"Gunsmoke" Sweet and Sour (TV Episode 1957) Poster

(TV Series)

(1957)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A Woman Entertained by Deadly Conflict
wdavidreynolds4 January 2022
Matt Dillon and Chester Goode are waiting for the stagecoach in Wichita when they meet a pretty woman named Rena Decker. Rena had engaged a man named Ab Laster in a conversation. When Laster begins to become a bit too aggressive with the woman, Matt steps in. Matt and Ab exchange angry words, and Matt punches Ab. Ab makes some threats about getting even with the Marshal after they get to Dodge City.

Rena is a stranger in Dodge and needs a job. Matt introduces her to Kitty Russell, who - for the first time - mentions she is half-owner of the Long Branch Saloon, in the hopes Rena can work at the Long Branch Saloon. When Kitty interviews Rena, she finds something more sinister behind the attractive exterior. Rena has developed the dubious skill of goading men into fighting over her, and she enjoys it immensely.

Initially, Kitty refuses to hire Rena, but Matt and Chester dismiss Kitty's concerns. Kitty accuses the men of being unable to see beyond the pretty face. Kitty agrees to hire Rena as much to prove a point as anything.

Actress Karen Sharpe perfectly fits the role of the dangerously beautiful Rena Decker in this, the first of two Gunsmoke roles. At the time this episode was filmed, Sharpe was signed to John Wayne's production company and accepted roles in many television westerns. She would later marry renowned director Stanley Kramer after which she quit acting and worked with the production company she and her husband formed.

John Alderson plays the Ab Laster character. This is one of three Gunsmoke appearances for the actor who often played villains. A few other familiar faces appear in small roles in this story. Walter Reed plays Joe Garrett. John Mitchum plays a man known only as "Joe." Ken Mayer appears as Hank.

Once again, the production team behind the Gunsmoke series delivers a unique tale for the time this episode was produced. The male lead characters are all clueless, while the Kitty Russell character is the one smarter person that can clearly understand the situation that exists and predict what will happen. Thanks to Matt's refusal to listen to Kitty and trust her judgement, needless violence and deaths will result.

(There is a cleverly shot, key scene in the Marshal's office where Kitty joins Matt, Chester, and Doc to tell them she is not going to hire Rena. The three men are surprised by this news and begin to question Kitty's reasoning. The aggressive body language of the three men - Chester and Doc are standing, while Matt is seated - compared to Kitty's seated, passive position is noteworthy.)
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Well played plot centered around a young beautiful woman
kfo94948 June 2013
A young beautiful woman named Rena Decker rides a stage into Dodge with Matt and Chester. Matt sees that the young woman is vulnerable and has already stopped a man that was getting fresh with her. So Matt take the young girl under his wing and tries to get her a job at the Long Branch.

But when Kitty tells Matt that something is not right with the woman, it makes the entire Marshal's office laugh. The girl is too nice and good looking to cause any trouble in Dodge. Kitty goes ahead and hires the woman and it only takes a few minutes before Rena makes a liar out of someone.

A different plot that centers around a young woman entering the rough town of Dodge. With some fine acting and creative writing, this show was interesting throughout. Good show.
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
About Manipulation
sambase-3877316 January 2022
This episode is about manipulation for the benefit of one's ego and/or profit. It could be a man or a woman, but in this case it happens to be about a woman. Beware of manipulators. I've run into them my whole life and I've hated them my whole life. They are nothing but trouble. You can't just punch them and shoot them like you can on TV westerns, so they are much more difficult to deal with in real life, especially when they win the confidence of one of your family members.

Matt Dillon runs into a beautiful young woman and rescues her from a trouble maker. Then the woman turns up in Dodge needing a job. Matt wants Kitty to hire her at the saloon, but Kitty doesn't want to saying she thinks the girl is a manipulator and that Matt is being suckered by her pretty face. And of course Kitty is right and Matt is wrong. Dead wrong. But Matt persists and Kitty gives in and hires the girl, warning that somebody is going to get hurt because of her.

I'll stop right there, but anybody can probably guess what's going to happen. A pretty girl right in the middle of tough guys in a country awash in guns. Gee, what could possibly happen?

Anyway, this is a very good episode. And a good lesson for all of us. Beware of manipulators. They are everywhere.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Episode is not over the top
LukeCoolHand10 December 2020
Others have reviewed this episode very well so all I will talk about my experience as it relates to this episode. Having played guitar in every sort of Honky Tonk bar, I have seen it all when it comes to a beautiful woman causing a real stir. Some reviewers are saying this episode is way over the top. NOPE. Mix alcohol, testosterone, and a sexy woman and you have a real problem. I have never seen a death but have seen guns, knives, fists, and even a chain saw pulled out over a woman. All a woman had to do was look at a man, and her boyfriend or husband was ready to fight. The plot of this episode happens all over the world. Some bars I played in asked you at the door if you had a gun or knife before they let you you in. If you replied NO, they said well in that case we'll loan you one. LOL

Anyway this was an interesting episode to me and that Karen Sharpe really lived up to her name. What a looker ! If you are in the mood for a little something different, don't miss this one. This 30 minute episode goes by like it was only 5 minutes long.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Good Premise-- Not So Good Execution
dougdoepke16 February 2012
Interesting premise— sweet young Rena (Sharpe) gets harassed in stage depot, causing Matt to intervene. Now Matt wants to help her by getting her a job at the Long Branch. But Kitty senses something about the girl, except Matt's skeptical since the girl is so sweet looking. Now there's going to be trouble.

It's a clever twist on the sweet-young-thing that populated so many oaters of the day. However, in my book, the impact is lessened by clumsy staging and an over-done script (Meston). Did the entry really need so much clumsy gunplay when fist fights, for example, could have made the same point. All in all, it's a 30-minutes that doesn't execute the premise very well.
8 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Stayed pretty true to the radio script
hpringnitz8 March 2022
I don't remember who played the role of Rena on radio. Karen Sharpe was very good at portraying this sort of role on TV. She did pretty much the same thing on Bonanza in The Ape. Pretty on the outside and VERY ugly on the inside.

This is a very good episode.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Meet Rena Decker... So Sweet (!?)... So Innocent (!!??)
You know what? I definitely think that screenwriter, John Meston really went way-way-way overboard (right to the extreme) in this episode of "Gunsmoke" when it came to illustrating Rena Decker's overall power to seriously manipulate men.

Like - Talk about, literally, overplaying things here with Rena (to the max). I ain't kidding.

I mean - We're dealing with a woman here who was totally getting the guys (who were good buddies with each other) so riled-up and randy over her that they were actually resorting to committing the most fatally drastic act imaginable (against each other) in order to be the one who Rena (being such a P.Y.T.) would eventually choose to be with.

Like - Hello!? - C'mon, now! Let's get real here, folks!

Yep. I'd certainly say that this episode of "Gunsmoke" was downright ridiculous, preposterous, and yes, totally demented (on all counts). Yep. It really, really was.
2 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed