"The Mothers-In-Law" How Not to Manage a Rock Group (TV Episode 1968) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Some Enchanted Evening
wes-connors26 December 2016
While his parents and in-laws gather to watch color TV, college student Jerry (Jerry Fogel) announces he's managing a rock group. The hippie quartet is The Seeds (as The Warts) and they need $500 for "a good dub" (first record demo). The parents refuse until reminded about how present-day rock groups quickly sell millions of records. Roger (Roger C. Carmel) and Herb (Herbert Rudley) agree to sponsor the group. The Seeds sing their song "Pushin' to Hard" but the in-laws are not impressed. Eve (Eve Arden) suggests they revamp the group, to save their investment. Kaye (Kaye Ballard) thinks they need to visit a good barber, although her hairstyle looks just like the boys in the band. Finally, the Hubbards and Buells decide a cover of Rodgers and Hammerstein's "Some Enchanted Evening" would be a groovy first record...

This was the last aired episode of the season and ends on a high note. Sky Saxon and the Seeds give the story genuine youth appeal. Many sitcoms would hire imitation rockers and use "pseudo" rock 'n' roll music in situation comedies. The Seeds' song "Pushin' to Hard" is a real psychedelic garage-band classic from the era. The "adult pop" music it balances is also used well. Desi Arnaz directed this episode from a script by Don Nelson (Ozzie's brother), so the music and comedy was in knowing hands. The one-note band "leader" in the final scenes is Joe Besser, one of the latter-years "Three Stooges" and excellent in his role...

"The Mothers-In-Law" was a fine comedy, although perhaps too derivative in story ideas. To be fair, Desi-Lucy shows did the same sort of borrowing, sometimes going back to radio comedies. More often than not, plots were modernized. Despite the quality, TV ratings were not as high as NBC expected and they nearly canceled "The Mothers-In-Law". Fortunately, it was renewed for another season. However, this was the final episode with Roger C. Carmel as the actor and Desi Arnaz' production company parted company. When you consider how TV series replacements usually work out, he was very successfully replaced by Richard Deacon.

******* How Not to Manage a Rock Group (4/28/68) Desi Arnaz ~ Eve Arden, Kaye Ballard, Roger C. Carmel, Herbert Rudley
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
This wouldn't make it as "South Central Pacific".
mark.waltz3 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
It's the Warts vs. the Squares in this season one finale that bid farewell to Roger C. Carmel, leaving the show over a controversial salary dispute. He is simply part of the usual ensemble of the old fuddy-duddies who invest in Jerry's rock band, The Warts, and try to change their image simply because they do not get them. But with the Buells and Hubbard's each investing $250, they want some say, and that means completely trying to change the rock band's act. The Warts won't hear of this, and sneak out while the foursome are making their suggestions of how to alter their act. When they end up in a recording studio, the Warts do not show up and the foursome decides to record their own record, the oddest version.of "Some Enchanted Evening" ever done.

That's Three Stooges regular Joe Besser as the Salvation Army like band leader, and his familiar Lou Costello imitation is unmistakable. This episode is memorable for its weird version of the Rodgers and Hammerstein classic, as well as several other novelty songs performed by Eve, Kay, Roger and Herb. It's obvious that they didn't really have a script long enough to fill up 24 minutes because a good 10 minutes of the episode is filled with these pointless little numbers. Still, there's enough entertainment to make this enjoyable and Debbie Watson does know how to shake her shimmy. As for the Wart's song, I can describe it simply by saying that the name of their band is more interesting Down the song.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed