"Wagon Train" The Ben Engel Story (TV Episode 1964) Poster

(TV Series)

(1964)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Grover Cleveland redux
bkoganbing18 February 2018
Clu Gulager and John Doucette who both made several Wagon Train episodes are together in this story with Doucette in the title role. Doucette did something that got Grover Cleveland in a political jackpot , he paid a substitute to fight for him. One could do that during the Civil War. Doucette was three days short of 45 when the draft was instituted, a wealthy merchant with no family. He pays Gulager to substitute and Gulager goes on to be a hero with a medal from the Wilderness campaign. What their relationship is and its dynamics is the crux of this episode.

I could identify with Doucette. My granduncle, my grandmother's brother was 44 and unmarried and he had in fact served in World War I. He got a draft notice for the second war. You can imagine it upset him., fortunately he stayed stateside during WW2. Doucette was 3 days short of 45.

Gulager is married and his pregnant wife Katherine Crawford stayed with Doucette during the war and gave birth to their child who grew up to be Darby Hinton.

Gulager is one of those amoral and irretrievably evil people. He really enjoyed the war, he could kill legally. Some are like that. He also had a bad leg and walked with a limp. But physical standards weren't quite as high back in the day. Sergeant Boston Corbett who shot John Wilkes Booth in that burning barn where he was cornered had castrated himself and the Union Army took him, he even enlisted.

Gulager's performance will really creep you out. This is a Wagon Train episode with no happy ending other than the world was better off without Clu Gulager.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Keyser Soze !! Keyser Soze !!!
shermandemetrius4 January 2021
Long before Kevin Spacey played him, Clu Gallegar did. Only this time the meaning of the limp is explained and the story has a commentary on war, war heroes and greed. The best Wagon Train episode I can think of.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Let's make a Diel
jarrodmcdonald-128 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
This episode is obviously an allegory for Vietnam and how people were dodging the draft in 1964. We learn that John Doucette's character, Ben Engel, was able to buy his way out of serving in the Civil War, by pinning his duty on young Harry Diel (Clu Gulager). It was seen as the "right" thing to do, since it spared Diel from prison. Also it gave his wife (Katherine Crawford) a roof over her head with Engel while she was pregnant and Diel was off at war.

Dialogue in a key scene refers to the kinds of killing that are acceptable. Early on we have Coop (Robert Fuller) talk about men who kill because to destroy someone else gives them a sense of purpose and validates their own life. To which Chris Hale (John McIntire) replies that the services of such men are needed in times of war.

I couldn't help but think of Audie Murphy and other heroes known for massive killings in battle, who come home and are decorated with countless medals. In fact Harry Diel does just that-- he survives a wilderness battle and returns from his time in the army a respected and much-honored soldier. He's even given a medal from the president.

But as the story continues it is shown over and over just how much of a devil Harry Diel is. He seems to want everything that Ben Engel owns. In fact at one point Chris Hale realizes Diel means Devil in some European language. So when Engel (which means Angel) kills Diel at the end, it is presented as a form of justifiable homicide. Not sure if I buy into that. Does this mean upstanding members of society should go out and kill others they consider devils or demons? And it's okay?

The story is certainly heavy handed. Gulager's acting is very much in the vein of moustache-twirling villains. Every time we see Engel talking with Chris Hale, the camera cuts to a reaction shot of Diel, where Gulager gets a dramatic aside to remind us he's playing a bad character, with the actor smirking. Interestingly, at the top of the episode there's a line where Chris Hale tells Coop to smile when they encounter flooding and mud, so the train won't know what's really wrong.

In addition to the obvious villainy with Gulager, the story relies on extensive flashbacks covering the early part of Diel's relationship with Engel. This entire recollection of events plays out one night while others are dancing back in the main area of the camp. It ends with Diel getting his violent comeuppance, after we've seen how he had "valiantly" served his purpose in war. Wonder if his wife and young son kept his medal.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed