"Perry Mason" The Case of the Malicious Mariner (TV Episode 1961) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
The Ancient Mariner
telegonus20 February 2019
No, this Perry Mason does not channel the famous Coleridge poem, however it concerns the aging captain of freighter that nearly sinks at sea during a storm en route from Japan to to California; and once safely in port things appear amiss amiss on this troubled ship; and its master is none too happy about the way his first mate took control of his boat from him. The younger man saved the ship, but where's the cargo?

This is a Perry whose plot is so convoluted as to cause he heads of all but the most experienced Perry savvy viewers heads to spin. The story is well told, and most of the non-regular characters come off as either suspicious or a bit shady. The plot is good example of the Something's Wrong With This Picture that's at the core of its story. What makes the episode one of the better in the series is how obvious it was that the police were barking up the wrong tree.

This isn't a brilliant episode, yet it was handled expertly by its cast and crew. There are a couple of red herrings, and lots of possibilities put forth as Perp Of The Week
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Too Many "Couldn't Happens"
Hitchcoc18 January 2022
Robert Armstrong, famed for King Kong, is hauling cargo. The ship ends up in a bad storm, and the second in command decides to get rid of the cargo after Armstrong is injured. It turns out that there is a big time insurance scheme going on. The young First Mate is seen as careless and that he overreacted. He is brought before the Coast Guard and Perry defends him, but Armstrong, who could help him, is killed, and Junior is accused. The problem with this is that the whole plot is so full of holes and so improbable it's laughable.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Citatation
darbski2 October 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** Here's where you find out how far over the hill I am. I remember this episode from when I was a kid because I remember it was the first time I'd heard a parking ticket referred to as a "Citation". Just one of those quirky little words that sometimes find their way into your vernacular that trips a specific memory. I'd never forget this episode.

The only weird part of the scheme in this story is WHY did Captain Bancroft decide to straighten out and fly right; support first Officer Griffin? Whatever it was is lost on me, unless he thought he could profit from turning on his other cohorts. Or maybe his brother made him do it. It took a lot of close quarters detective work involving the Japanese Coast Guard (or Navy) to determine what had happened to the substitute cargo but they got it done. I wonder just where the crooks got ahold of the scrap iron? After all, their own manufacturing base was working 24-7-365 implementing the MacArthur/Deming Plan of rebuilding Japan's mighty industrial class. Scrap iron was in high demand. Now, supposedly, this was done by means of Japan's underworld society, and That's the only way THAT connection could occur - I think. Anybody that the Japanese authorities caught would face severe prison terms for industrial sabotage, if not for treason.

On OUR side of the Pacific, Perry Mason was getting cited for parking next to a standpipe. He probably had beautiful Della get records from the L.A. Port Authority, and he then followed the trail to the conspirators, and the first person murderer. Janeel's gonna take a fall for Second Degree Murder, and all the rest of the fraud and outright theft, but so is Griffin's brother. He can try to say that he only wanted to cash in on the original ripoff, but IT was connected to the murder. In California, that is causally linked to homicide, and is therefore subject to a murder charge, too. If I was Burger, I'd offer to separate the murder charge and then dismiss it in exchange for testimony against Janeel, and then have the U.S. Customs and State Department wring him out for information about his overseas accomplices. I ask you, it's NEVER simple, is it?
8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Crate 'em Up!
therealjohnhood31 March 2021
The stack of crates seen dockside when Perry gets the ticket are marked Claver Collection Rio de Janeiro, which is the name and coordinates of the art collection that was reportedly torched in The Case of the Torrid Tapestry (Season 4 Episode 23).
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Perry blanks out at the witness stand.
gkimmarygleim20 February 2019
Another comment under Goofs states that while in court Perry reads from the wrong side of a piece of paper, the blank side. Having just watched the episode on MeTV, I think Perry is attempting to make the witness believe he is reading a document but is in fact stating his theory of the actual murder, thus catching the murderer.
14 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Shore up everything and keep on pumping!
sol121814 November 2012
Warning: Spoilers
***SPOILERS*** In a Parry Mason, Raymond Burr, episode that could amply be called The "Janeel Trader Munity" has the ship's 1st Mate Jerry Griffin,Lee Farr, gets himself involved in an elaborate maritime insurance scam that lead to a double cross and murder that he ended up getting framed for.

With the cargo ship "Janeel Trader" hitting high seas and heavy winds as it sailed off the coast of Japan Griffin in trying to save the crew has the ship's cargo of expensive machinery dumped overboard. It's then that the ship's Captain Bancroft, Robert Armstrong, who was knocked out cold during all the confusion threatens to press charges against the heroic Jerry for taking over command of his ship, while he was in no condition to sail it, with mutiny. Just before Jerry is to go on trial Bancroft is talked into dropping the charges against him in order to cut the insurance losses of his ship. And just before he can testify Bancroft is found dead with his skull cracked open on his boat with Jerry, whom he's to exonerate of losing the ship, who just happened to be at the scene arrested as the #1 suspect in his murder!

Perry Mason who was to defend Jerry on the unnecessary sinking of the "Janeel Trader" is now defending him in the murder of the ship's Captain Bancroft. This soon has Perry through his in house PI Paul Drake, William Hpper,travel to Japan where he finds out that the expensive machinery that Jerry had dumped from the ship in order to keep it from sinking to the bottom with its crew was worthless junk! Now it becomes evident that all this was done in order to collect the insurance on the so-called machinery that would amount to 1.5 million dollars that no one would be able to recover!

***SPOILERS*** Perry really gets into this case and gets in good in order to keep Jerry Griffin a true hero from ending up getting strapped into the San Quentin gas chamber for a murder that he didn't commit! Perry using all his skills and courtroom tricks as a defense attorney finally gets the to the bottom of this very complicated and confusing murder case. What Perry eventually uncovered, besides who Capt. Bancroft's killer was, is this totally insane plan to pull off an insurance fraud that went kaput when the ones who planned it double crossed each other! That in order for them not to have to split the 1.5 million dollars in insurance money!
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Mutiny in the Merchant Marine
bkoganbing12 November 2012
Lee Farr who saved a tramp freighter from going down only by jettisoning the cargo is Raymond Burr's client when Farr asks Perry Mason to represent him before a Coast Guard hearing. Of course he later needs Burr as his attorney to defend on the charge of murdering the captain of the vessel where Farr was the first mate and who pulled a mutiny as the ship was foundering in a storm. Sounds familiar doesn't it, but at least Captain Robert Armstrong wasn't rolling any ball bearings.

This was an episode where the writers got a little too complex with the plot. Just so happens that the cargo jettisoned was some factory equipment that Farr's brother Edward Binns was shipping from Japan to the USA. It also turns out that William Hopper has to go all the way to Japan to salvage the cargo and finds out it's just scrap iron. Who pilfered the cargo then?

And on that score there are a couple of frauds being perpetrated by people both against the insurance settlement and against each other. Don't doze off or you'll miss something and the whole thing won't make sense.

At the criminal trial and the Coast Guard hearing Perry Mason is worth every dime you pay him.
19 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed