"The Inspector Lynley Mysteries" One Guilty Deed (TV Episode 2006) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
truly excellent
blanche-22 November 2012
Inspector Lynley and his partner Barbara Havers investigate "One Guilty Deed" in this season 5 episode.

When a criminal who is turning state's evidence is murdered in his home town, Lynley and Havers get the case. The home town is seaside and a place where Havers spent many happy childhood summers with her brother in a seaside caravan. She's thrilled and excited to be there. There is only one caravan left that she and Lynley share; he's less than thrilled about roughing it.

Havers befriends a woman who lives in the town, whom she remembers from her childhood. As she and Lynley attempt to sort through what happened, the gangster they suspect of murdering their victim is also killed.

Havers begins to suspect the murders may be tied to the death of a little boy who had drowned years before.

What makes this episode so good is that it starts in one direction and goes into another, and also we get to see a new, cheery side of Havers as she belts out karaoke at a local club.

Lynley is in a foul mood, particularly at the beginning. Both actors do a wonderful job, and the seaside resort looks like incredible fun, particularly an old building with turquoise turrets. Being American, I was not familiar with caravan parks or, in fact, caravans, so the episode was especially fascinating.

This is one of the better Lynleys, mixing a dark, sad story with some lighter moments.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Caravans and criminals and karaoke.
chart1762930 September 2020
At least two suspects are in the running for the murder, a contract killer and a bitter old man. Which suits the victim, as he was killed twice. A good mystery and a good solution, primarily thanks to Havers. I like that last episode and this she's allowed more of the lead in the detecting. Also that Lynley has stopped complaining/disparaging about it and begun encouraging it.

The caravan park brought a smile to my face. (I grew up in New Jersey, USA.) It and the town seemed a mash up of Asbury Park, Ocean Grove and Long Beach Island. Like Havers, I have fond memories.

The introduction of Martin is welcome. Someone besides Havers and Lynley working on things will make the investigations a bit more believable. I hope to see more of him. As to the new Helen ...

Personally I find the new Helen annoying. Not that they swapped actors. But that they completely swapped characters. With no explanation. Up until this series (the old) Helen was languid and deliberate and justalittlebit patronizing. This new one is bright and smiley and definitely Not to the manor born. Every scene between Helen and Tommy in the first three series has now become a waste of my time.

And allow me one more thing. (Oh, yeah. I've read the other reviews.) I have No interest in karaoke. Watching/listening to flat, nonrhythmic singing live is annoying enough. But video of it rises to the level of ABH. The two snippets here were mercifully brief,. They could have been briefer.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Lynley and Havers investigate the murder of a police informant.
joyteach122 June 2006
Warning: Spoilers
A good episode.

SPOILER : A notorious criminal thinks better of his wicked ways when his own daughter is killed. He intends to become a supergrass and provide evidence that will enable the police to put away other criminals for a long time. He returns to his home town to try to make what amends he can for a bad deed he and others were involved in years before.

When all is revealed towards the end there are shades of Barbara Vine.

When the supergrass is murdered on the beach near where he grew up, Lynley and Havers arrive and gradually unravel the threads.

Many of the characters are more sympathetic than they first appear to be.

Havers has fond memories of the seaside town herself, from childhood holidays. She finds out about the tragedy that led to her family going elsewhere.

There are some amusing incidents in this episode, including Lynley's reaction to staying on the caravan site that Havers loves. You will wish for more when she sings Karaoke in the club.

Very well-produced, I thought, apart from a speech error from Lynley in the first few minutes :'laying' instead of 'lying' Urggghhhh. Otherwise excellent.
23 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A fantastic episode.
Sleepin_Dragon24 August 2021
I absolutely loved this episode, it feels very different to all made before this, different settings, and more so different tone.

More pace in this episode, it's more energetic, end packs in more humour than the usual episodes. The opening sequences are brutal, and are real shock, they grab your attention, and keep you hooked throughout.

I'm with Barbara here, absolutely love a few days in a caravan, the look on Lynley's face is a treat, total terror,

The Bristol gets multiple central shots, and why not, shown in all its glory, the motor is sublime. The production in general is terrific, it looks fantastic, the music is very different, not the usual atmospheric type, this is more action, it works well.

Very nicely acted, loved Esther Hall, and her scenes with Barbara, the night out was great fun.

This series is wonderful, another terrific watch, 10/10.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Manners havent improved!
davyd-0223728 May 2021
Despite a brief appearance from "helen 3" Lynley is still going around as though he is something near to a great detective. Given when this was written, he has to be the hero which may well explain a surprise ending as to who ultimately is the killer but he leaves Havers and the rest of the team trying to work out what his thought processes are. Some nice Suffolk locations for this one and good individual performances from members of the cast. The Lynley character doesnt come across like a "hero"!
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Intrigue until the end, and Valerie Lilley's performance stands out
safenoe8 October 2016
Warning: Spoilers
It's a shame Inspector Lynley didn't go longer than 6 seasons, whereas shows like Saved by the Bell went on for way too long.

Lynley and Havers head off to a seaside area (where Havers had wonderful memories growing up) to investigate the murder of a guy shot on a beach (who in turn lost his daughter to an assassin's bullet intended for him a few months earlier). Havers is so excited when she and Lynley manage to book a caravan in a resort, as their base. What's interesting is that Havers and Lynley are comfortable with each other with no suggestion of any romance, especially when Lynley comes out of the caravan shower. Also I was impressed by Nathaniel Parker's acting, especially when he sees the caravan Havers booked them in, not condescending but more bemusement.

Seeing Havers doing karaoke with the caravan park owner was excellent, "Sisters are doing it for themselves"!! If there's an Inspector Lynley soundtrack then the full rendition should be on it.

Deborah Sheridan-Taylor, who plays Erika Pollard, is incredibly beautiful and poised, and she deserves to have more prominence as an actress. Valerie Lilley who plays Pat McRae, put on an incredibly moving and nuanced performance as the mother who lost her son in the seaside town all those years ago.

The ending was very said, and it sort of embodies the saying, "You can't go home again".

Due credit also to the production team, including Chan Chau (Production Coordinator), Mark Galbraith (Production Executive), Lindsay Hall (Production Runner), and Zoe Liang (Floor Runner).
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Rupert Procter Steals The Show
ilovdebaby0810 July 2017
As he always does in every piece he's in, Rupert Procter steals the show as Simon Henshaw in this episode of The Inspector Lynley Mysteries. Procter is so vivacious, energetic, and so authentic in his role. He also gets the dialect of the type of background his character might have come from just right--and it's very different from Procter's real-life dialect. Procter is the best!
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed