"The Defenders" Death Across the Counter (TV Episode 1961) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
1 Review
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Over-wrought
schappe113 September 2016
Warning: Spoilers
The third episode of the series hearkens back to the 1957 pilot with father and son arguing about how best to pursue justice. A drug- addled man, (Clu Gulager), has robbed a store and killed the proprietor before being knocked unconscious by the deceased's long- time partner. The Prestons are assigned the case. Lawrence can see their client is an addict. He feels somewhat sorry for him because he became addicted to morphine in the military service. But he's obviously guilty so Lawrence feels the best he can do for his client is to work to get him a reduced sentence.

Kenneth does some digging because he "feels" that the client isn't guilty. he doesn't have anything to go on besides a feeling at first and doesn't wind up with much, either. it turns out the partner gets $10,000 form an insurance policy and is having the ceiling repainted even though that was done only months before. Kenneth believes they should try to get an acquittal.

he and his father have a running argument about this which gets into the issue of how to best serve their client, the theme in the pilot, where the issue was whether to work to get him off by using a courtroom trick to discredit a witness or to try to get him a reduced sentence based on circumstances and sympathy.

The problem here is that the arguments between father and son seem forced, (at one point Lawrence says he might "slap you around").And in the end, Lawrence comes over to Ken's point of view for no apparent reason other than his idealism, which Lawrence says he once had. He then elicits a Perry Mason-like confession from the partner in the courtroom and father and son smile contentedly at each other.

It's a poor execution of a worthy theme.

One other note: The IMDb entry for their episode says it was filmed entirely in New York. I find it interesting that so many actors who were doing episodic television on the west coast appear in this: Gulager, McHugh, Harry Townes as the DA, J. Pat O'Malley, etc. Where are the "new York actors" we later saw all the time in Law & Order? Is it possible this was really shot in LA with some exteriors, (like the opening credit sequence) done in New York?

Check the message board, ("The Real Pilot") for an updated opinion on this episode.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed