- Rebecca's estranged sister, Susan Howe, is in Boston to shoot a commercial. She's an actress specializing in horror movies. She stops by the bar in the off chance that Rebecca might want to see her. Rebecca doesn't. Sam finds out that much of the sisterly discord is from the Susan stealing Rebecca's boyfriends when they were younger. Sam uses this information in his attempt to bed both sisters. He tells Susan that Rebecca and he are an item, after which she agrees to go out with him. He tells Rebecca that Susan is interested in him, to which Rebecca replies that to get back at Susan, Sam should break off their date and Rebecca would go out with him in Susan's place. So Sam postpones his date with Susan to take out Rebecca, with his date with Susan now later in the evening. However Susan can't wait and appears at the same time Sam is supposed to go out with Rebecca. Sam has to try and manage his dates with both sisters without the other finding out.—Huggo
- Sam is surprised when a woman named Susan arrives in the bar looking for Rebecca. It is soon revealed further that she is Rebecca's sister, as well as a B-movie actress, who Woody recognizes from a horror movie.
The idea of know that Rebecca has a sister entices Sam, but he soon gets an earful when he finds out that both Susan and Rebecca are not that chummy, due to Susan having stolen several of Rebecca's previous boyfriends.
Sam then attempts to play off this, and convinces Susan that Rebecca likes him. When Susan shows an interest in him, Sam then goes to Rebecca, and tells her that Susan likes him. Rebecca then makes a deal with Sam: break off the date with Susan, and he can go out with her (Rebecca).
Sam secretly tells the guys at the bar about his plan: he first intends to go on a date with Rebecca, then has one later that night scheduled with Susan. The guys leave the bar in high spirits to hear how Sam's date night went.
Minutes after closing the bar and waiting for Rebecca, Susan shows up, and attempts to seduce Sam in his office. As she does so, Rebecca shows up, and seeing Susan with Sam, pulls a gun out of her desk drawer! Susan pleads for mercy, but the gun goes off, and her body crumples to the floor as Sam looks on in shock! Rebecca fires several more shots, before demanding Sam help her dispose of the body.
Sam does so, but is shocked when he finds the other members of Cheers behind the bar. Sam attempts to explain, but is shocked when Susan begins talking again. It soon turns out that it was all a prank set up between the two sisters. Sam is upset that he has been made the butt of a practical joke, but the two Howe sisters tell him that they are grateful that he managed to bring them together after years of bickering. When Sam asks 'how grateful' they are, they turn away from his last attempt to get lucky.
Contribute to this page
Suggest an edit or add missing content