"Hogan's Heroes" Hogan, Go Home (TV Episode 1968) Poster

(TV Series)

(1968)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Return of the bumbling Colonel Crittendon
kfo949420 August 2014
In this episode London sends a message advising that they are calling Colonel Hogan back home much to the chagrin of the others. It even gets worse when Hogan's replacement is the bumbling Colonel Crittendon (Bernard Fox) that has very little in the way of deception.

Hogan, which has been relieved of ranking officer status, wants to make sure that his escape will not look bad on the operations at Stalag 13. So he gets Klink to transfer him to another Stalag. But when he finds out that he will be riding on the train that the Allies are to destroy, he is not a willing part of returning to London.

There are some funny lines between Klink and Hogan in this episode as Klink uses the phrase "Chop, chop, chop" in a very special way to make the show enjoyable. And anytime we have the return of Crittendon the show is going to be interesting. Good show
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Funny even though the plot had a hole the width of a battleship
FlushingCaps29 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Some have written here on IMDB that this episode has no laugh track. The DVD set I have most definitely has a laugh track for this episode.

Right after outlining the latest sabotage plans to the men, Hogan receives, via Kinch, an order from London to escape to England in preparation for him to go home to the US and be treated as a war hero, going on tour to raise money for war bonds. He immediately reacts with great joy-which the Heroes are surprised to see at first, but realize they would all do the same.

It seems his "replacement" will bring the specifics on how his escape will be orchestrated. Everyone in the group is surprised, and most disappointed, to see that it is the bumbling Col. Crittendon who is sent to be the new leader. He works with the men to carry out the big sabotage they had planned-but his ineffective ways with Klink get Hogan a truck ride not to his new Stalag, but to the very train the men are about to blow up. Crittendon's blunders almost make them unable to stop the truck as planned.

The show very briefly mentions that Crittendon is now being transferred elsewhere and Hogan escaped only to voluntarily return to Stalag 13 where he is welcomed back by Klink. We are led to believe London will accept the big change in arrangements and forget about this big tour to sell war bonds.

This was a fairly funny episode, particularly Klink and Hogan's playful dialog and Crittendon's blundering. Klink takes great joy telling Hogan that he is about to be replaced as senior POW officer. Crittendon has barely entered the barracks when he goes about trying to destroy printed orders and he nearly burns his hand holding the papers, then tosses them into a wicker basket that holds the men's laundry and is oblivious to the growing fire he has caused.

The big plot hole was that this "hero's welcome" we are told Hogan is to receive would be murderous to the men back at Stalag 13. Officially, Hogan was just a flyer who was shot down and then prisoner from long before D-Day. He could only be given hero treatment if it was publicized that he led many sabotage and rescue efforts helping the Allied cause while a prisoner. Of course, the German spies in the US would report to Berlin and the men remaining in the camp would be executed.

Just the illogic of a man running an on-going effort that was most effective in helping the cause being pulled from his mission just to go back to sell war bonds makes no sense. Even military leaders as stupid as the ones usually portrayed on MASH wouldn't dream of giving up a successful operation like that just to sell bonds. The only way something like this plot MIGHT have been believable would be if London believed the Krauts were on the verge of catching our Heroes and killing them all. Then they would order them to finish their big mission and shut down the whole operation and all of them come home immediately before discovered. But that would have been a whole different episode.

Funny episode-worth an 8.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Klink has fun with Hogan before things change
FlushingCaps27 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Right after outlining the latest sabotage plans to the men, Hogan receives, via Kinch, an order from London to escape to England in preparation for him to go home to the US and be treated as a war hero, going on tour to raise money for war bonds. He immediately reacts with great joy-which the Heroes are surprised to see at first, but realize they would all do the same.

It seems his "replacement" will bring the specifics on how his escape will be orchestrated. Everyone in the group is surprised, and most disappointed, to see that it is the bumbling Col. Crittendon who is sent to be the new leader. He works with the men to carry out the big sabotage they had planned-but his ineffective ways with Klink get Hogan a truck ride not to his new Stalag, but to the very train the men are about to blow up. Crittendon's blunders almost make them unable to stop the truck as planned.

The show very briefly mentions that Crittendon is now being transferred elsewhere and Hogan escaped only to voluntarily return to Stalag 13 where he is welcomed back by Klink. We are led to believe London will accept the big change in arrangements and forget about this big tour to sell war bonds.

This was a fairly funny episode, particularly Klink and Hogan's playful dialog and Crittendon's blundering. Klink takes great joy telling Hogan that he is about to be replaced as senior POW officer. Crittendon has barely entered the barracks when he goes about trying to destroy printed orders and he nearly burns his hand holding the papers, then tosses them into a wicker basket that holds the men's laundry and is oblivious to the growing fire he has caused.

The big plot hole was that this "hero's welcome" we are told Hogan is to receive would be murderous to the men back at Stalag 13. Officially, Hogan was just a flyer who was shot down and then prisoner from long before D-Day. He could only be given hero treatment if it was publicized that he led many sabotage and rescue efforts helping the Allied cause while a prisoner. Of course, the German spies in the US would report to Berlin and the men remaining in the camp would be executed.

Just the illogic of a man running an on-going effort that was most effective in helping the cause being pulled from his mission just to go back to sell war bonds makes no sense. Even military leaders as stupid as the ones usually portrayed on MASH wouldn't dream of giving up a successful operation like that just to sell bonds. The only way something like this plot MIGHT have been believable would be if London believed the Krauts were on the verge of catching our Heroes and killing them all. Then they would order them to finish their big mission and shut down the whole operation and all of them come home immediately before discovered. But that would have been a whole different episode.

Funny episode-worth an 8.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
CBS's Laugh Track Experiment
Tom_Barrister21 May 2019
From its beginning, the artificial laugh track was controversial, with those who liked it and those who didn't. Most wanted or tolerated the laugh track. By and large, those shows whose creators and/or stars objected to laugh tracks or live audiences had their shows canceled after short runs. A notable exception was Charles Schultz; his Peanuts specials were met with critical acclaim, sans the canned laughter.

In the summer of 1967, CBS executives decided to try an experiment. They chose a sitcom with both comedic and serious elements, "Hogan's Heroes," and made two versions: one with and one without a laugh track. Then they screened them to different audiences. The versions with a laugh track were well-received, and those without largely failed. The shows with the laugh track were aired (I remember them well), and CBS ended the experiment, although they did tone down the laugh track in select future series.

Through an error, some of the shows without the laugh track were distributed to certain outlets (i.e. METV), including this one, and they're shown as-is. The United Kingdom went a step further: they removed the canned laughter from all episodes (which is possible if the laugh track has its own channel), preferring to emphasize the serious aspect of the show.

M*A*S*H was made this way, with the laugh track made optional to distribution points, and it's well-known that it was eliminated from operating room scenes early in the series.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed