"The X-Files" All Things (TV Episode 2000) Poster

(TV Series)

(2000)

User Reviews

Review this title
28 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Mobylicious
Muldernscully7 July 2007
all things is different. Plain and simple. If you are looking for a standard, creepy, mysterious x-file, you are not going to find it here. Gillian Anderson wrote and directed this episode that shows a side of Scully we haven't seen.

I like how Gillian gets the rhythm of the episode going with the dripping water. It sets the tone. The Moby music is different but nice. Mark Snow did a nice job of incorporating it into his score. Three is a significant number in this episode. I don't know why. I know that three is a good karmic number. The first slide shows three crop circles, Waterston's room number is 306. Colleen's house number is 3.

Gillian uses a lot of slow motion during the course of the episode, mostly to good effect. I thought the one unnecessary use of slow motion was when Scully was receiving the folder from the nurse. In the episode audio commentary Gillian said that it was hard getting the tapping pencil to be rhythmic. I agree.

I like how Scully hides from the daughter behind the magazine. The name of the magazine is Feng Shui Life Magazine. Hmmm. Once she goes into his room, there's this rhythmic pinging sound. I felt it was out of place. When she goes home, the toggle(I got this from the audio commentary as well) is knocking against the wall. The rhythms are nice when they are a natural sound, like the water dripping or the toggle knocking, but that pinging in his room is just out of place. Scully has a Mac with a web cam on the top of it. I never knew Scully was this techno-savvy. Who is she tele-conferencing with from home? Mulder?

Gillian's opening shots for scenes start with shots on a specific object then zoom out. As mentioned in her commentary, there are contrasts between the two hospital rooms. #304 is red, brown, warm, and happy. #306 is blue, dark, and sad. Nice use of contrasts.

My favorite line of Scully's is when she's saving Waterston's life. "Who's paying attention?!?!?" Taking control. Just like in the movie. After he goes into a coma, it looks like a music video as Scully walks into a D.C. Chinatown. I like how the creaking sign interrupts the music. The scene of the transparent Waterston was weird. Gillian said that her vision in the Buddhist temple was her attempt at adding a paranormal aspect to the episode.

Another thing I dislike about the episode is Scully having the guy come in to do the new age/psychic kind of healing of Waterston. It is out of character for her. That's something her sister Melissa would of done, not Scully. Scully's dream sequence is kind of freaky. I like how later the shot transitions from the back of Waterston's head to Scully's head.

It's interesting how the pony-tail lady turns into Mulder at the end. However, the jacket and hat that Mulder is wearing are not his color or style. It is out of character for him. Although, I do like his hat "Stone Henge Rocks".

Lastly, some additional items from GA's commentary. She had to shorten her script considerably. Her original script made it more obvious that she did not have an affair with Waterston. She broke it off when she found out he was married so that she wouldn't break up his family. However, it was too late. Waterston's wife suspected he had an affair and hung herself. Gruesome. Also, the cardiac arrest scene was originally one shot like in 'Triangle', but GA had to do close-ups to add more drama to the scene. And finally, Gillian says she loves the final scene of the episode.

This is a good hour of television. Gillian Anderson does so me interesting camera work that is not standard for the X-Files. The few things that are out of character for Mulder and Scully and the lack of it being a traditional x-file prevents it from being in the top tier of X-Files episodes. all things is not everyone's cup of tea, for sure, but it shows that Gillian Anderson can do more than just act.
61 out of 76 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Intangible Emotions
radioheadrcm1 April 2009
How do we convey profound connection to an 'other'? How can we feel strongly towards spirituality that we don't believe in? Why do we feel obligated towards figures of the distant past? How can a simple situation overwhelm us?

All Things deals with one of the most difficult objects to film: intangible emotions. Emotions that go beyond being sad, happy, or confused. Emotions that make you sit down and really think out: "What the hell was I just feeling?" I've read comments about this episode that complain that it isn't an X-File. In the tradition of Ray Bradbury's Martian Chronicles, I ask: Why explore other worlds when there is so much of ourselves left unexplored? How well do we really understand these vague, alien dynamics we feel towards ourselves and others? Gillian Anderson offers a depictions of these difficult emotions through original and deeply artistic direction, paired with masterful acting.

On top of that, All Things provides an new and interesting lens through which we can view Scully. She can seem utterly in control of her environments and competent as an individual, yet internally feel lost, confused, and perhaps helpless. Unfortunately, this is a concept that seasons eight and nine failed to follow through with. Instead, we are to settle with just one brief, beautiful glimpse into the potential of Scully's character. All in all, this isn't the slickest X-File, but it is certainly the most emotional for me. Submit to Gillian Anderson's artistic vision and she will show you the way.
36 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The Sky is Broken
Sanpaco1326 July 2007
All things is a very good episode even if it is not so much an X-File. While it is not necessarily my usual choice of entertainment (ie a little too new age-ish) I still enjoy learning about Scully in this episode. They way I see it there's some kind of guardian angel that is causing seemingly random events so that Scully can learn a lesson and realize what she is supposed to be doing with her life. I love that part where the ponytailed girl turns into Mulder and he's wearing the Stone Henge Rocks cap. What a nerd. This also serves as a confirmation for Scully that she is doing the right thing with her life since she is led back to Mulder at the end. Another high point for this episode is the awesome "The Sky is Broken" by Moby. I love that song and I love the scenes where they play it and show Scully walking in slow motion down the street with the flowers dangling at her side. I give this episode an 8/10.
36 out of 49 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Get ready to be caught off guard...
lotr_freak5143 July 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I was not expecting All Things. Although it hardly seemed like an X-file Gillian Anderson took Scully to a whole new level with this episode. This episodes shows a more unguarded, less scientific view of the character Scully. I thought it was very creative and allowed Scully something she had not been given in the past: flaw. For once it wasn't her medical knowledge being put to the test, or her morals, or her religion, it was her womanhood. And if you're a shipper like I am you will love this episode for a whole other reason, too. *wink*

Apart from the character development I thought the episode itself in the way it was written and directed (Love you Gillian) was very creative and very different from the previous X-files styles we had been shown. It threw me for a loop, and I was not disappointed.
28 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Watchable, if a bit slow.
Sleepin_Dragon23 September 2022
When Mulder gets set for a trip to England, Scully accidentally discovers that former lover Daniel Waterston is in hospital, seriously ill.

Very different, I can imagine that this one divides fans, don't come here expecting intrigue, suspense or chills and thrills, this one is out and out melodrama, an affair of the heart, not even an X Files twist.

I have to be honest, I was a little disappointed, I was excited to see Mulder and Scully in England, I wanted to see if they'd be there for real, or if it would have been done in the style of Murder she wrote, with a London bus and taxi somewhere in the middle of L. A.

We get to learn that Scully has a penchant for the more mature gentleman, and I have to admit, I thought Anderson was awesome throughout.

The daughter did my head in, Maggy was the most irritating, stroppy character, she stormed out of the room in every scene, bar one.

Moby didn't half get some of his awesome music played on the show, I've heard his tunes a few times.

I wouldn't want episodes like this one to come along too often, but it wasn't a bad watch, 6/10.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
This is a great insight into Scully's past and psychological make up
angelog-314 April 2007
In my opinion this is one of the best episodes on learning about Scully's life. There are two types of episodes. Those with special effects and UFOs -the signature of the X-Files-, and those where we learn more on the life and psychology of the characters -Molder and Scully. This one falls into the latter category. I love this episode because I can learn about Scully's past. One where she is emotionally involved in a forbidden affair, where she loved passionately. Also, the music used in this episode gives a really special touch as well as the use of images make and camera angles makes it very interesting, in my opinion. Although it is not a typical X File episode,I must admit, and I really enjoy it a lot. I have seen it in several re-runs and I still like it, more and more. Scully's performance is great. She shows a new side of her, one where she displays confusing and contradicting emotions. Psychologically is very interesting, which is the main perspective of the episode. Also as I said before, the song chosen for this episode is great. I bought it on itunes. I like the filmography and the notion of time-splitting that is presented in this episode. In summary, I recommend it, but I warn fans of the X Files to look at this episode with different eyes. In summary, I like it!!!
40 out of 58 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
another side to Scully
paltrow38912 February 2007
Like the above poster, this is far from my favorite episode - either when it aired or watching it again all these years later. Parts of it are way too touchy-feely and smack of pop psychology, and the slo-mo effects are little gimmicky. At times, it feels like a music video (though a nicely done one) with bits of drama and narrative thrown in.

But seeing it again, I appreciate that it gives us a different glimpse of Scully. Like many females, I loved Scully's intelligence and determination throughout the series, but in this episode, it was nice to see her passion too, even if it also means she might not be perfect in her choices. Finally, she gets to respond to impulses that aren't governed by logic or science! Preceding X-Files writers (Glen Morgan and James Wong, especially) were instrumental in making Scully her own person, independent of Mulder, but leave it to Gillian Anderson herself to force the question of Scully's life outside of the X-Files.
27 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
I Really Liked This Epiisode, Despite Many Reasons Not to
loudprincess13 April 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Up until last night, I would have sworn that I had watched every last episode of The X-Files. I thought I knew every last bit of trivia, all the funny lines, and all of the critically important shifts Scully and Mulder's characters had taken.

LAst night, All Things was on the SciFi channel, and it was almost like I was watching an entirely different series. Suddenly, the forever stoic, consistently skeptical Scully was a home-wrecker, and shaky about her faith in science. Maybe this is the pivotal episode that started all the "I believe in extreme possibilities" rants from Scully later in the series. Maybe this is the one point that I missed over the years, when I watched the episodes out of chronological order, and couldn't understand how Scully began taking over Mulder's mission for herself.

At any rate, let's go over the reasons why I shouldn't like this episode. One, Scully, through a weird twist of happenstance, finds that the man she once had an affair with is in the hospital with serious heart problems, and his daughter makes it blatantly obvious that she blames Scully for the emotional devastation the affair caused the family.

For as far back as I can remember Scully has always been the one with the high moral barometer in any situation, so it's a little difficult to digest that she would be so judgmental of, say, Skinner in Avatar.

Two, Scully learns that this man has spent the last ten years of his life living in D.C., in order to be near her again. How could she have not known about this before? She's an FBI agent, for crying out loud. She has access to all kinds of information an just about anyone she chooses, but she never figures this out before? And he never tried to contact her before? A little unbelievable.

Three, at one point, Scully finds herself wandering into a Buddist Temple, and having a big vision of her personal choices and circumstances. Now, remember, this is Scully, who's trademark is a golden cross pendant became a big symbol for her over the years. And God only knows how many times she's talked about her faith in miracles and Catholic mythology. So how can she so easily drop a lifelong faith in Christianity to suddenly be in awe of Taoist mysticism? This leads to the fourth point...Scully, after having this big epiphany, brings in a mystic healer to help her former boyfriend, and then tells him that this ritual may have saved his life. Wh-wh-what?? Seriously? Our Scully???? But now that I've explained why I shouldn't like this episode, I need to explain why I liked it so much.

It's beautifully directed, there are great, deep moments of clarity for Scully, that probably had never really been explored before, and, despite my personal love of the fact that she is the moralist of the show, it makes Scully seem more human.

There were some moments in the show that made me think I was watching Six Feet Under, and maybe that tone drew me into this installment. Yes, there's liberal use of music, and there's the recurring theme of one of the characters chasing someone who seems to be leading them to a place of significance. However, I do think it adds to the story, rather than being distracting. I'm not a huge fan of Scully or Mulder's voiceovers in episodes, but this one is short, and more to the point.

(For those who aren't familiar with X-Files and Gillian Anderson history, there was a HUGE following for Anderson after she recorded an erotic poem underscored by some electronica artist, and I think a lot of the episodes that used Scully in voice-over banked on that end of the fan spectrum.) Sure, it's not typical X-Files, and there are a lot of moments that are hard for X-Files junkies to buy into, but it's a nice diversion from some of the other installments that had become so predictable that you could set your watch for whenever certain moments would happen.
16 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Not my favorite
aurrora_australis12 December 2006
Warning: Spoilers
This episode tries to be very serious, with Scully narrating and trying to figure out why some things happen and other things don't. The whole episode is about how she almost ended up spending her life with some guy. First of all, I find it out of character for Scully to have had an affair with someone who was not only her professor from medical school, but was married! It is hard to swallow, given that she spent 7 years up to that point in a close working relationship with her single, attractive partner, which was never anything more than platonic. I really disliked that aspect of her history, since I think that kind of thing is repugnant. Second of all, the guy was creepy and at least 20 years older than her. They had ZERO chemistry together. Then, equally maddening was the implication that Mulder and Scully slept together for the first time in this episode, which I say did not happen. The episode is shot out of sequence, with Scully getting dressed in the morning and leaving Mulder's apartment in the beginning; in the end, which was the night before, he tucks her to sleep on the sofa and leaves the room. One could speculate all day, but it was there just to tease the shipper fans. Aside from that, it is hard for me to find fault or even to be objective when commenting on any episode of the X Files because I love it so much. I still watched this episode attentively, and I found it to be visually stunning. The Moby music set the mood nicely (as it did in Closure), and I did like the somber narration, and the fact that Gillian wrote and directed this episode. Watching this one makes me sad because it is not long afterward that the fans lose Mulder and have to endure a traumatizing upheaval of the X-Files. Anyway, that's my take on it.
29 out of 47 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
A confusing mess
treborbasset16 June 2021
An episode written by Gillian Anderson, in which she plays herself rather than Scully, which barely features Mulder, which is about a long lost love interest we have never heard of. This isn't even an episode of the X-Files, it's just some some hospital soap opera.

This guy we are supposed to care about means nothing to us, and the writing is all over the place. It was very difficult to follow and all a bit pointless.

The Taoism/Buddhism connection was also completely out of character considering Scully's strong history of Christianity in the show. Again, it was added because Gillian Anderson was interested in it. I think it's an interesting topic and I'm sure the writers could have come up with a real plot for it but it had no place in this episode, which itself has no bearing on the wider show. Just immediately forgotten as the silliness it is. Season 7 really is where The X-Files jumped the shark repeatedly.

The one saving grace of this episode is that it's better than the comedy/musical episode that David Duchovny directs two episodes later.
23 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
i love one scene in this episode
mail_her22 June 2007
there is this moment in the episode when you see such tenderness and longing in Scully -- a memory of a great love and loss... it is when she learns he has been in DC for all this time... i found it so incredibly tender... it so perfectly captured that moment we all have when we remember what was and what might have been... i am still blown away when i see the way she bends forward and touches his hand... the rest of the episode is a blur, just back fill. but that scene to me is priceless and makes this whole episode so utterly great... when you look at the first season (which would mean Scully had just ended the relationship a couple years before), she is young and driven and professional -- it's hard to imagine that she felt such passion and pathos... i wonder if she could only show it with the passage of time and realization of where she is at now...
23 out of 41 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Forgettable
pablo-colangelo25 June 2015
Warning: Spoilers
The teaser was totally unnecessary. The sexual tension between Mulder and Scully was interesting the first 150 episodes but now we know for sure that the usual thing is that nothing happens between them, which is OK. So, Gillian, if you are going to tease us with you getting dressed in the same room than Mulder, please make an episode worth the teaser and most importantly, a good ending. The episode ends like all episodes except one: nothing happens between them. Think about something better. I just felt fooled and hooked to watch an uninteresting episode, that had little to do with the teaser. Nothing paranormal here, Mulder has like 1 or 2 minutes on screen and the few moments we see him his behavior does not correspond with the character built in 7 seasons (dialogue, clothes, attitude) showing a poor script. But I think the worst thing is the main arc of the episode: Scully's past. It could have been interesting, but it isn't. We are not given enough info to feel something for this dying guy who no one cares about. There is no relationship with what has happened in the series so far. There are no consequences for the future. Definitely, not worth for a re-watch. Since Mulder almost doesn't appear and Scully didn't show up in the previous episode, I guess they managed to film these two at the same time to save the budget stupidly spent in "First Person Shooter" another forgettable Season 7 episode.
10 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Scully gets spiritual, possibly.
n-town-smash17 June 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Scully's past: let's find out about it!

Personally, I never cared about or even really picked up on the "will they? won't they?" tension that seemed to have been the hot water-cooler topic since the show began. Was it that hard to imagine that two people of opposite sexes could work together without Stuff Happening?

Whatever. "All Things" decides that, rather than continue with the occasional hints at the nature of Mulder and Scully's relationship offered over the last 7 years, we're just going to find out the story of how they first "did it". And we're going find out about it through the medium of some vaguely New Agey stuff, some repetitive tapping, and some guy who may have had an affair with Scully who is dying. As a sort of subplot to get rid of him, Mulder is now apparently really interested in crop circles.

There's a little more to it than that, but nevertheless, it's slow, plodding, perplexing fluff for the most part. Scully's spiritual awakening, if that's what it's supposed to be, is just weird, for the same reason that it's weird when she starts believing in aliens in later episodes despite being perfectly capable of ignoring overwhelming evidence and her own senses until then. Gillian Anderson's creative role in this episode is perhaps the source of this, since she seems to be playing herself rather than Scully a lot of the time.

The whole point of it seems to be: look out for the moments that change your life, and you might get laid.
35 out of 65 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An exploration of the other world we all live in.
lastcathar9 August 2015
"All Things" follows Dana Scully as she consciously drops out of her routine as the great skeptic, Mulder's straight-man, and instead is cast into circumstances entirely outside her expertise and experience, the spiritual, emotional, even the feminine aspects of this world. This is an entirely different, introspective interpretation of the X Files' fundamental theme of other world influences on human existence. In keeping with this "other world" theme, Scully finds herself dealing not with aliens and present dangers, but with the interconnectedness of all things, her own past decisions and their unintended consequences. And to reflect this mirroring of the usual X Files' storyline, the plot progression throughout this episode does not rely on causal connections and reasoning, but instead the plot is moved forward by synchronicity and emotion, the forces at work on the other side of all our lives. There is some exceptional cinematography in this episode, as for example in the sidewalk scene, unexpectedly broken like a dream by the creaking Apothecary sign. (Look up the etymology for the word. It's about things that are concealed, put away. The creaking sign represents Scully's awakening to aspects of her own life that she needs to recognize and come to terms with.)

"All Things" is a pretty spectacular first effort for writer-and-director Gillian Anderson, a bold re-formulation of the series' tried-and true thematic foundations. This episode also gives us the best use of music in the entire series. Moby's "The Sky is Broken" works to tie the tale together like The Dude's rug. "All Things" gets my vote as the most impressive episode of the entire X-Files series…and the runner-up is right down the road at "Hollywood A.D."
13 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Maybe sometimes nothing happens for a reason
sini-20012 April 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I really liked the premise of the episode, where it was going and of course the tension of the start . I liked the different pace from the usual X files episode, how Gillian Anderson chose to direct, but there was too many slow motion scenes for me. And the music was kind of weird at some points. But i liked the depth of Scully's past we got to dive into, even it could have told more about her history with Daniel to understand the whole story. I was disappointed of the ending the 'night before', because it gave nothing. The start, as one would assume, that Mulder and Scully slept together. But the episode ended with Mulder putting her to sleep with the blanket, like ? What. I was not expecting them to go there all the way, but even quick kiss could have hinted them sleeping together. Like okay I'm all for the hinting and subtlety, and the sexual tension - but at least give something when you are that kind of premise.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
amazing episode so spiritual
Elveon5 April 2020
Don't listen to haters this is in amazing episode both spiritual for tru believers this episode more than life , sometimes we need to stop rushing and see inside ourselfs into deepest mysteryies of our mind energy and soul, love it!
11 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
All Things.. that are unbelievable and stupid
crimsonsun-6048630 August 2018
Warning: Spoilers
One of the most icky 'Scully' episodes.. We learn of a former chapter in her life where she was apparently a lover to an older looking man who seems utterly unbelievable as a love interest to her. The dialogue between them is just awkward and incredibly icky (he looks like he could be her uncle or something). We see some prime Anderson over acting during the silly slow motion scenes and the 'spiritual awakening' scene that pops out of nowhere.. It's easily one of the worst episodes of The X Files - totally incoherent and near non existent 'plot', more pretentious Scully monologues, lame Moby 'esque (is it Moby??) music that's used incredibly amateurly to try to make Scully sexy and sultry (qualities that her character never had and just fall flat when suggested). Mulder's off looking at crop circles (it's easy to get rid of Mulder in any given Scully episode - just have him go off chasing some esoteric subject matter..) which turns out, conveniently, to be a dead end - actually the most interesting part of the episode because Mulder's rarely wrong about anything..
19 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
We knew she'd brains and now we get to see what's in her heart.
kbaever30 August 2018
The episode isn't brilliant but it isn't trash either. We get to see that Scully is far from flawless. If you're confronted with your past, you're forced to make peace with it and deal with your present life and choices. If all you want is the brainless entertainment you will hate this episode. I don't blame Gillian Anderson for wanting to give Scully's character more depth. We know Scully; the scientist, her morales, her loyalties and her religion. Now we get a peek at Scully; the woman.
8 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Hard to Follow
Bobby12324229 November 2020
This episode is extremely out of place, and hard to follow. None of it makes any sense in the greater scheme of things. A big letdown.
13 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Skully does not do Dallas
XweAponX1 April 2012
This Ep started out with Tension - The Sexual Tension which had been Held at Equilibrium for the previous 7 years. This Cardinal Rule was broken at the beginning of this Ep. But it was broken for a very good reason and an equally good episode.

The thing the two Leads in a Series ought to Never Do - And Skully was awkward with it for the rest of the Episode.

The interesting thing here is the way this is introduced, we are shown an image of a Morning After. What happened The Night Before is not mentioned. Not here, and not in the rest of the series, except for one episode of the 9th Season by someone whose knowledge of the event is as mysterious as they were.

We see right off the bat, Mulder is fine with this change in status between the two, but Skully-all of a sudden she is not as supportive of Mulder as she was previously. For the first time, she tells Mulder outright that this particular effort he wants to embark on is Worthless.

For the first time, Skully refuses to go to an X-File with Mulder, and what does he do? He's OK with it, he'll go by himself.

And leaves Skully with some suspiciously New-Age things to check out. A woman who makes Computer generated predictions of the variations on Mandelbrot Set that may be made into Crop Circles.

I don't know if Gillian Anderson is into New Age things, Skully is basically against these things. At least The Skully that Mulder met in Season 1 - She would refuse to grant any credibility to any form of alternate Medicine or Healing.

Which is what makes this a very interesting X-Files X-File. There are times when we need to stop the clock and see what is happening around us.

And so this is about, what Skully Would have done, and what Skully does do in the present time. It's about the Subtle changes a person goes through, it's never all at once, it's always gradual like this. In this Episode, the Herald of that change is the mysterious Woman with the White hat - Who becomes Mulder at the end of the Episode. Actually, not really the Herald of Change, but the Herald of the Knowledge that things have changed. Because Skully would have just gone about her business and never would have known anything had happened, except for the unusual circumstances in this episode.

The Skully of Season 1 never would have looked for a Holistic Healer - But this Skully in an almost out-of-character way brings the Holistic Healer to her friend.

Which means, it was out of character in the past - But it is not now.

How many times, have we said to ourselves, "I'd never do that" - Or of someone else, "They'd never do that" and then it gets done?

It's because we did not know ourselves or others as well as we thought.

Sometimes, little changes with a person - Sometimes, nothing changes, except everything.
15 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
"There is a greater intelligence in all things."
classicsoncall8 August 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This was a very thoughtful episode about life decisions, forks in the road and ultimately for Scully, the road not taken. It's a very introspective insight into her character, even though everything we know about her after almost seven seasons suggests she would never have had an affair with one of her teachers and mentors. Aside from the fact that Dr. Daniel Waterston (Nicolas Surovy) was dying, I thought he was something of a pathetic character, virtually paralyzed over the fact that Scully walked away from their relationship after she learned he was married.

What resonated with this viewer were the random events that came into play in the story - the misplaced X-ray, the 'accident' that almost happened, and Scully's spilling the contents of the envelope that contained the Chakra crop circle leading her back to Colleen Azar (Colleen Flynn). Absent any of those events, you would have had an entirely different story, which I think was the point the writer, in this case Gillian Anderson herself, was trying to convey. The idea that "Maybe I want a life I didn't choose" serves as the existential core of this episode, and perhaps in a way, expresses Anderson's feelings about her own life and career.

But boy oh boy, the misdirection with the teaser had me going, just as I'm sure it had most fans who were looking for some kind of closure on Scully's relationship with Mulder. Close but no cigar on that one folks. The way this story opened made it look like they spent the night together, and of course they did, but in typical X-Files fashion, what you see is not always what you get. Damn!
8 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
An episode out of the ordinary
carolhendry-2512624 March 2024
Warning: Spoilers
I rewatched this episode the other day and I found that I really like this episode. I like the way Gillian Anderson explores her character- her background and how she ended up where she is. We all have turning point in our lives and Scully is at one. She's testy with Mulder, tired of his crop circles and sometimes crazy quests. She is allowed to see the road not taken with Daniel, but comes to realize that her decision to leave him and go to the FBI was ultimately the right decision. Having this also be the episode where Scully and Mulder finally show that they are having a physical relationship brings things full circle. My only quibble with the episode was the pacing was a bit slow, but otherwise I felt it was an excellent first writing and directing credit for Anderson.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
2/10
boneyween22 October 2021
Possibly my most hated episode - to the point where I am forced to write a review.

The disjointed story line which was all over the place. The dumb music that kept repeating throughout. The hospital patient that no one cares about. The hospital patients bipolar daughter. The cheesy slow motion shots e.g. The part when she was walking down the street with the flowers was especially cringeworthy.

The episode feels like it was written by some 15 year old edgelord. I spent the whole time cringing.
10 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Horrible
keshby363628 April 2016
First of all... Moby? Worst music ever. What the hell happened to this series? This episode was the most boring, pretentious X-Files ever. Didn't it occur to anyone that this was a painfully embarrassing episode being made? It was basically a soap opera. I first began watching the X-files back in the 90's when it came out. I'm betting this episode is why I eventually bailed. I think they should have ended it around season 4 or 5. Too many shows extend way beyond their creativity(Supernatural, hint, hint). I'll keep watching though. I can't imagine it will get much worse at this point. Guess I'll find out soon enough. No wonder David Duchovny walked away from the show. Wait. He probably ran.
27 out of 59 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Worst. Episode. Ever.
daisydrew1416 March 2018
Bizarre plot. Overdramatic. Not enough Mulder. Overall lameness guaranteed.
17 out of 44 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed