(TV Series)

(1970)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Conclusion of a Cinematic Episode
wdavidreynolds13 July 2021
Warning: Spoilers
The second part of this story begins with the passenger train bound for Dodge City stranded in the cold in the mountains, and Matt Dillon trying to make it to a relay station while fleeing from pursuing Sioux. Sioux leader Red Willow has demanded the release of two men from among the train passengers who sold the Sioux poison whiskey which killed three braves and blinded five.

Part 2 of the story delves more into the background of the passengers and includes more of Matt Dillon's journey to and from the relay station. Those two story elements necessarily slow the pace of the second part of the story.

One of the passengers named Sam Wickes proposes the stranded passengers attempt to determine the identities of the two men wanted by the Sioux and surrender them to save everyone else. Of course, Festus Haggen tries to prevent this turn of events, but he fails. A makeshift trial is convened where the passengers are questioned as to their whereabouts prior to boarding the train in Dodge City.

Meanwhile, through some kind of supernatural effort, the Marshal finally makes it to the relay station, which is appropriately named "Oblivion." How the Marshal could run/jog for hours through the snow and subdue three Sioux along the way is quite a feat. He finds the telegraph is not functioning, but the operator there is able to provide him a horse and rifle, and -- more importantly -- a wire he received before the lines went out with the identities of the two men that sold the Sioux the bad whiskey.

As Marshal Dillon races back to the train on his newly acquired horse, he stops long enough to free one of the Sioux braves that had been chasing him earlier. He leaves the brave with a knife to use to free the other two tribe members.

Back at the train, Wickes and the other passengers participating in the sham, mob "trial" choose the two men they think are responsible for the bad whiskey and throw them off the train to their certain death at the hands of the Sioux.

The story directly addresses themes of justice and honor. It is easy for the viewer to take a sanctimonious stance, because from the story observer's viewpoint, the proper actions are clear. However, it is difficult to say how one would act immersed within the same circumstances.

The cinematography in this episode is spectacular. Shots such as the Part 1 opening shot of the Sioux along a ridge overlooking the railway are breathtaking, and such shots are plentiful throughout the entire story. Another example that takes place in Part 1 is near the end when Matt is fleeing from the men pursuing him and we see the Marshal in the foreground and his pursuers approaching in the distance. Likewise, in Part 2, Dillon and his pursuers are shown running through a herd of buffalo. These kinds of shots were rare in television of the time.

Veteran television writer Preston Wood wrote this episode. He was no stranger to multi-part episodes as he also wrote the Season 12 episodes "Nitro! Part 1" and "Nitro! Part 2." He was good friends with Jack Webb, and contributed several stories for Webb's 1967 Dragnet reboot, Adam-12, and Emergency!. He was a contributing writer to the made-for-television movie The Steel Inferno for Emergency!, which was turned into a two-part episode for that series. In fact, "Snow Train" possesses strong cinematic qualities and could easily be edited into a movie.

The ending of this episode is unique among Gunsmoke episodes in that most of the credits appear as the story concludes by showing each character individually. In many cases, these scenes provide closure to the individual stories.

The producers went all-out on this episode. The location shooting, the large cast, the John Parker score, which won a Western Heritage Wrangler Award, and the story complexity all lend to the ambition and grandiosity of the effort.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Different Kind of Gunsmoke
kenstallings-6534624 March 2018
This is the two-part episode that sought to be different from all other series episodes. From a production standpoint, it stands apart with the highest quality ever. The outdoor location shooting was a monumental challenge and resulted in the finest cinematography of any Gunsmoke episode ever shot. Indeed, that production value stands well above average today.

The two-part script allowed for deeper than normal character development, which was strange considering that only three principle cast members were present for the photography: James Arness, Ken Curtis, and Milburn Stone. It was just Matt, Festus, and Doc, surrounding by an unusually strong guest ensemble of veteran actors.

Ultimately, it is an episode that gives Dillon the chance to be the hero in a desperate bid to wire for help. That just ended up removing the one character perhaps strong enough to prevent the evolution of the central theme of the narrative. What happens when people desperate to live become willing to abandon honor for survival?

In this episode, the answer is that they are wiling to forego civilized behavior for mob rule, and become willing to sacrifice two of their own so that the others might escape.

Dillon returns just in time to end the standoff, but not before one man dies due to the desperate nature of the situation.

In the end, it comes down to a clash of cultures. Two men engage in a profit enterprise and cause death in a way they did not anticipate nor wanted. The Sioux tribe uses their own tribal sense of justice to hold a trainload of people hostage to get the two they believe guilty of harming their tribe. Two other men, guilty of something different, find out just how some are willing to abandon law and order to survive, and how easy it is for civilized behavior to devolve into the law of "club and fang."

Playing throughout both parts is a soaring theme composed by John Carl Parker, complete with several different arrangements played out to strike different moods. The music was quite effective.

Ultimately, this two-part episode was intended to rise to the level of a stand alone movie. In that regard, the 90 minutes of actual play (two hours counting commercial breaks) would have made a nice TV movie. Complete with end credits of the ensemble cast played out as a series of stills from the extended ending, and one understands how original this episode truly stood.

Only a series with such gravitas as Gunsmoke could have negotiated the production budget to pull this off, and it was a joy to watch.
15 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Part Two brings the show to an entertaining ending
kfo949428 November 2012
In this part two of this two part episode we get back into the train that has been stopped by the Indians. Two people on the train sold the Indians tainted whiskey that caused death and blindness in the Indian Nation. With the identity of the people involved unknown, the train and its passengers are at a standoff with the Indians.

Matt has left the train and is trying to make it to a transfer station where they have a telegraph line. Three Indians are giving chase making Matt have to use some tactics to escape. But when he makes it to the transfer station the lines are down. Exhausted Matt has to turn right back around toward the train. But this time he has a horse and the names of the people that sold the tainted whiskey.

On the train things have deteriorated to a point where they have tied up Festus and interviewing the passengers in order to turn the two guilty parties over to the Indians. They think they know the two men and give them up to the Indians but will it be the true guilty parties.

Again not a fan of the two part episode plan but this one played out rather good. I still believe if the show had been reduced to an hour format it would have been better. But nice cheers to the writer that did a nice job of making this interesting.
10 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed