"The Rifleman" The Shattered Idol (TV Episode 1961) Poster

(TV Series)

(1961)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Had a lot of potential but missed the mark.
kfo949414 March 2016
Since North Fork is the crossroads of the world, we get a visit from none other than Mark Twain. And when the stagecoach needs repair, this will keep Mark Twain in town for a few days to the joy of one of his biggest fans, Mark McCain.

But things does not go how Mark McCain wanted. It seems that Twain is having some issues with his young son's death and McCain is devastated as his idol does not live up to his reputation.

I am sure this sounded like a nice idea when the writer was making this into a teleplay. But the way the story evolved around a pool table and some made-up information, the story seemed dull. There was a lot of potential with this story but it seemed that the writer took the wrong path. Even when the episode ended, it was difficult to comprehend what the story accomplished. Had it not been for the acting by Johnny Crawford and Kevin McCarthy, this could have been disaster. An average offering to say the least.
10 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Let's fake history!
grizzledgeezer10 May 2013
Warning: Spoilers
I've given this episode a low rating, because it blatantly ignores historic fact, and is a cheap attempt to get the McCains involved with A Famous Person.

Samuel Clemens, in this case. Clemens shows up at the McCains' door when a coach axle breaks. He's even crankier than usual, because He Carries A Heavy Weight In His Heart -- in this case, the death of his son Langdon from pneumonia. He blames himself because he let Langdon get chilled during a carriage ride, while he was thinking of literary matters.

This is totally bogus. Langdon died of diphtheria, about 15 /years/ before this episode occurs.

Of course, with the help of Lucas and Mark, Samuel Clemens Learns An Important Lesson. (The mind boggles at the thought of how the series would have handled a visit from Walt Whitman. The "Doctor Quinn, Medicine Woman" * Whitman episode was a notorious disaster.)

Kevin McCarthy does a decent job as Clemens -- though one wonders whether any attempt was made to get Hal Holbrook, who even then was well-known for his Twain impersonation. (As I write this, he's been performing "Mark Twain Tonight!" for 59 years!)

* The greatest series title in TV history. It's such perfect self-parody it can't be improved on.
7 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed