"Wagon Train" The Geneva Balfour Story (TV Episode 1964) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
They all lie and shade the truth
bkoganbing5 February 2014
This one was an interesting and entertaining episode of Wagon Train in which even the regulars lie or at best shade the truth some to keep the Train moving.

The army due to Indian trouble has declared the regular trail out of bounds. Which means that John McIntire is forced to use a desert route, a particularly bad route that Robert Fuller and Denny Miller both say is a rough cross.

McIntire buys extra supplies and they set out, but Sherry Jackson in the title role of The Geneva Balfour Story is a willful young bride who was spoiled rotten by her rich parents and in a moment of both fear and pique sets fire to those supplies halfway across.

After that McIntire and Fuller are forced into lies of different kinds trying to keep the people of the Wagon Train strong enough for the crossing and not ready to lynch Jackson. Her husband Peter Brown is willing to take the rap for her. And Robert Lansing who was a judge back east is a passenger challenging McIntire's authority.

It's a nicely done story about how even good people have to lie sometimes to accomplish their objective.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
*Spoliers*? Not really, but kinda. Yet another example of how the last 2 seasons of 'Wagon Train' tried to ruin the entire series
vnssyndrome899 November 2017
Warning: Spoilers
It's not that this episode was terrible, but it is certainly not up to the standards that made 'Wagon Train' a household name.

These episodes (from the last 2 seasons) DO NOT need to be almost an hour and a half long. They d--r--a--g out, until you almost lose interest. I don't know whose idea it was to extend the length of these shows, but it was a terrible mistake.

This episode is supposed to be focused on a spoiled pregnant woman from Boston, named Geneva Balfour. She is an unlikable harpy, who never wanted to go west, and never lets her husband forget it.

An Indian war forces the wagon train to take a dangerous detour through the desert. Chris Hale, the wagon master, makes sure to take on an extra wagon full of provisions. These supplies will be needed to take on this perilous journey.

The people of the wagon train know of the impending dangers, and Chris Hale even puts the decision to continue in their hands. They vote to press on west to California, thus absolving Mr. Hale of some of the responsibility of this somber decision.

Conditions worsen for the weary travelers, and Mrs. Balfour's mental stability worsens with them. She decides to force the train to turn back, by burning the extra supply wagon. Somehow, her husband gets blamed for this, and is almost lynched in the process. This whole incident seems to go nowhere, and is too soon forgotten.

The Chris Hale of previous seasons is now gone. He is replaced with a worrisome old ninny, who feels the need to lie to the people of the train, instead of reassuring them with his leadership and strength.

The rest of the trip is a disjointed mess, that makes little sense. There is a meddling judge, a group of obstreperous women, who become violent towards a pregnant woman, a miner who shoots Duke, but then saves the day, and yet another unstable woman, who attacks Chris Hale with a shotgun.

Like I said, a mess.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed