"Gunsmoke" Potato Road (TV Episode 1957) Poster

(TV Series)

(1957)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A Western Horror Story
wdavidreynolds10 January 2022
An excited young man rides into Dodge City and tells Matt Dillon his father has killed someone. Matt and Chester Goode follow the young man, whose name is Budge Grilk (another bizarre John Meston character name), back to the dugout house where the Grilk family lives. (Dugout houses were popular choices for frontier, plains homes because they could be built cheaply and did not require a lot of resources. In a later season, Chester builds his own dugout house with decidedly mixed results. The Grilk house in this story is the same structure that was used for the Season 1 episode, "Smoking Out the Nolans.") Pa Grilk has devised a plan to lure Marshal Dillon to their ramshackle homestead and kill him. Pa thinks with Matt out of the way, the Grilks will then easily ride into Dodge and rob the bank.

Robert F. Simon returns to play another overwrought character in Pa Grilk. He had portrayed another ornery character in the late Season 2 episode "Cheap Labor," but the Pa Grilk character is even more incorrigible and clearly deranged.

Promising young actor Tom Pittman takes on the Budge Grilk character in this story. Pittman had appeared as a sly, young cowboy who outwits Marshal Dillon in Season 1's "Dutch George" episode. Pittman, who reportedly idolized James Dean, was killed in a terrible automobile accident within a few months after this episode was filmed. (Pittman was driving the same model Porsche Dean was driving when he was killed.)

The incredible Jeanette Nolan makes her first Gunsmoke appearance in this episode where she plays Mrs. Grilk. Nolan appeared in eight different Gunsmoke episodes over the run of the series, including portraying the character "Dirty" Sally Fergus in three episodes (one was a two-part episode) in Seasons 16 and 17. The Dirty Sally series featured the same Sally Fergus character and was the only Gunsmoke spin-off series. Nolan is almost unrecognizable in this episode, as her character has clearly suffered extreme abuse from her husband and moves about through the story in a sort of hopeless, cowering despair.

Morgan Woodward -- who would later appear in so many Gunsmoke episodes it almost seemed he was part of the regular cast -- makes his first appearance in the series in a brief scene as a man named Calhoun who is the Grilk's neighbor. This appearance takes place early in Woodward's acting career. His next appearance in the series did not occur until Season 11.

This story is about as close as Gunsmoke gets to a horror entry in the series. The Grilks are deranged and sadistic. For example, there is a scene where Pa is going to shoot Matt and Chester, and Budge calls to his mother, who is inside the house, to come out if she wants to see the killing.

Viewers looking for an uplifting story or a happy conclusion would be advised to skip this entry. The Grilk family is another of those amazingly dark, despairing, hopeless John Meston creations. Meston often created these characters to represent the brutal life of homesteaders who settled on the plains. The ending of this episode is especially sad and dark.

On the other hand, viewers that enjoy this kind of story might also want to check out Season 8's "Phoebe Strunk," Season 9's "No Hands," and especially "The Cabin" - arguably the darkest story in Gunsmoke history - which appears later during the third season.
16 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Terrible people again
LukeCoolHand31 January 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I keep writing reviews that state I have seen the worst, most depraved no morals people, but then have to take it back as in this episode. The mother in this episode has a teen age son and her husband is not his father. The clan has tricked Matt and Chester into coming to their house and then locked them in the cellar. They want to kill Matt and Chester so they can have free reign to rob the bank in Dodge, The father is about to shoot Matt and Chester but the deranged son stops him because he wants him to wait for his mother to come out of the house so she can watch her husband kill Matt and Chester. Crazy people and the worst so far but there is probably worse to come the way it's going.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Chester "Nolan Ryan" Good
jamdifo28 January 2013
Warning: Spoilers
What a great episode! It kept me guessing the whole way thru with a very sad and crazy ending. The family is crazy as we find out for sure when they kill their neighbor, they don't kill Dillon and Chester because they "need to eat and not die on an empty stomach".

Great performances by all the family Jeannette Nolan as Ma, Robert Simon as Pa, and Tom Pittman as Budge (too bad he died at a young age in real life also). Dillon's monologue at the beginning on Boot Hill was so true for this episode. This episode again deals with a man beating his woman, in this case brother in law beating his sister in law.

Chester kills "Pa" just by throwing a rock which hits him in the head. The fact that Chester could throw such a big rock with that accuracy and velocity with a bum leg is amazing. If baseball was around Dodge back then, we would have the Chester Good Award instead of Cy Young for best pitcher.

This is now Chester's 4th confirmed kill and 3rd already in this early of season 3.
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Yes! This woman actually looks like a poor potato farmer's wife.
iluvtv-9884316 April 2022
I LOVE Gunsmoke but find it annoying to see "modern" hairstyles, makeup, etc., on the women performers. Dance hall girls back then didn't have the makeup, eyelashes, and hair styling tools to get those looks. But in this episode, the important female part LOOKS exactly as one would. Jeannette Nolan played this part so well it seems as if we have gone back in time and met a real potato farmer's wife. Everyone portrayed their characters so well. Great early TV; great display of how the West really was.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Interesting for What It Implies
dougdoepke4 August 2011
Matt and Chester are tricked into riding out to a squalid homestead where they encounter a half-crazed family intent on robbing Dodge's bank.

An interesting episode for both its highs and lows, and for what the story implies. The idea and title clearly come from the backwoods movie of 1941, Tobacco Road. However, instead of a humorous tale of an eccentric family of Southern rubes, the Grilk family are desperate and murderous, nothing amusing at all. The trouble is, it's spread on so thickly the portrayals come close to unfunny parody that undercuts the entry's serious intent. On the other hand, is the entry's powerful ending. Now, what distinguishes Gunsmoke from other series of the time is its occasional refusal to come up with a happy ending. And that's certainly the case here, with a desolation that speaks volumes about homesteading on the frontier.

All of which brings up two of writer Meston's favorite themes— namely, the psychological and physical toll of homesteading, especially on women. In the script, Pa Grilk (Simon) takes out his frustrations on Ma (Nolan) by beating her regularly, and being isolated on the prairie, she has no defense. Now, being isolated like that is a powerful theme and I wish Meston had developed it more than he does since it would more fully explain the family's half-crazed behavior. Besides, that ramshackle dugout of a house or whatever it might be is like nothing I've seen from the time, and speaks volumes in itself.

Anyway, it's an interesting episode as much for what it doesn't say as for what it does.
11 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Another sad story of life in the early west
kfo949417 June 2013
The show started off with a rather simple plot that will be played out many times during the series run, as Matt and Chester get called for assistance outside of town with the desire to get them away so the bank can be robbed. The difference in this story is that the people that want to rob the bank are uneducated dirt people that live by their on standards.

It begins at the dirt house (that has been used many times in the series) located outside of town. Budge Grilk, the son, has gone and advised the Marshal that his help is needed at the house.. When Matt and Chester get to the house, that is occupied by Ma and Pa Grilk, they are held while Pa tells them he is going to kill them then rob the Dodge Bank. Matt has to find a way to escape.

This episode actually turned out to be a sad tale of life in the early west. A way of life that many people had to endure as things make a incorrect turn in living. Jeanette Nolan, that played the Ma, is excellent as she brings the hardship of the character's life to the surface. Even with the forlorn direction of the story, the episode was at least entertaining to watch.
12 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Outstanding Episode of an Outstanding Series!
atomicis8 July 2021
Other reviewers have mentioned "The Twilight Zone", and also Hitchcock as not providing a happy ending, correctly so! "Gunsmoke" was billed as an "Adult Western" and this episode sure lives up to that.

I feel compelled to mention the "Potato Road" title, as another reviewer says it's related to "Tobacco Road". That may well be correct, but I found a road just off I-40 in Lebanon, Tennessee called "Tater Peeler Road". Asking some locals, I found it was so named because it was so rough that the potatoes in their wooden crates would be peeled by the jostling as the farmer traversed that route....
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Twilight Zone good!
helenem-6363816 May 2020
Not your usual Gunsmoke episode. No dance hall girls, no beer. Just a lot of law and order and coffee and potatoes!
5 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed