"Daniel Boone" The Peace Tree (TV Episode 1965) Poster

(TV Series)

(1965)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Children fix the Problem
gordonl5614 May 2014
Warning: Spoilers
DANIEL BOONE – The Peace Tree -1965

This is the 38th episode of the long running 1964-70 series about the life of American frontiersman and explorer, Daniel Boone. The lead is played by Fess Parker. Also in the mix are, Ed Ames, Patricia Blair, Veronica Cartwright and Darby Hinton. This episode is from season two, which was the first season to be filmed in colour.

Daniel Boone (Fess Parker) is cutting some firewood when he is paid a visit by his friend, Cherokee scout, Mingo. (Ed Ames) Ames would like Parker to speak to a group of settlers from Scotland. The Highlanders have decided to set up homes on Cherokee land. This of course would negate the peace treaty and bring war.

Parker has a chat with the leader of the Scottish, Liam Redmond. Redmond sees no reason to ask "savages" for permission to settle. If the Cherokee want war, the Highlanders are willing give it to them. Now Parker pays a quick visit to the Cherokee Chief, Nestor Pavia. He asks Pavia for time to get the Scottish to move. Pavia gives him a week.

Needless to say there are side issues at work here. Several of the younger braves decide a spot of war would be fun. They make a raid on the Scots. There are casualties on both sides and a full-fledged battle is barely avoided.

While all this is going on, Parker's son, Darby Hinton, the Chief's son, Larry Domasin, and Redmond's grandson, Peter Oliphant have become friends. They decide to do what they can to prevent any bloodshed. Of course the boys show up the adults for being stupid and the like. Everyone sits down and comes up with a compromise that makes everyone happy.

While a little light in the action department, the episode is still worth a watch.

Veteran director George Sherman handles the reins on this episode. Sherman could do stuff like this in his sleep. He was equally adept at film noir and westerns. The noir, include, LARCENY, THE SLEEPING CITY, SPY HUNT and THE RAGING TIDE. His westerns, include, RELENTLESS, BLACK BART, RED CANYON, COMANCHE TERRITORY, TOMAHAWK, WAR ARROW, DAWN AT SOCORRO, COMANCHE, LAST OF THE FAST GUNS and the John Wayne feature, BIG JAKE. (Colour)
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Before "Outlander"
militarymuseu-8839912 February 2024
A group of apple-growing Scottish Highlanders led by a gruff clan chief (Liam Redmond) move onto Cherokee land, and Daniel must persuade them to take an off-ramp before a general Indian war erupts.

Continuing the previous hour's delving into actual economic detail on Appalachian frontier life, this outing focuses on the role of the Scots-Irish in colonial settlement. And the story is privileged to center Dublin Abbey Theatre alumni and distinguished stage actor Redmond as the Celtic thunder. He marshals the Scottish screen attributes well (for an Irishman!). Also along is B-movie journeyman Nestor Paiva as Cherokee chief Menewa.

The hour starts with high hopes, but rapidly nosedives when the focus is on the interplay between Israel plus a Cherokee and Highlander of his age. Disneyfication quickly sets in and remains; a comparison of the Highlander and Cherokee tribal structures would have been far more interesting.

Plus, the writers would have had a wealth of material to work with. After the initial executions for the failed Scottish 1745 rising at Culloden, the British government hit on the idea of reprieve, swearing of loyalty, and resettlement of Highlanders on the North Carolina frontier. (Depicted well in the later seasons of "Outlander.") For them a bargain at the time that soured; fulfilling their loyalty to the Crown and mustering to join with British forces during the early Revolution, many were decimated by Patriot militia at the 1775 Battle of Moore's Creek, NC.

Not a tremendous amount of action here, and Daniel doesn't do much. Mingo gets to take up his interlocutor role, and we do get a nice tutorial on Highlander settler tradework (though the Highland bonnets look a bit too much 19th century). Redmond carries the screen when deployed, but the writers let Israel and pals take over the hour. Not to any benefit; a strong start with possibilities becomes fairly pedrstrian fairly fast.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed