"The Twilight Zone" The Changing of the Guard (TV Episode 1962) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
49 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
"The Changing of the Guard" an emotional piece
chuck-reilly21 February 2008
Warning: Spoilers
One of the more emotional and thought provoking entries in the "Twilight Zone" series, "The Changing of the Guard" stars Donald Pleasence as Professor Ellis Fowler, a long-time teacher who is being forced to retire due to his advancing years. Feeling that his life and work have been all for naught, the good professor contemplates suicide until he enters the "Zone." He is soon visited by many of his past students, some of whom are already deceased. They inform their former teacher that if it wasn't for the lessons they learned from him, their lives would have had much less meaning and fulfillment. For the first time in his life, Fowler receives some belated but deserved gratitude for a job very well done. He decides that a "Changing of the Guard" is in order now. The story ends on a highly-charged emotional note, and it's nearly impossible to watch without getting a few tears in your eyes.

Pleasence gives an admirable performance here and he never allows his character to be overly sentimental. He hits just the right notes as a man who discovers his true self-worth just in the nick of time. Pleasence was an under-rated actor in his day and "Changing of the Guard" was a great venue for his abundant talent. The story was written by Rod Serling and the subject matter was obviously close to his heart. At the end of Serling's days in Hollywood, he went back to upstate New York and did some teaching himself.
58 out of 61 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
"I would be brave, for there is too much to dare".
classicsoncall16 June 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Inevitably for a series like The Twilight Zone, there would eventually be a story that dealt with the theme of suicide. Actually, this wasn't the first one for Serling; back in the second season 'Long Distance Call' might have broken some ground when it broached the subject of childhood suicide at the behest of a departed family member. The topic is never an easy one, and here it's done with understated elegance. As the aging college professor involuntarily retired from his position at an all boys academy, Donald Pleasence turns in a bittersweet portrayal that's sure to affect the viewer emotionally. I try to think back to the year this show was first aired in 1962. At that time, World War II was only a seventeen year memory. The mention of Pearl Harbor and Iwo Jima might have resonated more strongly with viewers of that era, but as my interest and research into that period of history grows with time, I found myself even more touched by the accolades accorded by Professor Fowler's students. I dare say, there were more tears in my eyes with each recognition of the teacher's achievements than in those of the teacher. For his part, Rod Serling might have written in some small measure his own epitaph in quoting Horace Mann, having with this story 'won some small victory for humanity'.
52 out of 55 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Wow...Donald Pleasence did a great job...
planktonrules2 October 2009
Warning: Spoilers
While Donald Pleasence made a few stinkers that might some might remember (such as his appearance in HALLOWEEN II), he was still a very good actor. His role as a wistful aging professor who is forced to retire is a wonderful job of acting, as his little soliloquies are quite compelling. So good, in fact, that I wish he'd done more episodes of the series.

"Changing of the Guard" begins with Pleasence teaching a class of seemingly indifferent students. After the class ends, he is informed that he is being forced to retire after 51 years of teaching. Sadly, that evening he sits and thinks about his life--imagining that it was wasted--that he influenced no one and made no difference in any lives. However, in a GOODBYE MR. CHIPS moment, ghosts of his dead former students come and tell him about the way they changed their lives for the better. It's all very sentimental and lacks some of the typical "Twilight Zone" ironic twists you might expect, but it was made so well this can be overlooked.
55 out of 63 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I get choked up whenever I see this
john-57927 November 2006
I've lost count of the number of times I've seen this particular episode and it always always always chokes me up when I see it. It's worse now that I'm older, but I figure that that's due to our becoming more emotionally incontinent as we age.

I've a teacher from 35 years ago who's still alive who I continue to be close to. The episode is a great reminder to everyone to find the teacher that made a difference to their life and thank them for the ways in which they made your life better. (You have no idea how good it'll make them feel.)

One other great thing about this episode is the pleasure of seeing the late Donald Pleasance doing anything. Honestly, he could've read a phone book on camera for half an hour and it'd be worth watching. :)
147 out of 150 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
We Can Make a Difference
Hitchcoc10 December 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I'm sure there are a lot of teachers who weigh in on this episode. I've been teaching for 39 years and one of the most gratifying parts of the job is when I see my previous students years later. There are times when we wonder, as the professor does, if what we say and do makes any difference. Obviously, the subject matter is what we gage our success on, but it's really the character of the people that count. Rod Serling must have known this and presented it so well. The Professor has been let go after a particularly hard day, distracted students and so on. He drops into depression, seeing his life as meaningless. He stands by a statue of Horace Mann, the father of modern education, and puts a gun to his head. Then, miraculously, the bells begin to ring at the school. When he enters his room he is met with a great surprise.

This is a touching episode. Had it not been the Twilight Zone, it would have made a wonderful drama. Donald Pleasance's acting is superb. It is understated and emotional. It's just a beautiful. Personally, this may be my favorite of all the Zones.
105 out of 110 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Best of the Un-Twilighty TZ's
AltairIowa14 May 2012
What has always drawn me to the Twilight Zone ever since I was a kid was the surreal twists that screwed some poor sap's fate. Tonight's episode on MeTV was one that I had never seen before, and it was very different from TZ's usual fare, and as a young college professor myself, it inspired me the way few things do. The great Donald Pleasance does a wonderful job learning what it truly means to be a professor and why we do the things we do. Sappy, yes. Sentimental, yes. Tear-jerking, yes. But the tears are tears of beauty at a truly beautiful Twilight Zone.

The central quote of this show (and it's a quote I've bookmarked) is Horace Mann's quote "Be ashamed to die until you have won some victory for humanity." The bane of our profession is the hollowness of what we do, with students going through the motions, absorbing just enough to regurgitate what passes for knowledge on the test, but not really learning anything. Or at least so we think. And, in academia, if we are taught one thing in grad school, it is how to think. How to question and double-think everything, including what we do for a living. We think we have no impact, where our impact is far, far deeper, as Donald Pleasance's character learns. Well worth the watch.
54 out of 57 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A bright and old mind has his heart touched when he sees the future of bright young minds!
blanbrn31 May 2007
Really this has to be one of the most touching and better "Twilight Zone" episodes in series history. Donald Pleasence who's such a legend and acting veteran stars as an old college professor, who's becoming angry with his male students at an all boys school. He sees the desire to learn just isn't present, and to make matters worse he finds out that the institution wants him to retire or be fired. So the depression sets in and the worry is starting that no students future will develop into a successful life because he now considers his teaching a failure. Yet that's why you enter the "Twilight Zone"! as his bright mind sees into the future and all of his students have became great success stories! Ending on a happy note, proving that all of us have been touched by knowledge at some point and we always will remember at least one teacher, and take something from them and remember it and use it as knowledge. Great episode that's touching and brings out your emotions.
68 out of 74 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One Of The Best!
mitchyalls12 May 2013
I absolutely love this particular episode,it's probably my favorite of the scores of great TWILIGHT ZONE offerings. It has no real twists or turns as one expects from the show,it's just a sweet,sentimental story that manages to hurt me every time I view it. Forty-two year old Donald Pleasence gives a great performance as Ellis Fowler,an older professor being discharged from his teaching position,which clearly is his entire life,what he lives/loves to do. He learns a little later that his assumed small contribution in the classroom spread much wider than he ever knew. I've read it was Pleasence's first American television appearance.
44 out of 47 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Mr. Chips is shown his worth
bkoganbing14 May 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Donald Pleasence who mostly has played some of the worst villains on screen gets to play an aging English teacher in a prep school who is told that he has to retire after about 50 years on the job. This episode is so good I would never say it was ripped off, but it certainly was a gentle homage to James Hilton's Goodbye Mr. Chips.

I can only think of one other good guy that Pleasence ever did in his career and it was one of the escapees in The Great Escape. Here he's been told by headmaster Liam Sullivan that it's time to retire, but he will be on half pay for the rest of his life. Pleasence takes it as a reflection on himself as a teacher and concludes he's not really accomplished much of anything.

But as he's about to commit suicide he gets a visit from some of his pupils in the past and realizes just what influence and for the good he's had on the young men he's taught.

This episode is Donald Pleasence's and being cast against his normal type shows what a fine actor that man was. This episode will move the lions at the 5th Avenue library to tears.

Pleasence's performance and a fine story and script make this one of the best Twilight Zone episodes ever.
52 out of 57 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Well-Done Human Interest
dougdoepke23 January 2017
Elegiac entry, tastefully done. Elderly Professor Fowler has taught at boy's school for a half- century. Now the Board of Directors has decided to replace him with a younger scholar. Convinced that his years have failed to reach his students, he contemplates an empty future and suicide.

I like the way Fowler's class of adolescent boys seems remote from his reflections on poetic wisdom. After all, how many hormonally gripped youths will tune into high-falutin' language. Then too, the prof. seems removed from the class as he quotes from pages of the greats. Thus, it appears the two worlds are sliding past one another, fruitlessly. But then we get a TZ reveal showing that things are not always as they seem.

Actor Pleasance manages to avoid a sentimental pitfall—he never gets maudlin. On the other hand, there's no action, nor special effects, or other eye-catchers of the series. I guess, my only reservation is with the crucial visitation scene that seems unduly bland. Anyway the narrative engages with human interest the whole way. And if the half-hour is not exactly memorable, it does remain trans-generational in appeal.
11 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Only took 37 episodes, but nice one!
bombersflyup12 November 2019
Warning: Spoilers
The Changing of the Guard is a poignant episode. You make your mark on people as you touch their lives and you live on through them. It's a nice message, though nothing much happens either.
4 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Simple but powerful
emguy13 April 2016
At a certain level, this episode is so simplistic you could capture the entire plot, with the ending, in a single sentence. A lesser production would have delivered a treacly bit of fluff, padded out to fill the time slot. But Donald Pleasence turns the story into a powerful tale that puts a knot in my throat.

This one's not about the plot. It's about the character. It's about dedication to a purpose even though you may never find out if you were successful.

This episode is among my favorites. Maybe it's all the teachers in my family. Maybe it's the teachers I wish I could tell about their positive impact on me, or the teachers I've been able to tell.

(P.S. If this was written grammatically, it's thanks to Mrs. Prokopik in the 7th grade, and Mr. Carroll on the high school newspaper.)
37 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Darker Mr. Chips
cjskama-956-5157062 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
"The Changing of the Guard" appears to be Rod Serling's version of "Goodbye Mr. Chips," the award-winning 1939 movie. Both the movie and the show center around an elderly teacher at a private school who wonders if he has made any impact on the world or his students. Of course, the movie had much more time to develop Chips, while CotG only gives us a brief glimpse of Fowler. Also, the movie has a warm feel to it, while CotG is much darker as Fowler contemplates suicide. But in the end both Chips and Fowler come to realize that yes, indeed, they had a positive impact on their students, many of whom died in combat over the years.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Man Of Consequence
AaronCapenBanner29 October 2014
Donald Pleasance is outstanding as Literature Professor Ellis Fowler of the Rock Springs School For Boys, who has been teaching there for 51 years, but now, just before Christmas vacation, is informed by his sympathetic headmaster that he faces mandatory retirement. Shocked and disheartened by this news, Fowler goes into a depression, and considers suicide for what he considers a failed life, but the timely intervention of departed but appreciative former students give him a lesson he'll never forget... Wonderfully realized story is both touching and authentic, with a distinctive holiday mood that distinguishes this exquisite episode. Last of the third season would prove to be ironically titled, since series went on hiatus before returning in a new hour-long format.
32 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Christmas Carol in reverse
joerushhead-125 November 2011
Warning: Spoilers
This is a great episode. As one stated, Donald Pleasance could read a phone book for 30 minutes and it would be worth watching. I couldn't agree more. I have always admired his approach and this just nails it. It seems to me that it has undertones of the "A Christmas Carol". As he recalls his former students, and how he affected their lives, He feels as if there was no affect whatsoever. He seemed to find joy at the idea of shaping the coming youth with his teachings. At the prospect of losing this, he contemplated ending it all. His 'spirit' guides tell him he did more than he knew. For them to change his ideas; Not one of a miserly old codger, but of someone who loved his job. I delight in watching this episode.
30 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
I suddenly feel sorry for all my old teachers...
Coventry24 May 2021
The last handful of episodes leading up to the finale of the third season "The Twilight Zone" were truly weak and disappointing (especially "I Sing the Body Electric" and "Cavender is Coming"), so I'm utterly relieved the actual last one is again a brilliant one. This is largely thanks to the flawless performance of the downright amazing Donald Pleasence, and the great plot. True, the story is rather sentimental, and I usually don't like sentiment in "The Twilight Zone", but the identifiable "Changing of the Guard" genuinely moved me. Pleasence depicts the ageing teacher Ellis Fowler, who's forced to go into retirement on the last day before the Christmas break. Fowler promptly sinks into a mental depression, because teaching is all he has, and especially because he suddenly realizes that he hasn't made the tiniest difference in any of his former students' lives. He intends to end his own life, but suddenly hears the school bells chime and gets lured to his classroom for a very special type of reunion.

Donald Pleasence, already one of my favorite actors of all times, is truly genius here. He plays an old man, and yet I think it's the first time - ever - I've seen him with hair. His character, Fowler, supposedly has 51 years of experience as teacher. So, that must make him at least 70 years of age, and yet Pleasence was only 42-year-old when this episode got aired on television. Still, I wouldn't want anyone else to play the lead role in this intelligent, thought-provoking and mesmerizing "Twilight Zone" Christmas Carol.

"Changing of the Guard" made it into my personal top five of the third season, at #4, together with "The Shelter" (#1), "One More Pallbearer" (#2), "To Serve Man" (#3), and "Deaths-Head Revisited" (#5).
18 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the best TZ episodes ever
postaldude101322 February 2017
"Changing of the Guard" was, for me, one of the most moving and uplifting Twilight Zone episodes ever. Donald Pleasence is a fine actor one of the best. I can relate to Prof. Fowler's thoughts and emotions I graduated from college with a degree in Music and taught several students privately but I was never sure if my teaching was working. I taught private voice lessons. I struggled with one student who couldn't understand the mechanics of singing. But I did have a small victory just like Prof. Fowler. A former student, a soprano, called me one evening and thanked me for teaching her. She told me my training helped her become a lead singer in her church choir. For all of you in the teaching profession, keep plugging away and you will all win "small victories for mankind".
28 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Superb
grantss24 May 2020
After teaching for 50 years at the same school, Professor Fowler is forced to retire. He does not take this well and contemplates suicide, considering his life a failure.

One of the best episodes of The Twilight Zone. This coming immediately after one of the worst, the silly, slapsticky 'Cavender is Coming'. Just when I thought Rod Serling was phoning it in, he comes up with one of the most wonderfully sentimental episodes of all. It reminds me of 'It's a Wonderful Life' and 'Dead Poet's Society', it's that warm and profound.

A great way to end Season 3.
22 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Donald Pleasence shines in this touching episode
Woodyanders20 July 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Aging Professor Ellis Fowler (beautifully played by Donald Pleasence) is forced to retire after putting in 51 years at a college. Fowler contemplates suicide that night because he feels that he has failed to make a difference in the world. However, a surprise visit from the spirits of several deceased students teach Fowler a valuable lesson about his own self worth.

Director Robert Ellis Miller adroitly crafts a gentle sentimental mood as well as makes nice use of the Christmastime setting. Rod Serling's thoughtful script makes a poignant and pertinent point on how the measure of a man's life can be gleaned from the sheer number of people said man made a positive lasting impact on throughout his existence. However, it's Pleasence's extremely sweet and understated performance that makes this particular episode so special: Pleasence gets a rare chance to show a surprisingly tender and vulnerable side that's a true touching revelation to behold. A lovely show and a worthy closer to the third season.
21 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
"I gave them...nothing."
meansphene23 December 2018
"The Changing of the Guard" is the Twilight Zone at its most unabashedly sentimental. A professor at an upper class boys' school is forcibly retired after more than 50 years of teaching. As Professor Fowler reflects on his career, he becomes convinced his lessons gave nothing of value to his students and concludes he has been a failure. With no future to look forward to, and no past to comfort him, he returns to the campus one final time, to commit suicide. Yet, he will find that his past, of which he is so deeply ashamed, is not so easily escaped.

In this installment, Rod Serling once again relied on a formula with which he'd have amazing success throughout the entire run of The Twilight Zone: the transformation of a sensitive, disillusioned man by way of an extraordinary or even supernatural encounter. As I've noted in other TZ reviews, some of Serling's best episodes were based on a character such as this, and in most of these episodes, a brilliantly cast lead actor allowed Serling's writing to reach its full flower. This time, the incomparable Donald Pleasence was front and center as Ellis Fowler in a portrayal that was deeply emotional without being maudlin. It wasn't often Pleasence had the chance to play someone so sympathetic, and it's a real shame another role couldn't have been found for him in the series. His work in "The Changing of the Guard" is easily among the finest performances ever to grace the Twilight Zone.

This episode was originally broadcast in summer, but its tender themes combined with a Christmastime setting makes this an ideal holiday watch. Ably supporting Pleasence are Liam Sullivan and Tom Lowell just before his first big movie appearance in "The Manchurian Candidate". "The Changing of the Guard" sits right alongside "The Night of the Meek" as being an outstanding holiday-themed episode despite its aggressive playing of the heartstrings. 9.0/10.
21 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
sweet but insubstantial
HelloTexas112 March 2009
Warning: Spoilers
One of the Twilight Zone's quietest episodes, 'The Changing of the Guard' belongs to a sub-category within the series marked by shows like 'Walking Distance' and 'A Stop At Willoughby.' These are all stories, inevitably written by Rod Serling, which are ruminations on life and what is truly important. The main character, always an ordinary average man, usually begins the episode unhappy with his life and by the end finds some reason to feel fulfilled. So it is with Donald Pleasance's Professor Ellis Fowler, who finds himself forced into involuntary retirement and is convinced his life's work has been meaningless, until he is told otherwise by the ghosts of dead students. There's no denying it's a sweet, sentimental episode with a gentle performance by Pleasance, but it needed something more substantial to make it memorable. One gets the impression that Serling could write these kinds of stories in his sleep, and that's almost where the episode puts us. This was the last episode of the third season; it seems the show and Sterling were beginning to run out of steam.
8 out of 62 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Literary Quotes in this Segment
mark-zecca2 January 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Professor Fowler makes several literary quotes during several sequences. As the main character, he is portrayed as the tough professor with a velvet hand and warm heart, that finds himself forced to retire. There is a theme, several to be exact, that runs through this story. One is that organizations ambivalent to the feelings of there members. The message is that value is somewhat timed and despite contribution there is a "time" when all things must be new again. Another theme is that the human condition many times suffers from under appreciation of its own worth. This is a supported cultural force in society, but sometimes introspection is necessary to see the affect and the value one adds to their environment. The literary quotes were wonderful in this segment. I am looking for an author/Poet by the name of Mann I think.There was a particular quote of personal virtues that Professor Fowler made. I can't find a script for this show to look them up. Does anyone have a better memory or can reference some of those quotes?
29 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Tremendous Episode
ramsfan28 January 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Changing of the Guard is rarely discussed when talking about the all-time classic Twilight Zone episodes, but it should be, such is its quality. Rod Serling's poignant story is a touching and emotional testament to age and perceived irrelevance. When Professor Ellis Fowler, a teacher at a Boys Prep School is told his contract won't be renewed after 51 years of service, he is devastated. Feeling himself "an abject, miserable failure", Fowler begins to brood and ruminates on past lessons that were important to him but to no one else. Convinced he's made no impact on the lives of past students, he takes a pistol into the courtyard one evening and contemplates suicide. He is startled by the sound of school bells and retreats to his classroom, where a number of his ex-pupils appear. Each long dead, they present themselves and share personal stories of bravery and accomplishment- acts made possible by the lessons Fowler had taught them. As the apparitions disappear and with a mix of awe and astonishment, a tearful and humbled Fowler is now ready to accept retirement- content that he has indeed made an impact on so many.

As Fowler, actor Donald Pleasence is tremendous- at first devastated at his forced retirement but later secure in the knowledge he's indeed been a valued faculty member whose teachings have shaped lives. Count me among the many teachers for whom this personally resonated. A very underrated TZ episode, and a must watch.
19 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of Rod Serling's little victories
darrenpearce1116 December 2013
A meaningful, emotional,and absolutely life affirming offering from Serling. Rather quietly done with a 42 years old Donald Pleasance brilliantly playing an old teacher who tried to make education an inspiring force for good for boys. His life seems over when he hears it's time to retire. If you take time to think about this story and about the courage of such very young men in who died in WW2 (we owe our freedom today from fascism to them) I cannot imagine a more worthy subject than this. Literature is shown to be a mighty force and the essential message here is how important remain the deep, fine, unselfish words that motivate . A genuinely moving TZ that shows where humanity's hope resides - and it is not in ignorance and dumbing-down.

A tremendous, lovable fantasy-drama that I profoundly recommend you watch.
23 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great Television
june-sasser24 December 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I never realized the true awesomeness of Pleasance until today when I caught this on MeTv. The writing was above the bar as well. Mr. Pleasance really taught an acting course in this one. A lesser actor could have made this into schmaltzy drivel. Instead it was thought provoking, cathartic theater at it's best. As a man approaching old age, it made me think about the kind of influence, if any, that one might have on young people in one's life.
18 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed