(TV Series)

(1977)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Fair episode with a plot that is still relevant today
rayoflite2422 August 2015
Death Casts a Vote begins with a young woman (Migdia Chinea) finding her fiancée, David Brady, dead inside his car with a hose leading from the exhaust pipe into the vehicle. The prevailing theory is that David died of carbon monoxide poisoning as a result of suicide, but his fiancée and father (Robert F. Simon) both reject that explanation and believe he was killed. Quincy (Jack Klugman) does find some inconsistencies when he conducts the autopsy and begins to believe that the victim was murdered which leads him into an investigation of the labor union in which David was a rising star.

I would say that the highlights of this episode for me are that it features a murder mystery and the story maintains relevance to this day in that corruption in labor unions and illegal immigrant workers continue to be hot button topics in our society. Whenever I see a Quincy episode like this where the plot line involves something that we are still struggling to deal with nearly 40 years later, I can't help but wonder if this will still be the case 40 years from now? In any event, I think it is a credit to the Quincy production team and writers that several of the topics addressed in these episodes are enduring issues that have stood the test of time.

All of that said, I wouldn't characterize this as one the better episodes of Season 3 in that there is very little action and it just seems to move at a very slow pace. The resolution is pretty anti-climactic as well, so don't expect an exciting ending as a payoff.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Average Quincy episode.
poolandrews21 November 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy M.E.: Death Casts a Vote starts as a young woman named Felicia Aspenosa (Migdia Chinea-Varela) finds her fiancé David Brady dead in his car in his garage. Lt. Monahan (Garry Walberg) & Los Angeles coroner Quincy (Jack Klugman) are called in, at first it appears like a straight forward case of suicide by Carbon Monoxide poisoning but Brady's father (Robert F. Simon) begs Quincy to investigate further as he is convinced his son would not commit suicide. Quincy finds out that David worked for a workers union called the 'Farm Workers Alliance' & that a rival union called 'The Labour of Brotherhood' run by Tony Gordon (James Gregory) might have a strong motive for murder, as Quincy digs deeper he discovers that David was murdered but he can't find any motive as to why...

Episode 5 from season 3 this Quincy story was directed by Ron Satlof & isn't one of the show's best ever 50 odd minutes. Here in the UK workers unions aren't that powerful & pretty much a thing of the past & therefore I found it really hard to relate to the story, I found it hard to relate to the fact these unions featured in this episode have any power whatsoever & the basic concept just didn't interest me that much. The murder mystery here is alright, it starts off looking like a suicide & Quincy in his usual methodical way & medical expertise proves that it wasn't although there's a lot of co-incidences & the plot isn't that great. I also thought the identity of the killer was far too obvious, I worked it out pretty early on to be honest. Even at 50 odd minutes in length this one seemed to go on for quite a long time & isn't as fast moving as some Quincy episodes. I like the show in general so I thought it was watchable if nothing else but if your not a fan of the show then Death Casts a Vote won't change your opinion of it.

Despite featuring quite heavily during the 15 minutes Monahan then suddenly disappears & he isn't seen at all again during this episode, strange. Unusually Danny doesn't feature at all in this episode either although there's still time for a cheesy happy ending with a bad joke. The same point & shoot technique is employed here as in every other episode of Quincy I've ever seen, it certainly isn't going to win any awards for style. The acting is alright, the regulars are good but the guest cast are merely average.

Death Casts a Vote is an OK Quincy murder mystery episode, it's not the show's best but it's not the show's worst either. Fans of the series will like it, those who aren't fans of the series probably won't & it's as simple & straight forward as that.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Not among the series' finer moments
planktonrules6 April 2013
Warning: Spoilers
This episode begins with a lady finding her fiancé dead--the apparent victim of suicide. The body was found in a garage--with a hose leading from the exhaust into the car--an apparent carbon monoxide victim. But, when Quincy and Sam autopsy the body, the carbon monoxide saturation is too strong to have come from that car in that garage. So, Quincy decides to investigate--to talk with this dead young lawyer's friends within a migrant worker's union. This leads to the actual cause of the man's death--and he was apparently killed somewhere else and later placed in his car.

This is only a fair episode of "Quincy". There were two problems with the show--it was a bit preachy when it comes to the immigrants and the show ended with a 'Perry Mason moment'--where the murderer confesses to the crime even though there is no concrete proof that they did it! This was also the problem with the previous episode. While a good show, occasionally it relied on such silly theatrics.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed