"The Four Just Men" The Village of Shame (TV Episode 1959) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Murder by Drowning
gordonl5631 May 2013
Warning: Spoilers
FOUR JUST MEN – "The Village Of Shame" – 1959

This is the third episode of the 1959-60 series, THE FOUR JUST MEN. The series stars, Richard Conte, Jack Hawkins, Vittorio De Sica and Dan Dailey. They are all part of a group out to fight injustice throughout the world. In each episode one of the four men is the featured player. This episode is centered on Jack Hawkins.

Hawkins gets a phone call from an old Army friend. A mutual friend they both served with has died. There might be something not kosher with the death. Hawkins grabs a plane to the south of France to investigate. Landing in Toulon, he heads out to a small village on the Mediterranean coast.

The village constable, Arthur Gomez, tells Hawkins that his friend had went swimming and drowned. It was ruled an accident. Hawkins knows this is not likely, as his friend was deathly afraid of water. He never went swimming.

Hawkins knows something is off here. The more inquires he makes the more hostility he gets from the locals. Malou Pantera, the hostess at the local bistro, tells Hawkins that everyone is wary of strangers. There had been a large amount of village men shot here during the war for helping Allied fliers escape into Spain. Her own cousin and the Mayor's brother were among those shot by the Gestapo.

Hawkins of course keeps digging into his friend's death. Soon the town mayor, Leo Britt, pays him a visit. Britt asks him to leave town as he is upsetting the townsfolk. No go there as Hawkins intends to solve the case.

A few calls to one of the other, "Four Just Men", Dan Dailey, a newsman stationed in Paris are made. It seems that the mayor's brother is not dead. He is living in Paris. He had escaped the date with the firing squad. Hawkins soon uncovers that it was the mayor, Britt, who had ratted out the village to the Gestapo. He wanted to save his brother from the firing squad. Britt is not all that pleased to have this information made public and tries to silence Hawkins. Britt is unsuccessful in the attempt and is handed over to the police. It seems that Hawkins dead friend had discovered the same info on Britt. Britt had cracked him on the head and dropped him in the sea. (B/W)
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Betrayal and murder
Paularoc19 June 2013
Jack Hawkins as Ben Manfred is the "just man" in this episode. Manfred learns of the death, apparently by drowning, of Austin Smith, a man who he had known during the war. Smith, who had been with the OSS during the war, had a post war job of hunting down Nazi war criminals. Manfred is very suspicious about Smith's drowning death and goes to the small isolated fishing village of St. Paul near Toulon where the death occurred. The locals, including a policeman, the local priest, and the Mayor are very unhappy about Manfred's investigating the death and try to get him to leave. The shame of the village is that during the war the local resistance was betrayed and many of the local fighters were killed. Smith was one of the those that the resistance was trying to smuggle out of the country but because of the betrayal ended up a prisoner of war. The villagers know that it was one of their own who betrayed them but have no idea who it was. A young woman who as a girl during the war had known and liked Smith helps Manfred. Manfred uncovers the name of the betrayer whose motive for this heinous act was understandable (and probably all too common) but still deplorable. Hawkins, as ever, was great in this episode. He had just a strong screen presence and such a distinctive and pleasing voice.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Hunting for a traitor.
Sleepin_Dragon22 January 2023
Ben Manfred attends a small fishing village, investigating the death of Austin Smith, who apparently drowned accidentally, Smith was a Nazi hunter.

The first episode to feature Ben Manfred as The lead, and it's a personal case for him, Smith having been one of his friends, in this case he's chasing after a rat.

It's a very engaging thirty minutes, again I'm so impressed by how much content was crammed into just thirty minutes. A true mystery, with lots of intrigue, you wonder why Manfred is met with such hostility, even the clergy seem vague and unhelpful.

It's worth remembering, that the end of the second World War was just fourteen years before this episode, feelings were very, very strong naturally.

It's very well produced, nicely filmed, and the transfers look terrific, was it made on film?

Jack Hawkins was excellent, I have a feeling I'm going to really enjoy the Ben Manfred episodes.

I think this may have been my favourite so far.

8/10.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An indomitable force (for justice)
lor_10 February 2024
Jack Hawkins makes stellar acting look easy in the episode, a strong statement about "pulling the bandage off" to reveal old war wounds and settle the score for treachery.

In the tiny village of St. Paul near Toulon in France, Hawkins visits after a rickety bike ride to get to the bottom of the murder of an old war buddy turned Nazi hunter. No, he wasn't there hunting Nazis, but instead on the trail of a traitor in the Resistance who finked on his comrades to the Nazis during the occupation.

Everyone in town is against him, but Hawkins cannot be deterred from hunting down the bad man among them. This is such an urbane story, tightly directed with utter class by Basil Dearden, that instead of violence it's a thinking man's litle thriller, loaded with the drollest of humor. Future ace director John Schlesinger gets a "Exterior director" credit, presumably having shot second unit footage to establish the locale before the dialogue scenes were all made in the studio back in England.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Village of Shame
Prismark1022 January 2023
Ben Manfred (Jack Hawkins) is the just man who visits a remote fishing village in France. He had to cycle it there after reaching Toulon.

He wants to know what happened an old friend Austin Smith. He was in the OSS during World War 2. After the war he was hunting down Nazi war criminals and collaborators.

Smith has drowned, but Manfred thinks it was murder. Smith could not swim.

The village has not recovered from the war. It was full of either the Resistance or collaborators. The first man Manfred meets was a man blinded in the war.

The locals are suspicious of Manfred snooping about and some plan to get rid of him.

A good episode as Manfred seemingly ignores his own safety as he conducts his own investigations. The locals are suspicious enough, any one of them could be a hidden collaborator who murdered Smith.

Hawkins brings a lot of style and class.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed