"Perry Mason" The Case of the Lazy Lover (TV Episode 1958) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
14 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
excellent episode
lewis-5114 November 2013
The plot has been summarized by other reviewers, so I won't go into much detail on that.

As are most of the early Perry Mason TV episodes, this one was based on a book by the same name. Unusually, the TV episode is much better than the book, which is too complicated and has people doing extremely unlikely things.

In the interest of time if nothing else, a number of the features of the book had to be removed or changed. Here, only one check for $2500 is delivered to Mason's office (not two) to start the story. Here, the stepdaughter is younger and more innocent than she is in the book. Here, the client (Mrs. Allred) is more willing to talk to Mason and is more straight forward.

But the essential features are the same: Allred's right-hand-man, Fleetwood, feigns amnesia after a blow to the head because he knows too much about a crooked deal. Allred wants to tightly control him, maybe kill him, at least keep him from his partner (who does not appear at all in the TV episode). Allred, his wife, and Fleetwood go to a motel; they are not all there at the same time. Later there is a murder, and Fleetwood ends up not too far away at a cabin on a small ranch.

That brings us to probably the most interesting part of the plot: the map showing the tracks left in the soft ground at the ranch by various people, a car, and a dog. The district attorney says the tracks clearly show that Mrs. Allred is guilty. But Perry has another idea.

It is very well acted, with Della looking especially young and lively. Highly recommended.
17 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Holy deja vu casting Batman!...
AlsExGal28 December 2022
... since Yvonne Craig plays the stepdaughter of Bertrand Allred (Neil Hamilton) in this episode, and the two played father and daughter in the Batman TV series with Craig being Bat Girl and Hamilton playing Commissioner Gordon. Weird stuff.

In this episode, Patricia Faxon (Craig) has to swerve wide to get around her stepfather's car in the driveway. Robert Fleetwood is found unconscious, and it is believed that Faxon hit him with her car when she parked in the driveway.

Later, Perry receives a 2500 dollar retainer fee from Patricia Allred, the mother of the girl who thinks she hit Robert Fleetwood with her car, with no explanation. Next, Bertrand Allred comes to Perry and asks that he find his wife and Fleetwood, as they have run away together. What goes on here? Did an unconscious man, possibly with life threatening injuries, have the energy and initiative to run off with Mrs. Allred, and why would she go with him? Complications and murder ensue.

This episode has some exceptional verbal sparring going on between Lieutenant Tragg and Perry. You can tell that Tragg is at the end of his career and so Mason presents a bit of a final challenge for him. He will neither be demoted or promoted based on his dealings with him. But Hamilton Burger has ambitions for higher office, so Perry does get on his nerves.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Fun but All Over the Place
Hitchcoc11 December 2021
Sometimes, in an effort to hide the real murderer, a mystery writer throws so much at the audience that they can't figure out what happened. This is one of those. Even when it is explained in court, Burger can put the pieces together for sure. This was a lesser episode but still great fun. I enjoyed Perry's reason for fogging up Hamilton's direction.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Good Luck, Hamilton
darbski26 May 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** Yes, Yvonne Craig looks really cute, but the real hottie in this episode is Frances Helm. She flirts seductively with Perry; probably to keep him guessing, while her boyfriend Harry Townes tries to slide under the radar and out of trouble. No doubt, she is a babe, as well as a very good actress. Perry would have had no trouble outmaneuvering Fleetwood for her attentions, but we then have to ask "Is this lady the equal of Della"? (Answer: NOPE). This episode does point out what Perry's job is, and how well he does it. First, eliminating his client from the suspect list, Next, in this case, throw it all back to the prosecution. BOTH Fleetwood, and Overbrook blame each other. Confusion to the enemy. Perry has a great last line. when asked by Della why not tell Hamilton who the real killer is, he replied "It might set a dangerous legal precedent". Hilarious.

Great scene setups, acting, and direction, with good courtroom drama, and a little challenge for Burger at the end make this a terrific story. Thanks to IMDb for the history of these actors/actresses. Once again, the depth of the Screen Actors Guild talent is shown from all the performers, but Harry Townes takes the cake with a very fine piece of acting.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Perry works through Hamilton's courtroom diagram to Perry's advantage
ebertip14 November 2020
Perry's client is Lucille Faxon Allred, accused of murdering her husband (played by Neil Hamilton later of Batman). Her daughter Patricia Faxon (later Batgirl) is the step-daughter of Mr. Allred. Despite a rather polished air, Mr. Allred is a scumbag, and two characters (other than the wife) have motives to kill Mr. Allred. This episode is somwhat unusual iin exonerating Perry's client while lacking a courtroom confession of the culprit. Hamilton thought he had the case solved with an elaborate diagram relying on "tracking" evidence but Perry brings up the time/sequence element. One not credible part of Hamilton's case relied on escape from a clised trunk. 1950s cars did not have inside trunk releases. Also, the tracking evidence did not evaluate shoe size. Why Fleetwood's ID was on Allred's body is not explained by Hamilton. Perry moves to dismiss but is denied. Perry is allowed to recall witnesses with the judge noting no legal gymnastics at the expense of the equities. There is some humor. Tragg asks if Perry is acting as emcee (MC). Relying on Fleetwood's "amnesia," Della pretends to be his wife. Of the tracking, Perry notes Paul solved the case tho Paul has no idea. In the "epilog," Perry confuses Hamilton about who the culprit is ( recall no confession here) and Perry notes he does want to set a precedent of helping Hamilton. In a different episode, Perry would explicitly say that's your job.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Two of my favorite Mason character actors were in this episode
calibertarian16 July 2021
Neil Hamilton appeared in this episode. I really enjoyed Hamilton in his multiple roles in a number of episodes and liked him best as a restaurant owner. He had the demeanor you would want from a hands on restaurant owner. Just a gut feeling but from the way he and Raymond Burr interacted in Hamilton's multiple appearances I think they were off the set friends.

Then there was an appearance by Frances Helm who was also in a number of episodes. She was my favorite actress in the entire Perry Mason series. Each to their own and I think she was the most alluring of all the actresses that appeared in the Perry Mason series. In this episode she did nothing to dispel that. In fact, just the opposite. .

Finally their was an appearance by James Bell the "Mr, I hope you like cribbage" guy from another episode. There are some lines you tend to remember and the "Mr. I hope you like cribbage" is one of them. Sorry, if the quote isn't exact. But that is how I remember it.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Retainer, Just in case
bkoganbing31 July 2014
Raymond Burr gets a retainer from Ann Lee asking that he represent her or her daughter if needed, no explanations. But explanations come from Yvonne Craig her daughter. Seems as though Craig might have hit someone, maybe killed them. Stepfather Neil Hamilton checks and sure enough there's some man lying in their driveway.

Famous last words, Hamilton says he'll take care of it. Hamilton and Lee drive away with the body and it's Lee charged with the murder. But of Hamilton whose body is found with their car in a canyon ravine.

As usual Hamilton had a lot of enemies. This one is in the how as the murderer is the one with a big grudge against Hamilton. You'll know right away. Let us say that William Talman uses this person for their expertise and Raymond Burr turns it right around.

There's a little coda at the end where Burr throws a real zinger into Talman. And Barbara Hale has a nice scene where she pretends to be the wife of an amnesia victim.
12 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Batman!
zsenorsock23 October 2007
Warning: Spoilers
This episode starts out fairly strong when the body of a man (harry Townes) is discovered in the driveway of the Archer home. The teenage daughter (Yvonne Craig) is convinced she accidentally hit the man while pulling out of the driveway. Both her mother Bonnie (Frances Helm) and her step father (Neil Hamilton) are anxious to keep it quiet. When they bring the body in, they discover the man is Robert Fleetwood (Harry Townes) and he's still alive. After this interesting beginning this then settles down becomes is a fairly stock Perry Mason episode in which a wealthy woman Bonnie Archeris accused of killing her husband who she was in the process of divorcing. To be clear, a stock episode of Perry Mason is still better than most shows. However, this is not the series best, really dragging in the courtroom when PE Overbrook (James Bell) testifies using a map. The most interesting thing is the casting. Yvonne Craig is playing the step daughter of Neil Hamilton. Ten years later she would again play his daughter (who is secretly Batgirl) on "Batman" as Barbara Gordon. Keith MacDonald who plays the judge was a frequent villain and con man in "Three Stooges" short subjects and its always a little amusing to see the former "Mr. Slick" play a judge. Harry Townes also later appeared with Burr on a couple of "Ironside" episodes.
14 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
No lemonade here
kfo949414 October 2011
This episode had everything to make it one of the best. Great guest stars, good acting, nice plot and a crime that has one interesting in outcome of the characters of the show. Then like a spectator at a 1937 airship landing- when it moves to the courtroom- it comes crashing down right in front of our eyes.

The show begins when a man is found near death in front of a wealthy family's house. It could have been the young step-daughter Patricia Faxon (played by Yvonne Craig soon to be Batgirl) or it could have been the not-so-nice step-father Bertrand Allred (Neil Hamilton soon to be Commission Gordon also from Batman).

The man makes a nice recovery but we get another crime also involving the family. At this point the viewer is caught up in the mystery and on the edge of the seat waiting to see more.

Then we have the courtroom scenes. By the time the show ends, we are thinking about anything other than who committed the crime.

The problem was a map that included footprints. Not just a few footprints but prints by the entire cast. It is so confusing we do not give a darn who was walking or who was running along the map scene. To make the map more confusing we have dog prints, boards and plants all within the map that may, or may not, have something to do with the crime. Even Hamilton Burger is confused at the end of the show.

This episode was a good book- but does not come across in film.
25 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The Case of the Lazy Lover
Prismark1013 March 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Holy Footprints.

Patricia Faxon might have unwittingly run over a man in front of her house. The man Robert Fleetwood works with her stepfather Bertrand Allred.

Allred and her mother took Fleetwood who claims to have lost his memory to a motel and cover up the incident.

Only for the mother to be later charged for murder. To the killing of Allred.

Fleetwood is later found in a farmhouse by Perry Mason. It comes to light that Allred was not a nice man who was involved in a lot of crooked deals. It seems Fleetwood has an agenda of his own.

After the set up, the plot gets muddied in a chalk map on a board with lots of footprints.

Hamilton Burger effectively uses a witness who is a tracker as an expert witness.

Even by the end it is unclear why Mrs Allred was being framed for murder by Fleetwood.

It might just be that this was an adaptation of a Perry Mason book and the adaptation was a bit messy.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
COMMISSIONER GORDON AND BATGIRL.... BEDORE COMMISSIONER GORDON AND BATGIRL
rwss2012-831-4262131 November 2019
Excellent... my header speaks for itself, lol. Always nice cs to see folks do something else, other than what they're famous for.
7 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Anything interesting this bleak Monday morning?
kapelusznik1815 November 2015
Warning: Spoilers
****SPOILERS**** Crazy is right like this Perry Mason title says about this episode. This has to be one of the most confusing and complicated of any of the 250 over a nine years run of Perry Mason episodes with so many side plots in it it made completing, in finding out who the killer in it is, a 10,000 piece jigsaw puzzle a piece of cake in comparison. Perry, Raymond Burr, for his part is his usual cool self never showing his true emotions in what a confusing mess of a case he's involved in and just plays it by ear or the script. And acts like he's in charge of things here which we, those in the audience, know that he isn't.

The person charged with the murder of her creepy husband Bertrand Allred, he's red all right, played by "Batman's" Neil Hamilton his abused wife Bernice, Frances Helm, isn't even suspected in his murder at first and he's not even the murder victim! It's her lover the fleet footed, who's always a step ahead of everyone in the cast, Bob Fleetwood, Harry Townes! It Fleetwood who' killed twice here and comes back from the dead with only a loss of memory. It's the now having his memory back Fleetwood who wakes up from his slumber to end this crazy Perry Mason episode by fingering the killer who's victim wasn't himself, whom we were at first lead to believe, but non other then Bertrand Allred!

****SPOILERS*** All this after were forced to sit through a boring demonstration by Perry of a map of the Overbrook, James Bell, residence about foot and dog prints leading back and forth from the murder scene! As for Mister Overbrook he also had it in for the by now very much murdered and disliked Bertrand Allred who as it turned out robbed him out of the rights of a gold mine the two had equal ownership of. At the very end of the episode Perry tries to explain who the killer of Bertrand Allred was but instead fall flat on his face doing it. That in him not leaving things as they were by Perry not making any sense at all in his shyster-like explanation!
5 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Good heavens.......
pmike-1131216 July 2021
I laughed, I cried......well, I laughed a lot, anyway. PM is always poorly scripted and directed, with horribly stilted and ridiculous dialogue and plots, but this one is SO convoluted and silly that the laugh-factor is ramped up considerably. I equate the show to a bad road accident: it's hard to turn away from staring at it.
4 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Always a Collision of Worlds
miketypeeach3 February 2024
These early episodes are full of people.. busy busy people with their hands in various cookie jars whose worlds collide in the most haphazard and ridiculous and unrealistic of ways. If only I had a nickel for every time I found an unconscious man in my driveway, well, I'd be rich beyond compare! Yeah, sure!

Aside from the improbable plot is the opening scene where a major goof occurs. A large car (weren't they all large in 1958?) is parked on the street where a driveway to a house begins. Another large car enters the scene which is driven around the parked car in such a way that the driver swerves rather violently in order to enter the driveway. The objective, as described in subsequent scenes, was to avoid hitting the parked car. However, as the second car is driven past the parked car, the parked car bounces, as if someone hidden behind it has shoved on it. Anyone who remembers those big, heavy cars knows that shoving one causes it to bounce. Suspensions were engineered to be rather soft in those days, guaranteeing a comfortable ride on any road. Anyway, it's evident that the second car sideswiped the parked car. How this escaped the notice of the production crew is anyone's guess. Perhaps they did notice and thought no one else would. Later, it's clear the left side of the front bumper of the parked car is bent upward a bit as a result.

Perry solves the case as only someone who wrote such a contrived story could.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed