"Emergency!" Decision (TV Episode 1972) Poster

(TV Series)

(1972)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Excellent episode
slackersmom27 June 2013
I really like this episode. Roy's "dilemma" was very natural, something I'm sure a lot of paramedics at the time faced at one time or another: for some reason it's not possible to reach the doctor, and action is needed NOW, so what should they do? Roy did what he thought was best based on the situation and on Brackett's instruction (keep patient ventilated), and he did it efficiently and successfully. I think Brackett's advice to Roy was good too; he basically said 'you were right to jump into action without stopping to consider details such as where he was, how far from the hospital, etc.' I've had occasion to say (and think) the same thing that Brackett said: a little amount of fear is healthy, too much will paralyze you. I wonder if that Dr. Sanderson ever apologized to Roy? He should have!

One thing I thought was interesting, though. At the house fire, I'm surprised that both John and Roy didn't go into the house for the boy. Usually in any type of situation in which someone is left in a burning building, both paramedics go in. I think in this case, for the sake of drama the writers had just Roy go in. It worked for this episode, but I don't think it was the usual practice during the run of the show.

Also, since when does the ambulance driver just stick an antenna on top of the ambulance in such a slap-dash manner?? Another contrivance that never usually happens, but which was done for dramatic effect in this episode. But that's quibbling. :-p

TWO things that were VERY GOOD about this episode!! As the first ep of the 2nd season, it marks the first appearance of our beloved Cap'n Stanley. He got no big introduction, no fanfare, and in fact I don't think he was even referred to by name, but it was great to see him. Oh, and the new firetruck, too!

The 2nd thing I liked about this ep was the final scene, of John & Roy driving back to the station in the middle of the night, all disheveled and dirty and sooty from the fire. There's something very attractive about a person (in this case, a man) who's all messy and rumpled from physical exertion. Rawr!! ;-p
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Roy's Problem
mitchrmp18 July 2012
Warning: Spoilers
The DVD actually lists this episode title as "Problem." Either one will work. The focus of this one is on Roy. While transporting a man to the hospital, he has to make a decision and gets chewed out by a doctor for not following protocol. Roy takes it to heart and wonders if he should leave the fire Station. Johnny thinks Roy is crazy to be so broken up about what he did. Even Dr. Bracket and Dixie think he made the right decision!

This is a good episode because we get to see the support Roy has. We really get to see a new element to Roy's character - how he CARES, something we don't always see so much of in the health care professionals. Roy, of course, makes the right decision and all turns out okay. Of course, Roy is in the spot light as he saves a child from the burning building.

Another thing that really stuck out to me in this episode is the look on Johnny's face when he realizes the safety rope was burned in half and Roy was in the burning building on his own. The Chief has to stop Johnny from rushing in there to his partner's rescue. This was such great acting!
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed