"Wagon Train" The John Wilbot Story (TV Episode 1958) Poster

(TV Series)

(1958)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Too Many Ingredients in this Soup
redryan6416 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
ONE OF THE peculiarities of Television series of the 1950's is that collectively they served as a sort of celluloid melting pot. The voracious appetite that weekly series production generated for acting talent brought a sort of cross era selection of people into the regular casts, supporting players and the 'guest star' categories.

AS AN UNINTENDED and not planned byproduct of this weekly breakneck scheduling, the casts of the individual weekly installments often boasted of a combination of players who were either on the way up, or had perhaps one time star status. So, in this episode, which is today's honored reviewee, WAGON TRAIN: The John Wilbot Story, had the benefit of the talents of Warner Brothers veteran actor Dane Clarke; as well as showcasing the abilities of a young Robert Vaughn.

AS FOR THE scenario of this episode, it may well have been an unusually intelligent episode if only the writer hadn't gone just a little to far. This is only our opinion, but that's what a review is by its very nature. (Right, Schultz?)

OIUR STORY: The Wagon Train is passing through territory inhabited by a known hostile Indian tribe, so Major Adams (Ward Bond), having determined that it would be advantageous to the caravan's safety to employ an advance scout, temporarily trades places with scout Flint McCullough (Robert Horton); whose shoulder was injured and currently in a sling. Adams temporarily appoints McCullough to the position of Wagon master, with Major Adams' taking the scout function.

WE LEARN THAT there are some passengers on the trip who are bitterly opposite contenders from the Civil War. There is also a very cultured man, who appears to have come from the theatrical world. This genteel man (Dane Clark) remains above the fray, offering some great Shakespearian quotations as peaceful bits of wisdom.

THIS IS WHERE we think that the story goes off of the deep end. The gentlemanly thespian (who limps noticeably) is accused of being JOHN WILKES BOOTH! THE HOUR-LONG teleplay is otherwise interesting as a vehicle for the young Mr. Vaughn; as well as for showing off some perhaps unseen talents as an actor. At one point it didn't even seem to be the same guy that we had seen in older feature films such as DESTINATION TOKYO.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the more interesting plots
jawlaw5 December 2018
This script, written by Richard Maibaum (who would later write most of the screen plays for the early James Bond movies), was based on 19th century suspicions that John Wilkes Booth (Lincoln's assassin) somehow survived his pursuers and hid out for the rest of his life.

It is hard to review this one without giving spoilers, so suffice it to say that the talents of Dane Clark, Robert Vaughn and Robert Horton produce a wonderful little drama that plays more like an episode of the Alfred Hitchcock Hour than an episode of Wagon Train. Other reviewers have been less kind to the script. In contrast, I think it was one of the best of all.
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
John Wilkes Booth?
bkoganbing2 November 2013
Dane Clark comes on board the Wagon Train in this episode as possibly none other than John Wilkes Booth who back in the day a lot of people thought escaped the burning barn he was trapped in. It was an urban legend back then, kind of like Elvis.

Anyway Clark is on the Train and he's a polished sort of gent, out of place among the pioneers. And he's a melancholy sort, giving out with an air of sadness. And he has the tantalizing name of John Wilbot.

On the Wagon Train itself are former Union and Confederate sympathizers ready to fight the war all over again. So when Tyler McVey finds an old newspaper clipping about the Lincoln assassination in Clark's volume of Shakespeare that gets everyone aroused.

McVey is the leader of the northerners, but his daughter Audrey Dalton is falling for the cultured Clark. Her behavior is truly astounding though.

Clark does fine in the guest star part, but the story is truly one of the more off the wall Wagon Train episodes.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed