for a bill which abolishes the slave trade
ma-cortes19 June 2012
The idealist William Wilberforce (finely played by Ioan Grufudd) along with Rhomas Clarkson (Rufus Sewell) and a group of anti-slave trade maneuver his way through Parliament, endeavoring to end the British transatlantic trade that would lead to a great victory . Wilberforce helped by his lifelong friend and future P. M . William Pitt (Benedict Cumberbatch) will fight to get their purports for social justice . Wilberforce encounters the inspiration in newfound love interest (Romola Garai) to rejuvenate the battle with new ideas . After many attempts to bring legislation forward over twenty years, he is eventually gets a bill being passed through Parliament in 1807, in which abolishes the slavery the British empire forever.

This is a bicentennial tribute to William Wilberforce and his parliamentary bill abolishing the slave trade . Thought-provoking and moving film dealing with interesting issues , including fidelity to historical accuracy and detailed moral battles . Ioan Gruffudd is good as obstinate , romantic parliamentary member who battles relentlessly injustices ; he does a dignified portrayal about a great man . The prestigious cast shows their awareness of the contemporary impact about the brooding themes and are allowed to step out of period detail . Special mention to Benedict Cumberbatch as his lifelong friend Prime Minister William Pitt and N' Dour realizing an enjoyable portrait of an ex-slave . All of them are quietly upstaged by Albert Finney as a repent , remorse ex-slaver . The motion picture was marvelously directed by Michael Apted , he's director, producer of several successes such as ¨The word is not enough¨, ¨Gorillas in the mist¨ , ¨Class action¨, ¨Nell¨, ¨Enigma¨ , ¨Chronicles of Narnia II : The voyage of Dawn Treader¨ among others . Rating : Above average and worthwhile seeing , the whole family will enjoy this film .It's a very likable biography and enormously appealing for students and scholars . Overall this is a really nice movie . If you are familiar with the history then you will like this splendid film .

This is a biopic well based on historical events , adding more details over the largely described in the movie are the following : William Wilberforce (24 August 1759 – 29 July 1833) was a British politician, philanthropist, and a leader of the movement to abolish the slave trade. A native of Kingston upon Hull, Yorkshire, he began his political career in 1780, eventually becoming the independent Member of Parliament for Yorkshire (1784–1812). In 1785, he underwent a conversion experience and became an evangelical Christian, resulting in major changes to his lifestyle and a lifelong concern for reform. In 1787, he came into contact with Thomas Clarkson and a group of anti-slave-trade activists, including Granville Sharp, Hannah More and Charles Middleton. They persuaded Wilberforce to take on the cause of abolition, and he soon became one of the leading English abolitionists. He headed the parliamentary campaign against the British slave trade for twenty-six years until the passage of the Slave Trade Act of 1807. Wilberforce was convinced of the importance of religion, morality and education. He championed causes and campaigns such as the Society for Suppression of Vice, British missionary work in India, the creation of a free colony in Sierra Leone, the foundation of the Church Mission Society, and the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. His underlying conservatism led him to support politically and socially repressive legislation, and resulted in criticism that he was ignoring injustices at home while campaigning for the enslaved abroad.In later years, Wilberforce supported the campaign for the complete abolition of slavery, and continued his involvement after 1826, when he resigned from Parliament because of his failing health. That campaign led to the Slavery Abolition Act 1833, which abolished slavery in most of the British Empire; Wilberforce died just three days after hearing that the passage of the Act through Parliament was assured. He was buried in Westminster Abbey, close to his friend William Pitt.
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Let's hear it for Wilbers
Philby-35 August 2007
This film has been described as stolid ("too many parliamentary speeches"), but I would rather say "old fashioned". It is very much a reprise of the earnest 1940's style of biopic exemplified by "A Song to Remember" (about Chopin) and "The Al Jolson Story". Michael Apted as a director tends to produce poetic documentaries (the Seven-Up series) and prosaic feature films ("Enigma", and even his Bond effort "The World is not Enough"). Here, though there is a literate script from Steven Knight ("Dirty Pretty Things"), the story doesn't come across as well as it might, partly as a result of tinkering with the timeline (1797 to 1783 to 1797 to 1806).

More crucially, we really don't know at the end how William Wilberforce managed to turn round the opinion of those who mattered on the Slavery Question, though we get glimpses of his tactics. We meet some of his supporters, like Thomas Clarkson, a clergyman of revolutionary tendencies, former slaver John Newton and ex-slave Oloudaqh, and the clever Chancery lawyer, James Stephen. They are obviously very committed, but there has to be more to it. Who collected the 390,000 signatures on the petition produced in Parliament? One gets the impression that anti-slavery was a mass movement and Wilberforce, brave and resolute as he may have been, was just the toff who kept on introducing the anti-slave trade bill in the House of Commons - a toff whose subsequent career did not show him to be a friend of the working man.

As the toff in question Ioan Gruffud is just fine, though he's so reluctant to touch his lovely sweetheart Barbara Spooner (Romola Garai) that one marvels that he has so many descendants. The lack of love scenes is probably attributable to the policy of the producers, the Anschutz film group, of keeping their films G or PG. Apparently such films make more money than MA or, horrors, R movies. Anschutz is controlled by a Colorado billionaire of conservative inclinations and evangelical beliefs.

On the basis of this film, the protagonists of slavery were not terribly smart. The thrust of Wilberforce's attack was not so much on slavery itself as the deplorable conditions under which it was conducted. If the slavers had cleaned up their act and accepted a bit of regulation they could have gone on for another 50 years. Instead they just bribed MPs, who eventually had to support abolition to get re-elected.

One pro-slaver featured in the film is William, Duke of Clarence, who later reigned briefly but not too badly as William IV (1830-37). In reality quite a handsome man who had spent 10 years in the Navy, he is portrayed here by Toby Jones as a malevolent dwarf obsessed with gambling. Anachronistically, but for dramatic purposes, he is shown as a member of the House of Commons (William did threaten to stand for the Commons once; his father George III bought him off with a Dukedom, remarking "I well know it is one more vote added to the opposition.").It is true, however that he opposed abolition, having West Indian sugar interests himself..

The role of Wilberforce's old school friend, the child prodigy Prime Minister William Pitt (who became PM at 24), played with feline charm by Benedict Cumberbatch is rather intriguing. Publicly, Pitt had to be very cautious on the slavery issue, but he and Wilbers are shown as very matey indeed in private, running around the lawn together in their underwear. The effect of casting stud-muffin Ioan Gryffud as Wilbers leads the viewer to wonder whether they might be something more than just good mates – something they may have missed back in Boulder, Colorado.

There are lots of fine performances here including Nicholas Farrell as Wilber's cousin Henry Thornton, Rufus Sewell as Thomas Clarkson, Michael Gambon as Charles James Fox, and especially Albert Finney as John Newton, the ex-slaver turned Evangelical Anglican priest and composer of hymns. (He not only wrote "Amazing Grace" but also "Glorious Things of Thee are Spoken" which somehow finished up with Haydn's music for "Deutschland uber Alles").

Wilberforce in fact only got to first base in the abolition of slavery; his 1807 Act merely prevented transportation of slaves in British ships. It was not until the year of his death 1833, some time after he had retired from public life, that slavery was abolished (more or less) in the British Empire. The British taxpayer picked up the tab to compensate the slave owners for the loss of their property - 20 million pounds (at least a billion in today's money). The slaves got nothing.
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Truly Moving Picture
tollini14 October 2006
I saw this film on October 10th, 2006 in Indianapolis. I am one of the judges for the Heartland Film Festival's Truly Moving Picture Award. A Truly Moving Picture "…explores the human journey by artistically expressing hope and respect for the positive values of life." Heartland gave that award to this film.

This is an inspiring story based on a legendary historical British Member of Parliament, William Wilberforce. During the late 18th century and early 19th century, a very young Wilberforce is elected to Parliament and over the course of several decades leads the fight to ban slavery.

Today this seems like an easy, obvious and intuitive decision. But this was not so 200 years ago. The film clearly explains the entrenched economic motives and the political motives for slavery. Wilberforce starts out as almost a force of one and slowly builds abolitionist momentum by brilliant oratory, political maneuvers, and appealing to his fellow man's better nature.

Ioan Gruffudd is totally believable in explaining to the audience the complexity and heroism of Wilberforce. Wilberforce over the course of his life is sickly and strong, religious and worldly, naive and romantic, and idealistic and practical.

During the course of this mostly political story, we get to see the immense cruelty shown to the captured Africans turned into slaves. We are shown the slave sailing ships where the captured are treated inhumanely and die of starvation, neglect, disease, and filth. Man's inhumanity to man was never worse.

Wilberforce is a great man of history even though mostly forgotten today. He respected his fellow man regardless of their station in life. He was always willing to sacrifice his life and health to help others. And his compassion and spirit was always masked by his humility. He is a hero for all ages.

This is a period piece and you are lost in it because of the attention to detail. The sets, art direction, and costumes allow you to totally suspend disbelief and be moved by the story.

FYI – There is a Truly Moving Pictures web site where there is a listing of past Truly Moving Picture Award winners that are now either at the theater or available on video.
209 out of 236 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Great story, well told
vandergraafn218 September 2006
This is a lovely, moving and intelligent film. I did not detect any notably weak performances among a remarkable cast. The older actors though, Michael Gambon and Albert Finney, were shameless scene stealers, but one can hardly fault them for their excellence. There were many things to like about this film. It was gorgeous to look at, brilliantly capturing the look and sound of a sumptuous age. The pacing and editing were fine, though the device using flashbacks for most of the film occasionally led to a moments confusion about when a scene was supposed to be taking place. And the story itself is quite inspirational. A note for my Canadian readers and the Canadians who attended the TIFF screenings. The film mostly covered the struggle to outlaw slavery in Britain itself, though they did touch on Wilberforce's efforts to have it outlawed throughout the British Empire. This continued in the years after the conclusion of the film, and a Bill to do just that was passed in 1833, a month after Wilberforce died. So the film we watched was very much about our own history, and the story of the abolition of slavery in Britain directly affected the eventual abolition of slavery in Canada.
139 out of 156 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Inspiring but inaccurate
Sophie-324 February 2007
To see this well mounted but simplistic and worshipful bio-pic, one would think that William Wilberforce (and to a lesser extent, young Mr. Pitt) were the only members of Parliament to speak out against the war with America, then against the slave trade. Not so, folks - next time you're in Westminster Abbey, you might check out the large abolitionist monument dedicated someone whose fight against the slave trade predated that of Wilberforce and was widely recognized during his liftetime: Charles James Fox.

Yes, that same Fox so inaccurately identified in the film as a tame follower of Wilberforce, agonizing over the slavery question and finally swayed by the young man's eloquence. Truth is, Fox - whose pro-American, pro-French Revolution, anti-slavery and anti-absolute monarchy sentiments put him at odds with George III during nearly his entire political career - was a "phenomenon of the age" in the words of a contemporary, and one of Parliament's most eloquent speakers on a range of causes that certainly rivalled those of Wilberforce.

He was also only 10 years older than Pitt, something you'd never guess from the fright-wig makeup Michael Gambon wears.

You can understand why such scripting decisions are made: Wilberforce has to be young and sexy to be attractive, and his more priggish attitudes (he often urged Parliament to pass laws prohibiting all amusements on Sundays, and was appalled at what he deemed Fox's immorality: his drinking, gambling and womanizing) have to be eliminated. It's a shame, because Wilberforce was all the more interesting for being a complex human - but it's so much easier to make him terribly young, eager and dashing, and all other politicians of the day old and timid.

Other strange egregious errors: Fox was not a lord, nor would you find any lords among Wilberforce's fellows in the House; lords do not sit in the House of Commons. The character identified as the king's son, the Duke of Cumberland, would have been about 12 years old at the time of the movie's action. Pitt was prime minister for some 20 years, yet his cautious political trimming was at least partly responsible for the slave trade continuing as long as it did.

It was a pleasant enough film and rousing in parts, but I prefer my history more red-blooded and reflective of real human beings.
20 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Amazing Inspiration
edavid13 September 2006
Warning: Spoilers
I saw this movie at a special screening, tied in with a sojo.com event to raise awareness of the slavery that still exists today. This strikingly beautiful film tells the true story of William Wilberforce (played with a graceful dignity by Ioan Gruffudd), who, after a struggle that took half his life, led the movement to abolish slavery in England, and stirred the same sentiments that led to America's Civil War.

It's difficult to tell a story about a long, difficult struggle without losing the allegiance of the audience, especially when the topic is politics.

Steven Knight's script helps by including a love story, colorful supporting characters and strong religious undertones (with a brilliant performance by Albert Finney playing the slave-trader turned hymn writer John Newton), and Michael Apted's socially conscious style keeps this film from becoming "Mr. Wilberforce Goes to London" by continually reminding us of the brutality of the slave trade upon which Empire is always built.

The final shot of the film (pre credits) is a freeze frame of Ioan Gruffudd's face as he has finally won, perhaps a nod to transcendental style, where the main character, after great spiritual suffering, is granted an epiphany or beatification, becoming a religious icon for us to meditate upon and, through which, we can glimpse God.
14 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Moving period drama
colin-5095 February 2007
I was well impressed with Amazing Grace; the period was superbly captured, and the interplay of the main action (the fight of William Wilberforce to abolish British slavery) with the other great events of his time (the American and French revolutions) was well presented. The film stirs the emotions but informs the mind. Ioan Gruffudd as Wilberforce is believable and depicts the tenacious Yorkshire MP with both his bodily weakness and great spirit well. Albert Finney as John Newton renders a moving portrayal of the ex-slave trader turned evangelical minister who influences Wilberforce's decision to remain in politics rather than entering the ministry of the church. Benedict Cumberbatch gives a strong representation of William Pitt, and the overall impression of the film is one whose history has been well researched. Well worth a viewing.
85 out of 99 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
An Interesting Ride
AgentCool28 March 2007
'Amazing Grace' is not what you might expect from a film about the trans-Atlantic slave trade. Unlike previous productions such as 'Roots', this film concentrates on the man widely held to be the driving force behind the abolition of the trade. I personally haven't read enough about William Wilberforce to know whether or not his characterisation is presented accurately (despite the fact I live in the city he was a Member of Parliament for) but, faithful or not, it is sympathetically done and never goes overboard.

Much is made of Wilberforce's personal life and, thankfully, most of it is directly relevant to the overarching narrative meaning there are no scenes that seem unnecessary or dull. Even the numerous scenes of Parliament manage to hold interest by shying away from long protracted speeches whilst remaining entirely convincing. By doing this, Wilberforce is portrayed as a master of debate, a headstrong and determined radical fighting an uphill battle against the vast majority of his political peers whilst at the same time struggling with some personal demons.

'Amazing Grace' is not a typically mainstream piece but the strategic coinciding of its release with the 200th anniversary of the abolition of the slave trade should see it attracting a fair bit of curious interest. As a motion picture, it is also well deserving of such an audience. It's a moderately slight work, never really delving too deep into the issues at hand but this is undoubtedly beneficial to its ultimate widespread appeal. This film could safely be shown to school-children who would no doubt get a lot out of it and I would recommend anybody with an interest in world history to take a look at what is essentially a biopic of one of the key figures behind the practical realisation of "all men being treated equal".
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Saw this at Toronto Film Festival!
pharaohs_kitty16 September 2006
Ioan Gruffudd in Amazing Grace, Michael Apted's new masterpiece - what can I say? The man delivered his usual brilliant performance. What made this one better than all the rest? Why do I think Oscar when I think of his part? Every moment he was on screen drew you deeper and deeper into identifying with William Wilberforce until at the end, when he finally achieves his life's work, you want to clap right along with the people applauding him on screen! When he suffers, you suffer right along with him. From the wry twist of his lips to the pain and devastation in his eyes to the fervent body language as he makes point after impassioned point, you are right there living Wilberforce's life.

The most charming parts were fodder provided by the fabulous screen writing and brought to electric life by Ioan Gruffudd as impassioned Wilberforce, Benedict Cumberpatch as driven and farseeing William Pitt, P.M., Romola Garai as Wilberforce's zesty and feisty wife Barbara and the surprisingly fantastic delivery by Jeremy Swift as Ioan's long-suffering wise butler. Jeremy has a way of delivering a comic line with a punch to your chest that bursts into laughter! Benedict and Ioan have clear chemistry as friends with a vision for the future. You can't help but believe these two would choose to be brothers if they could. But the best and most connected relationship was between Ioan as Wilberforce and Romola as his wife. You could feel the way they were already together even while their characters were still protesting on screen.

Michael Apted riveted the audience, bringing to life politics in a way that made you wish you could run out and find a cause of your own to champion. Again, I say Oscar. I have rarely attended a movie where the audience clapped to the point of hurting their fingers with the thunder they were creating for so bloody long! Entirely throughout the actor credits the audience applauded, only varying the volume for those performances they particularly appreciated. Ioan Gruffudd, Benedict Cumberpatch, Romola Garai, Jeremy Swift, Michael Gambon, and Albert Finney.

All in all, a tour de force movie that should impact everyone with the IMPORTANCE of trying to change that which is NOT RIGHT.

Congratulations to everyone who worked on Amazing Grace. Truly, wonder was on screen today.
147 out of 177 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
One man's determined fight to abolish the slave trade
vinsond218 June 2008
As one who is well-versed in history and politics, i had little problem following this story of a British parliamentarian's fight to abolish the slave trade. But i really wonder about others in the audience, especially the many without any background knowledge to the characters and the events of the day. The writers of this film seem to assume that the audience is either already familiar with the story or that the audience is just happy to watch without understanding the story. If that is so, then this movie is seriously handicapped.

Other than the very dry dialog and characters who pop up without any helpful introduction, the movie is however gorgeously photographed. The acting is excellent throughout, with Albert Finney particularly standing out in the supporting role of John Newton, the man behind the hymn Amazing Grace.

I would advise audiences to at least get a little background knowledge of William Wilberforce and British history of that period (around 1780 to 1830) before viewing this film. Such preparation will go a long way towards enhancing your enjoyment of this movie.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The redemption story of something terrible into something beautiful
kwojciec24 January 2007
I had the pleasure this past week of seeing a pre-screening outside of Washington, D.C. of the movie Amazing Grace, starring Reed Richards...err...Ioan Gruffudd as William Wilberforce – the famous British Christian politician that helped end the slave trade in Great Britain in the early 18th Century. The movie progresses through Wilberforce's life from about the time he begins his crusade against the slave trade in Parliament in his early 20's to the time it is eventually abolished. Everything in between is composed of all the hardships, victories, and relationships he goes through in the meantime. At some points the story can be a bit yawn inducing, but the film consistently seems to add just the right amount of humor or political intrigue to keep it afloat (more on the pacing below). There is a love interest Barbara, played by the quite attractive and dynamic Romola Garai, who keeps Mr. Fantastic...err...Wilberforce on track and encouraged. You get the feeling he would've never made it through the hard times without her (which is probably the case for most successful men as they say). The film does delve into evils of the slave trade, but it doesn't focus specifically on it, much like Amistad did focus on it. It seems to keep the main goal in mind, abolishing that heinous evil. This gives the film a "glass half full" feeling instead of a "glass half empty" one. You find yourself cheering for the good guys instead of seeking the heads of the bad ones.

You may be thinking they should've just called this film "Amistad: The Prequel", but that would do it a great disservice. Where Amistad succeeded in many ways such as exposing the horror of the slave trade in much more visual and visceral detail and containing great acting by Djimon Hounsou and Anthony Hopkins, I feel you ultimately left the theater not really feeling much better about anything. In fact, I'd say you may have left if feeling worse, maybe even shameful and/or guilty. Amazing Grace doesn't feel like that. In fact, it's not even really a "feel good" movie; it transcends that status. It's really a "do good" movie. You almost feel personal empowerment from the story, like you want to go out and change some social injustice yourself! Sure, we don't all have the political clout of a William Wilberforce, but we do have a voice. And I think that's why Amazing Grace stands above previous "social injustice" films like it. It feels organic instead of static. It feels like it could apply to today instead of some time long forgotten. It also appeals to everyone; black, white, or whoever. One African-American in the audience mentioned how he was impressed and encouraged at how passionate these white men were for the plight of the slaves. You also realize that slavery wasn't just an American problem, it was a world problem; which further emphasized the fact that the social injustice we see today isn't just a "fill_in_the_blank" problem, it's a world problem.

I'm not knowledgeable enough to comment very much on the technical aspects of this film, but don't let the religious overtones fool you into thinking this is another technical mess like so many in the past. It is on par with any period film of its kind from Hollywood in almost every way; acting, set design, costume design, story, etc.

One thing I found a drawback to it was its pacing though. It starts off fairly tepid, and though it builds up, it seems to go through a cycle of building up and then falling back down again. This could ultimately be a good thing though, because if you can keep your focus throughout the film, you'll be in for a very powerful ending that evokes positive emotions you didn't think you had, and I think the cyclic nature of the film's progress enhances the fulfillment the ending provides. I also found the time period jumping around within the film to be a bit confusing at some points; like some scenes I didn't know if they were in the past or present.

The representative at the screening said the movie would be playing on about 850 screens nationwide on its opening weekend (Feb. 23). Though this is small compared to most major movies, it is a pretty good amount for a smaller movie like this. I recommend going to see it if you're interested in a movie with depth, passion, character, goodness, virtue, and victory. Does it entertain? Sure. But it seems to do a little more also. You can't say that about too many movies these days. You won't leave wishing you had that $8.50 back.

In case you're wondering about the title, John Newton, the composer of the famous hymn 'Amazing Grace', (played powerfully by Albert Finney), was a contemporary and friend of William Wilberforce. John Newton was also a reformed ex-slave trader.
89 out of 105 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Dumbed down and PC
spencerc22171 April 2019
Warning: Spoilers
It is good that a film was made about this great man. Unfortunately it succumbs to political correctness by downplaying the religious motive of Wilberforce's campaigns, most especially against slavery. Having gone thru a conversion experience in his twenties, he was an evangelical Christian belonging to the Clapham Sect, who here are depicted merely as a group of friends. They were far more than that. Further the film, as is the current fashion, is dumbed down. Thus the magnificent oration praising Wilberforce in the House of Commons when it has finally, after almost twenty years of struggle, enacted the bill outlawing the slave trade, is reduced to the level of a fourth grader. To hear the actual oration, and part of Wilberforce's speech first proposing abolition of the trade many years before, watch on You Tube the far, far superior BBC The Fight Against Slavery, a six part series broadcast in the late 1970s. Everything in this is scrupulously accurate history, as I learned in the reading it promoted me to undertake. It is the most outstanding tv mini-series I have ever seen.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Disappointing
Sailor-213 April 2007
I can't agree with the many commentators who found this a great movie. It isn't.

I think many viewers confuse Wilberforce the man with the movie.

I have nothing but admiration for Wilberforce, a man with a powerful moral vision and great determination, who spent 15 years persuading his fellow parliamentarians to do the right thing and abolish the slave trade.

The movie does not measure up to the man.

The movie is nothing but a collection of pretty period scenes and idiosyncratic actions. None of the characters are developed in any depth. There is not a strong story line, moving inexorably from the beginning to the end of the sage. The story, such as it is, hops confusingly back and forth in time, to no particular purpose. There are scatterings of little vignettes, which add nothing. The script is dreadful.

The acting is fine, if frequently overdone. I particularly enjoyed the portrayal of Pitt the Younger.

The costuming, art direction and photography are fine, but do not redeem the film.

Too bad. Wilberforce deserves better.
20 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Amazing Movie
pkallestad200214 February 2007
This is a truly inspiring film that has much more than what appears on the surface. William Wilberforce was a man that understood persistance for change. He was a real World Changer that never knew the quit.

The film was beautifully done and the script was fantastic!! I love many of the phrase pulled from actual accounts of Wilberforce and Pitt's life.

Albert Finney does an amazing job as John Newton. He truly stole the show on this film.

Hollywood needs to pay attention and make more positive and moving films like this one!!!! Great Job.
140 out of 170 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
An exceptional film about an exceptional man
Bart_OP26 February 2007
What follows is the text of a letter I composed for my parish bulletin (I am a priest and pastor of a University Parish in Tucson) after having seen Amazing Grace. I often recommend movies to my parishioners, but seldom write a full-fledged review. This weekend I made an exception for an exceptional movie.

Dear Friends,

It is a movie-lovers' favorite weekend: Oscar weekend. So I beg your indulgence as I offer not just a movie recommendation, but an actual review of the remarkable movie I saw on Friday. I had been hearing about it for several weeks and looking forward to its opening in Tucson. "Amazing Grace" tells the story of William Wilberforce, a young American Revolution era British Parliamentarian who waged a three-decade legislative battle to end Great Britain's involvement in the African slave trade (Slavery was outlawed in England six decades before our civil war.) Among those who had influenced this remarkable Englishman was John Newton, the slave ship captain turned evangelical preacher, who penned the lyrics of arguably the best known sacred song in the world, which also lends its title to the movie. Newton had known Wilberforce as a child and, in the film, serves as his conscience when the task is unclear or proves daunting..

This is no schmaltzy feel-good biopic. Everything about it is compelling. It is beautifully written and directed. The cinematography and film-editing are superb. The costume and sets are exquisite. And the acting is top-notch. Ioan Gruffudd, the young Welchman best known for his excellent portrayal of C.S. Forester's seafaring hero, Horatio Hornblower, in eight made-for-A&E movies (1998-2003), brings great depth and passion to his portrayal of this complex hero of social justice. Gruffudd's star is on the rise. Award–winning actor, Albert Finney, graces this picture as an aged and eccentric Newton. The cast is rounded out by a gaggle of veteran British character actors who lend profundity to this compelling story. In addition to the cinematic elements that make this one of the few movies I have seen that I consider to be worth the $9 it costs to see a movie these days, it is first-rate storytelling! And Wilberforce is a hero whose story must be told. He grappled with one of my favorite issues: the place of faith in public life. As a young man, the rising political star began to rediscover an intense faith that had lain dormant for a time. His fire of conviction that something must be done about the slave trade was fueled by this reemerging faith. As he struggled with whether he should use his oratorical talents a politician or a preacher, he is convinced that he can use his popularity as an MP to do God's work by actively advocating for the voiceless slaves. The movie presents the story of a man who finds a perfect balance between his faith and his public life—each shaping the other in the face of a clear vocation. That his secular realm is that of politics and the time is one of great fear and institutionalized injustice gives this period movie much relevance in today's world. I hope every person of faith watches this movie. I especially think that it is pertinent for our student parishioners who may be struggling with the same issues as Wilburforce. (While I fear it would bore younger children, it would be good for older children and teens.) It opened on Friday at the El Con Cinema. I will be organizing a parish outing to see "Amazing Grace" in a couple of weeks. Whether you go then or another time, I recommend this movie as a great Lenten exercise. I loved it and consider it one of the most socially relevant films I've ever seen. "Amazing Grace" has long been one of my favorite sacred songs, but I will never hear it the same again.

Peace, Fr. Bart
76 out of 91 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
excellent movie
maridesadvincula17 September 2006
Warning: Spoilers
I felt like clapping from beginning to end as i watched this excellent movie. Everything about it was praiseworthy -- screenplay, cinematography, editing, costumes, acting, directing -- all in all an excellent storytelling that befits a story that needs to be told. I highly recommend it. I watched it at the Toronto International Film Festival on September 16, 2006 and i can hardly wait to see it again when it is finally released in theaters sometime in February 2007, and i will definitely buy the DVD for my own personal library.

I would give this movie a 99% rating. There's 1 single item though that spoiled it for me and i don't know whether the version to be released in theaters and DVDs would have this scene. I felt that the final scene where the song "Amazing Grace" was played was anti-climactic. Best to just end the movie with the members of parliament and observers in the gallery clapping for William Wilberforce, best to just end it on a high and positive note.
9 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Short on substantial worth...
sinncross25 June 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Years after failing to convince parliament to adopt an anti-slavery act, abolitionist, William Wilberforce (Ioan Gruffudd), tells the story of events leading to his loss in parliament to Barbara Spooner (Romola Garai). After the story Barbara convinces William to again take a stand in parliament to abolish the slave trade once and for all in Britain.

The story itself is simplistic, and from the outset the ending of the story is apparent. While the intrigue is gone it is somewhat expected considering that the story is an expose of sorts. The problem with the film is the fact that the hardships that slaves are forced to bear are never shown, but only talked about. This causes the viewer to become more attached to the perspective of those pro-slavery opinionated, many of whom did not know about the terrible conditions of the slaves. Another aspect is that of Wilberforce: it's difficult for one to truly sympathize with his position. We are shown how greatly affected by slavery he is, and how the thought of it makes him sick, but without clear visual evidence, the viewer is never given the chance to feel his disgust. While an obvious attempt to keep the age restriction down to allow for more universality, it does still hurt the experience.

Sadly, another weak element is the acting. It is by no means terrible, but the overall cast seldom act with much vigor. There are signs of potential where the actors raise the bar of their performances, but this is never the common and as as whole, never links the capable acting abilities together. Gruffudd does deserve some recognition, for he is the only actor who shows real passion - if only it were consistent from beginning to end.

The overall atmosphere is quite pleasing, as the environment and especially the costumes are in keeping with the times in which the film is set. Though the sets are nothing of spectacle, the film must be commended for not trying to over-glamourise the costume designs, and alienate the films realism and contained meaning.

Amazing Grace is a film which should be watched by many, so that all can know of the hard work that went into getting rid of slavery in Britain. But the subtleness of the film proves useless in getting its main concern about the wrongness of slavery across and the actors don't help either. It lacks real substance, but Amazing Grace is still a watchable history lesson.

--- Also available on Entertainment.Wikia ---
4 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
a must see film
annplatz3 February 2007
I saw Amazing Grace on Thursday at a private showing. The film has everything that I love about theater...passion, conflict, struggle, faith, redemption and grace. The story is true... making this film one of reality and substance. The struggle to rid the world of slavery has been a black mark against humanity. The British are to be applauded as the leaders in this journey to freedom. The actors' performances were incredible. Albert Finney's portrayal of John Newton is an Oscar possibility. The scenes were period and perfection. Even the dark mood of the times were reflected in the lighting and how the director portrayed the message of bondage. Go see this film...acquaint yourself with this powerful story and this man William Wilberforce. I rate it a 10!
68 out of 84 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
It's nice to see a well done PG movie
byro050223 February 2007
Like I said: it's great to see a PG movie that is not aimed at 10 year-olds. The movie was inspiring, touching, and surprisingly not filled with opinions from either wing.

The movie doesn't need to be violent to touch the audience's hearts, after all we have been taught about slavery and how terrible and brutal it really was. This point doesn't need to be driven home in this particular movie like Schindler's List did for the Holocaust. Descriptions are powerful enough in this film, and we are left to only hear about the terrible tragedies just as the naive and sheltered British parliament were forced to do.

But the story isn't necessarily about the issue of slavery. It's about perseverance and faith. Yeah, that's right, I said faith. There's a well done movie that incorporates faith in a very realistic and admirable way.

I didn't want to see the movie. I just tagged along. I didn't care to see another touching Hollywood movie meant to make me ask myself what's wrong with the world, but when it was over, I was touched. I was impressed. And I was entertained. Not bad.
4 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Most Amazing Movie I have ever seen. It is highly recommended to all.
EmmyRoseXox30 September 2006
This movie was the most amazing movie I have ever seen. I think that it is an empowering movie to be seen by all. Just the shear magnitude of emotion that is seen on the screen by not only Ioan Gruffard, but the entire cast.

If you did not get the chance to watch it at the Toronto Film Festival, then I highly suggest that you see it when it comes out in theatre.

After attending the Toronto Film Festival and hearing the Director speak about this movie, I know that this movie is not meant to be only the normal entertaining movie, it is also meant to be a lesson, a tale to be understood and appreciated by many.
89 out of 134 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"Grace" is good, not "Amazing"
filmfan9210 March 2007
"Amazing Grace", the new film from director Michael Apted (who is, in my opinion, the most overrated director in Hollywood) saves the best for last. In fact, the scene that I can't get out of my head appears as an after-credits coda. In the scene, a bagpipe band launches into an instrumental rendition of the title song. Slowly, the camera zooms out, and drums, trumpets, and strings are added, until, as last, an entire parade of musicians are on screen playing "Amazing Grace". Then slowly, the camera pans up to Westminister Abbey, David Arnold's score swells, and we fade to black. It is a moment of genius in a film that lacks flavor. Admittedly, after a season of edgy, complex awards films, a movie that deals in morals seems tame (almost refreshingly so), by comparison. This film is well-written, and filled with classy actors and a superb crew. But somewhere along the road from script to screen, something went awry. The main problem is Ioan Gruffud. He has more than proved himself as an excellent supporting actor ("King Arthur), but he has also shown ("Fantastic Four") that he is not yet ready to assume leading-man status. He shows it again here, with an uneven performance that doesn't really get at the heart of his character, William Wilberforce, a young British politician who spent his life trying to abolish the slave trade. All movies, especially biopics, fall apart without a strong center. Another major problem is simply that Apted is trying to fit three or four movies into one. He clumsily tries to juggle Wilberforce's story, the rise and fall of ailing British prime minister Billy Pitt (Benedict Cumberbatch), and the story of John Newton, a former slave ship captain who wrote the final ballad (Albert Finney, whose great performance deserved its own film). Somewhere along the line, the horrible decision was made to tell this already confusing, name-filled story out of sequence-narrated by an older Wilberforce to his wife Barbara (Romola Garai). Toby Jones and the great Ciaran Hinds are sadly typecast as upper-lip English villains who's simplicity is an insult to their talent. Michael Gambon and Rufus Sewell are serviceable in their bit parts, but the true breakout star of this film is Youssou N'Dour. N'Dour appears for maybe seven or eight minutes, but he plays the part of a freed slave with such heartbreaking brilliance that he runs away with the whole show. Also deserving special mention are David Arnold's Oscar-worthy score and Jenny Beavan's sumptuous costume design. "Amazing Grace" is not the uplifting epic that it has been promoted as, but it is a feel-good period piece that is slightly above the dung that the studios normally put out in the dead zone between winter and summer.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The film was both a touching and thought-provoking call to action.
wichitagirl15 March 2007
Warning: Spoilers
This was a magnificent film -- touching and thought-provoking on multiple levels. There were times when Wilberforce felt like giving up the battle, but the film is truly a story of perseverance and willingness to press through the raucous voices of dissent with a clear voice of what is right. The scenes with John Newton were so well done, with "reach for the tissue" moments, empathy and joy being among the emotions experienced by the moviegoer. The facial expressions throughout the film helped the moviegoer identify with the various characters; the casting was exquisite. I don't think if you're even minimally inclined to stand up for something you believe in that you can help but be stirred by the passion in this film. I do think we must see the ugliness of wrong and the repugnance of what one man can do to another in the name of economics and personal comfort almost as a preface to involvement. The symbolism of what one individual can do was wonderfully displayed in this amazing film.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Somewhat-Good Grace, not Amazing.
IgMasterW2 March 2007
So I think the movie needs to be called "Somewhat-Good Grace" because the movie left me with a bland taste in my mouth. I have to admit I didn't really follow the characters very well, my bad. I guess it was mainly because I thought two separate characters were the same guy... I mean Daddy Warbucks and Dumbledore look the same right? Well it took me until the last scene to realize they were two totally different men. And because of this the movie was even more bland.

Well, despite (or in spite) of my lack of character understanding I really think the director and writers of this film had a much bigger story to work with and decided upon the one which would sell best to the mainstream, white Christian viewers. Boring, boring, boring. The historical, period piece was so typical and wasn't even filmed that wonderfully. I was really frustrated during the first few minutes of the film because I thought people were walking in front of the projector. Low and behold it wasn't the theater's fault, but the directors. He had servants and messengers walking in front of the camera. Perhaps this was to subconsciously reinforce the notion of aristocracy and a class based society, but I don't know.

When I picture this movie in my mind I see something more along the lines of The Red Violin, Crash, or Amores Los Peros. It could have been as good as all of those. Something with multiple story lines all happening at once, culminating in the words of the song being expressed. Think of how moving it would be to watch the composer begin to write the words, watch the politician fight the words, watch a slave live the words, and maybe throw in another example of the words being passed on to another. This would be so much more amazing than what we were given.

Alas, the acting was OK. Nothing worthy of great kudos, and yes there were some moving brief moments in the story, but all in all I felt the movie was bland, typical, and while the story was good, it didn't flex it's cinematic muscles enough to be a work of art.
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
This is painted over British version of Wilberforce read the comment for the truth
ddelsol30 March 2007
The movie Amazing Grace purports to tell the story of the single white man who 'saved' poor passive Africans from the vicious degradations the British were inflicting upon them. Africans themselves play little part in this movie. Olaudah Equiano who was kidnapped at the age of 10, forced into slavery, freed himself, fought for the British, wrote a best-selling autobiography and tirelessly campaigned against slavery, and in many ways was the father of the modern trade unionist movement in his bringing together the industrial working class and urban artisans of the time, gets a meagre four minutes on screen. There are however a number of key facts that have been entirely left out of Mr Wilberforce's 'official' story, or painted over. Wilberforce was not a life- long activist. He only became involved in the anti- slavery movement when sent in by Prime Minister William Pitt. William Pitt was engaged in the buying of Africans for forced recruitment into the West India Regiment, which was then used to suppress African uprisings, after which the soldiers were released back to Africa to engage in further wars against other Africans. Wilberforce opposed the Haitian revolution. Toussaint L'Ouverture and tens of thousands of Africans fought for their freedom from 1791-1804, but Wilberforce did not approve of Africans establishing their own freedom and actually voted to send British troops to put down the rebellion and maintain slavery. The Haitians ultimately emerged victorious to become the first independent black nation in the 'New World'.Wilberforce was not against cruelty to Black people. He suggested that blacks should only be whipped at night, as this was better for production. He was also an advocate for Black men being put to work in breeding farms. Slave breeding farms became more popular after the slave trade abolition (1807), which meant an increase in rapes of African girls and Women and more forced pregnancies and abortions. Wilberforce was a drug addict (opium) and a frequent user of brothels. At this time, many African women were forced to work in brothels in England as the English pimps could make more money from them. Wilberforce was against women's movements to end the slave trade. In 1824 when Elisabeth Heyrich published a pamphlet calling for immediate freedom, rather than welcoming her support, Wilberforce denounced her "as such things were not the concern of women". He also did not wish women to have the vote.Wilberforce did not want immediate freedom for African people but thought it should be phased in over decades. Hence his comments - "If we can prevent the planter buying more slaves the only way he will be able to increase his stock is with the sons and daughters of the slaves he already has. When members and friends of the African and Asian Society dined at a tavern in 1816,with Wilberforce in the chair, the token Africans and Asians invited to the gathering were separated from the other guests by a screen set across one end of the room Wilberforce promoted missionary work When he retired from his campaigning, Wilberforce became heavily involved in training missionaries. The Christian faith was heavily involved in the slave trade, which prompted the recent apology
21 out of 45 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed