"Upstairs, Downstairs" A Voice from the Past (TV Episode 1972) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Sarah returns!
arrival14 July 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Any episode of 'Upstairs, Downstairs' featuring Pauline Collins as 'Sarah' has to be entertaining, and this is one of the very best! Sarah is found starving in a Soup Kitchen run by Elizabeth Bellamy. Elizabeth does not recognise Sarah, due to the fact she was away at school in Germany when Sarah was previously employed by her family. James however, does recognises her. Consequently, Elizabeth brings her back to Eaton Place and re-employs her whilst her parents are away. One problem; there's only one vacancy, and that's for 'Scullery Maid'! Sarah is given the job. Apart from the fact she believes she is 'above' the position, the rather 'snooty' Alice - who having taken her place, is somewhat jealous, and so some very entertaining and quarrelsome scenes ensue - including an amusing 'cat-fight' in their attic! This type of episode was pretty unique to the very first series, and these kinds of stories did not feature often in subsequent seasons.

Sarah, as usual, causes quite a stir - both 'upstairs' and 'down' once more! She attempts to hold a seance and to conjure up the voice of dead Emily who hanged herself some months before. She conveniently schemes to push Alice out of her old job as parlour maid, and out of the house, so that she can be reinstated sharing the attic bedroom with Rose once again! She succeeds with aplomb! Not to be missed! NOTE: Though most die-hard fans believe that the mix up regarding the dates the series and episodes were set in started in season two, in reality, it actually started further back than that, with a much earlier episode as this! Anyone who follows the series closely, will note some mistakes at around this time in the run. For example; it's supposed to be 'Autumn 1908' (according to the caption read on the opening titles) but apart from the fact that Hudson is off to Scotland to the family who are there for 'grouse shooting' (which is worth noting, can be as early as August anyway) which could 'loosely' back up this date, other factors in the episode do point to it being somewhat 'earlier'. It's still actually 1907 in my opinion, since Mrs. Bridges' behaviour (and Hudson's towards her after her upset of the 'stolen baby' incident) is still pretty raw. Considering that had happened in November of 1907, and given the subject matter in this episode, it's hardly conceivable that this would have been almost a year on...
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A Voice from the Past
Prismark1023 November 2022
Warning: Spoilers
It is a popular held belief that Pauline Collins was so popular as Sarah that the audience demanded her return to the series.

The fact that she returns for episode 10 of series 1 indicates that her character's return was planned in advance. The series would have already been recorded before broadcast of the first episode.

Elizabeth Bellamy is doing her bit for the poor and running a soup kitchen. On a visit to the kitchen, James Bellamy recognises Sarah who is now downtrodden and down on her luck.

Elizabeth takes pity on her and Sarah is employed as a lowly scullery maid. Not a position she is happy with.

It is not long before Sarah plots her way into her old position. The ghost of the late Emily is cynically used by Sarah as she holds a seance.

This story is a good look at Sarah's scheming side. She might be down but never out for the count. Even her relationship with Rose is distant as Rose felt let down by Sarah.

By the end she manages to mellow Rose down as well. Sarah is a determined lady.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed