Ricky is sick and tired of being bullied by Brenda, Wart, and David. To make matters worse, Tasha thinks Ricky is a loser and he finds solace in Iris. Ricky decides to get back at Tasha by publishing her phone number as payback for belittling him, but his plan backfires when she publishes Ricky's phone number in the school paper. Ricky soon gets a call from the Creeps and they are revealed to be Brenda, Wart, and David. The trio offers to help Ricky get even with everyone by putting seeds into the cookies to turn everyone into Creeps during a school bake sale. Ricky tries to warn them about the cookies but he changes his mind and he allows the student body eat the cookies, everyone including Ricky are turned into Creeps, much to Iris' shock.