When Linda Wolfe goes to the credit card office to talk about all the strange disappearances, Catherine Foley, the Credit Card Manager states "Earlier this week we took your cat and your dog" but the dog was taken at least nine days after the cat and the visit to the credit card office took place well after that. The Wolfe's bought their refrigerator two days after the cat disappeared. The dog disappeared at least 8 days after the refrigerator was purchased (It took a week to be delivered and the dog disappeared when Linda Wolf was loading it) The visit to the credit card office was at least 12 days after the cat was taken.