"Upstairs, Downstairs" Whither Shall I Wander? (TV Episode 1975) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
A true classic bows out with epic dignity.
granty-951719 November 2023
'Whither Shall I Wonder' was the template for many a series finale with its wonderful evoking of the end of an era, the sad parting of the ways, and finally a spot of reminiscing about a past that can never return.

It's Summer 1930 and the times are a changing under a new socialist government, and the days of large upper class households with lots of servants are in rapid decline. The Bellamys are not immune to this and are still reeling with shock at the tragic loss of James, while Georgina awaits the return of her fiance Lord Stockbridge, and unsurprisingly, the servants are feeling rather uneasy about their futures.

There are some genuinely touching moments, like Lady Bellamy telling Rose that she'd become one of the family, and Hudson presenting Edward with his pantry book, and it was nice to see aunt Prue return for the wedding. The final scene where Rose wanders from room to room in a now empty 165 Eaton Place provided a fitting end to this much loved classic.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Bellamy's pack up and leave...
arrival27 September 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Summer. 1930, This was the very last episode ever of the award-winning TV series 'Upstairs, Downstairs'. After five years of gracing our screens - and almost thirty in the actual story-telling, 'UD' finally came to an end having reached the summer of 1930, and the end of an era...

We see Georgina selfish and self-centred to the very last here, when all her concerns are for herself; the wedding that she can't pay for because James left debts (to hell with the way the poor man felt...) and her concerns as to whether or not she will be 'liable' for any of those debts... Charming! Whilst this episode is 'good', I have to confess at having been just a little disappointed at how it was done - particularly the final section (Part Three) when it is left to Rose to close up the house, and to wander through all the rooms reminiscing. Now, whilst I do not wish to sound 'overly sentimental', it seems to me, that someone like Rose would have had a few more 'flashbacks' than she actually did, and I suspect that many of these were cut short in view of the time and effort of searching for old tapes from earlier episodes for 're-dubbing'. Whilst this may have been a bigger job back then that it would have been today, I thought it was worth doing, as it is, we are left feeling not only 'cheated' having these scenes cut short, but also made to feel that somebody somewhere felt them not worth the time, trouble and expense, which to me is a great pity... For example; we only really get a couple of 'voices from the past' and both short 'snippets' from the very first ep. 'On Trial' featuring the voices of Sarah and Lady Marjorie. A couple more from slightly later on - and again, from the same ep. Apart from these, we only get 'snippets' from more recent episodes from James and Lily. It would have been nice to have seen Rose hearing perhaps Emily, more of Sarah, Hazel Bellamy perhaps, and some of the real drama that would most certainly have gone through the mind of Rose at such a time in her life...

However, it didn't happen - and a great opportunity lost in my opinion, which makes the closing episode to one the most significant British TV Shows, pretty 'unremarkable'...
10 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed