(TV Series)

(1978)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Amusing Quincy episode.
poolandrews11 December 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy M.E.: Crib Job starts late one Californian night as Los Angelese coroner Quincy (Jack Klugman) is called out to a suspected homicide, once there Quincy finds on old man known as Brownie (Boyd 'Red' Morgan) dead with bruising on his knuckles & around his neck. Back in the lab & Quincy performs an autopsy which confirms Brownie was murdered, Lt. Monahan (Garry Walberg) has a young boy called Victor Garn (Todd Davis) in custody as his number one suspect. Particltes of Victor's skin were found in Brownie's knuckle wounds, splashes of Brownie's blood was found on Victor while an eye witness places him at the scene of the crime. At first it looks like an open & shut case but a long time friend of Quincy named Rosey Grier (Roosevelt Grier) who runs a community scheme called Giant Step ask's Quincy to listen to Victor & his story that he killed Brownie in self defence because Victor's guilt could close his program designed to help both the young & old in the community down for good...

Episode 16 from season 3 this Quincy story was directed by Alex March & one has to say Crib Job has things going for it but at the same time has things going against it & it sort of finds an OK balance between the two to make a relatively enjoyable 50 odd minutes. This is one of those Quincy episodes which has a strong moral message at it's heart, a message about making the old feel wanted & needed by passing their skills & experience onto the young. Unfortunately it's pretty badly written & comes across as badly handled, the dialogue is simply hilarious at times as all these hip, young jive talking (anything but) cool kids interact with old age pensioners! I loved the scene at the end when a teenage girl asked an 80 plus year old man if he 'wanted to boogie'! I don't know if anyone took this seriously back in '78 when this was made but viewing it today it's surprising the amount of times I actually laughed out loud at this. Another priceless scene is when Quincy visit's the young black guy in prison & the way he talks to Quincy with all his attitude & contempt for authority is simply hilarious. Now one of the reasons I like Quincy is for it's humour but in the case of Crib Job it's mostly unintentional humour which can be fun at times if not what the makers intended. The actual mystery Quincy has to solve isn't much of a mystery at all, Victor admits to killing Brownie but in self defence you after that it becomes a relatively straight forward case for Quincy to use his skills to prove it & save his buddies community project group. This is an alright episode, it's quite funny for the wrong reasons at times & the mystery elements while OK aren't that great but at only 50 odd minutes in length it's worth a watch.

This one is as unremarkable as most Quincy episodes, I did notice though that when you first see Brownie's body one of his arms isn't in the white chalk outline drawn by the police! Either the police officer who drew the chalk outline was drunk or the actor playing Brownie had moved his arm before the cameras started shooting. Also I'm not happy about how Quincy in literally one afternoon just happens to find another railway worker who just happened to know Brownie & had just happened to have seen him recently, talk about a co-incidence. The cheesy comedy ending is even worse than usual in Crib Job, out of politeness Quincy ask's an old lady to dance with him if she can take it which she accepts & then proceeds to dance like she's on steroids which leaves Quincy rather embarrassed! The acting is alright & again like a lot of season 3 there's no Danny to be seen anywhere.

Crib Job, a term which refers to a youth stealing or preying upon someone much older than them, is an OK episode of Quincy although maybe not for the reasons the makers intended. It's pretty funny & has it's moments but isn't anything outstanding.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Incorrect cast listed above.
victoruk15 November 2019
The cast listed relates to anther episode. Rosey Grier, for example, isn't even mentioned.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Well-intentioned but seriously flawed
rayoflite2429 August 2015
Crib Job begins with a disoriented elderly man wandering the streets in a run down neighborhood and encountering a group of thugs. Later the man is found dead with bruising on his hands, and Quincy (Jack Klugman) is called to the crime scene to examine the body and gather evidence. Lt. Monahan (Garry Walberg) arrests a teenager who an eyewitness identifies as being in a scuffle with the victim earlier, but the young man maintains his innocence despite forensic evidence that he and the victim fought. To further complicate matters, the teenage suspect is part of a community program run by football star Rosie Greer and the negative publicity stemming from the arrest puts funding for the program in jeopardy. Quincy must work quickly to determine how exactly the victim died in hopes of exonerating the teenage suspect and saving the beloved community program.

While there is an element of mystery to this episode, it really focuses more heavily on the social issue aspect of bringing old and young low income residents together so they can learn from and understand each other in a more productive and peaceful coexistence. The community center scenes are very well-intentioned and Pollyanna-like, but I just kept thinking to myself where on God's green earth would this ever happen?? Another thing I found ridiculous was that the victim was supposed to be an 80 year old man when the actor playing him appears to be in his late 50s or early 60s at most. To make sure I wasn't way off or suddenly in need of glasses, I looked up the birth year for the actor (Boyd Morgan) here and it is 1915 which would have made him a little over age 60 around the time this was filmed. This is another example of a quality issue in a Quincy episode which could have been easily addressed/fixed with a simple script change (just say he was age 65 or something close to that range) but wasn't.

The resolution is very predictable and Quincy gives an impassioned speech towards the end about saving the program and not withholding funding over politics and hype, but it is not powerful enough to make this a good Season 3 episode.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
A bit embarrassing.
planktonrules14 April 2013
Sometimes, TV shows tried too hard to be hip and relevant to young viewers. I can remember an episode where Mannix hung out in a coffee bar while Neil Diamond sang a few tunes to the beatniks, the pilot episode of "The Rookies" where the new recruits hang out at the rec center in a bad part of town to 'get down with the guys in the hood' and now we have Quincy trying very hard as well as he helps out a rec center where old folks and young sit around and have rap sessions! To me, this just seemed pretty embarrassing. Even more embarrassing was the guest star who ran this program, football legend Rosey Grier.

This program comes under negative scrutiny when one of the regular teens is accused of murdering an oldster. However, this is unlike the young man and Quincy is on a crusade to prove his innocence. In the end, there's a party and you see old people pretending to be young because it's supposed to be cute...though I thought it was patronizing. Just once, I want to see a group of old people who are surly or just plain old!! Overall, a fair episode but one you really don't need to rush to see.

By the way, I have an odd bit of trivia. This episode's guest star, Rosey Grier, wrote a book entitled "Needlepoint for Men" in 1973. Considering I love to cook, I like hearing about other guys who have non-traditional hobbies.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed