"The Rifleman" The Raid (TV Episode 1959) Poster

(TV Series)

(1959)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Episode with great potential but pure execution IMO
george-84125 January 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Great potential is wasted here as this story idea was too big for one half-hour episode.

A band of Apaches raid Lucas's ranch, kidnap Mark and leave Lucas for dead. Of course, he isn't dead, just knocked unconscious---the Indians' first big mistake. The second was taking the Rifleman's son.

Marshal Torrance teams up with the "tame Apache" marshal (who we've seen before, long hair and all) and along with a few somewhat reluctant townspeople they go in pursuit of the Apache band, whose leader apparently lost his own son a couple of months before and chose Mark as his replacement because he's the son of a man known to be brave. Did I mention this was a mistake? Bandaged head and all, Lucas insists on going along. It's his son, after all. After a day of trailing, a couple of the townsfolk start raising objections---reasonable ones like Mark is already dead, they got their own kids and families to consider, etc. They get pressured into continuing by Lucas & Micah until finally a few of the Apaches ambush the white men, killing one of the "disposable" family guys. Lucas & Co. run off the rest of the Indians and then bury the poor sap right there along the trail. At this point the remaining townspeople have had enough and they turn tail, saying that the death of "Most Unlucky Townsman #23" was a big waste.

At this point, I'd be inclined to agree since this posse is not operating very intelligently. They're blundering after a band of wilderness-savvy Apaches, making lots of noise, especially with the weary, injured Rifleman falling off his horse time after time. Well, now they're down to three (injured Lucas, elderly Micah and the presumably still sharp "tame Apache" lawman) and the Apache good guy finally talks the others into staying in camp while he attempts to scout ahead for Mark's kidnappers. Lucas agrees so he heads off and then Lucas changes his mind and decides to follow along. Good thing because this "tame Apache" (his term not mine) has evidently lost all his stealthy tracking skills since his strategy appears to consist of CHARGING INTO THE ENEMY CAMP and getting himself knocked out, and then tied up as a captive. Lucas follows along shortly and literally blunders into the camp. What saves the day is that all the renegades stand right up with the campfire providing nice visual definition and Lucas is able to pick them off one by one with his ever-helpful rifle.

Tame Apache is saved, Mark is saved and Lucas is the hero as usual.

It's just a weak, weak story, folks. And in terms of fighting strategy it's pitifully bad. If this story had taken place in a TV show called "The Apache" and allowed the eponymous hero 50% of the luck of the Rifleman, his band of Apaches would have ambushed and wiped out the cowboy posse in the first encounter and 10 years later Mark McCain would be known as the great Apache chief "Son of Man with Fancy Rifle."

Not every episode can be great but this is still one my all-time favorite western shows.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
great idea--but confusing/disjointed production
augiepat21 September 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I agree with other reviewers that the ending was short and weak...this would have been a great 2-part story/episodes...for example, the first part would have covered the first part of the posse's pursuit, with part 2 covering the final posse's trail an d ultimate confrontation--with ample time for a much better finish...also would have used/detailed Michael Ansara much better as a prelude to his own "BROKEN ARROW" series...also confused by the final credits listing Toomey as "Johannsen?" and Mark Goddard (from LOST IN SPACE) as "Walt" but I never see/hear him or a "Walt" in the entire episode!?...it almost makes you wonder if the original casting/posse's roles were changed during (near) year-end production of this season 1 episode...just a thought?

As the posse approached the gully, they noted it would be a good spot for an ambush, so why did they just continue on the trek without more (back-side) vigilance??--which by lacking that resulted in a death (arrow in the back) and injuries to the posse!!

When Lucas leaves Micah alone--what did Micah do??...where did HE go??

In the final battle between Lucas and Chaqua, you would think the exhausted (and severely head-injured) Lucas would not win the hand-to-hand battle with an Indian Chief--since he used his trusty rifle to knock-off all the other renegades.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
could have been much better
grizzledgeezer23 March 2013
I'd like to add to George-841's review. This is indeed an episode with wasted potential.

One of the problems with pre-cable networks is that action/adventure programs tended to have violent resolutions. The villains are usually beaten to a pulp or killed. Though there are many good things to say about "The Rifleman", the series too-often falls back on the easy way out, with bloody endings. (As McCain can fire his rifle quite rapidly, more than the usual quota of bad'uns are disposed of.) Given that "The Rifleman" sometimes had unexpected or surprising endings, I was hoping this one would, too. It didn't.

Chaqua has kidnapped Mark to replace his own son, who died not long before. The audience knows Mark isn't going to be eliminated in the first season, so the given ending is an foregone conclusion.

A much-better ending would have had McCain and Chaqua confronting each other over the campfire, with McCain convincing Chaqua that a 10-year-old boy isn't likely to adapt well to Apache life, and that Chaqua should not be causing two people grief just to ease his own. After extreme internal conflict, Chaqua reluctantly agrees and returns Mark.

This could have been further developed, by having Chaqua "adopt" Mark as a surrogate son, with Mark occasionally visiting him (in future episodes) to learn things his father couldn't teach, and get a broader view of the world.
13 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Too easy, too Pat, not one of the better ones
pemigewasset684 July 2018
Others have covered the summation of the details, so only let me add that those who complain about the reliance on violence to solve problems, those who pronounce that the white boy would not take well to being an Apache make the mistake of you viewing through the lens of the 21st-century American. Natives did take white prisoners and make white natives of their children. That is historical fact. That these prisoners were highly resistant to being rescued is also fact. If your idealistic, tenderhearted sensibilities are offended by the violence and you believe violence solves nothing, I refer you to the Nazis thousand year Reich, Imperial Japan, to the Confederate states of America, Carthage in general and it's Senate in particular. Negotiation and discussion are infinitely preferable of course, but all of that is predicated on and relies on reason, rationality and commonality - and if anything haven't we proven that those are difficult enough to find even among people from the same culture, society and nation?
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Don't sneeze or you may miss the ending.
kfo94943 May 2016
Cannot add much more that the other reviewers as they have hit the nail on the head with this episode. As stated, there was so many ways this story could have gone but most was left off the table. There was so much time spent on the trail to find the Indians that captured Mark, that when the climax of the story appeared it was over in about twenty seconds. And then without any further details the show comes to an abrupt end leaving the viewer wanting.

Another thing about the episode that seemed amiss - was one of the members on the posses, Toomey, did not even want to search for Mark. He even went as far to say that Mark was already as good as dead. Was not sure why they wasted time on things that had little, if any, to do with the situation.

The concept was an interesting story, the production was a waste. Agree with the others on this episode.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed