"Doctor Who" Battlefield: Part Three (TV Episode 1989) Poster

(TV Series)

(1989)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Huh?
wetmars2 May 2020
Warning: Spoilers
The Brigadier rescues the Doctor from the stone spaceship before they set out to locate Morgaine before she gains Excalibur.

I don't get why knights are doing in the 80s, just all confused..
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Decent Doctor Who episode.
poolandrews22 March 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Doctor Who: Battlefield: Part Three starts as Ace (Sophie Aldred) is saved from the airlock by the Doctor (Sylvetser McCoy) who opens the outer hatch from which Ace can swim to the surface where Warmsly (James Ellis) & Ancelyn (Marcus Gilbert) see her, meanwhile back inside the spacecraft the Brigadier (Nicholas Courtney) & the Doctor are reunited at last as the former saves the later. Morgaine (Jean Marsh) has had enough, her son Mordred (Christopher Bowen) & the other Knights cause a diversion as she conjures up the Destroyer (Marek Anton) an incredibly powerful blue demon from hell as she increases her attempts to take possession of Excalibur...

Episode 3 from season 26 this Doctor Who adventure originally aired here in the UK during Septmeber 1989, directed by Michael Kerrigan I have to say that Battlefield has turned out much better than I had expected & I am actually finding myself enjoying it. The script by Ben Aaronovitch isn't perfect though by any stretch of the imagination, for a start I don't understand why the Knights from the parallel Universe would carry both sophisticated laser guns (despite having no destructive capability at all) & very antiquated broadswords. If ever there was two mismatched items these are surely it. Then there's Brigadier Bambera, oh God. Enough said. Part Three sees the reunion of the Doctor & (the proper) Brigadier Lethbridge Stewart, there's some nice self referential dialogue between them with the Doctor making comments about his gun-happy nature while the Brigadier mentions various old enemies including the Daleks & the Yeti from their previous encounters. The story in Battlefield has been good fun & certainly a lot better than many late 80's Doctor Who.

This episode sees the long awaited return of Bessie as well, the Doctors yellow car featured heavily during the Jon Pertwee era & the first time it has featured since The Five Doctors (1983) six years prior. Like Part Two when released on video Part Three was slightly extended with some cut footage reinstated including Ace being introduced to the Brigadier & a conversation between Ace & Shou Yuing. The production values haven't been half bad on Battlefield, apart from the poorly staged & somewhat limp looking battles the costumes & effects have generally been pretty good as have most of the sets. A lot of it was shot on location in Fulmar & Iver in Buckinghamshire, Leicestershire & locations in Lincolnshire too. The acting has been a bit hammy at times but fairly good, Jean Marsh as Morgaine first appeared in Doctor Who during season three's The Dalek's Master Plan (1965) which was also the first story Nicholas Courtney appeared in. Marcus Gilbert is quite likable as the naive Ancelyn while Angela Bruce as Bammera is awful.

Battlefield: Part Three is another good episode to a good story, at least there's a story here & it generally just about makes sense if you can overlook the drawing of chalk circles & blind people regaining their sight.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Battlefield: Part Three
Prismark1013 January 2024
Sophie Aldred nearly came a cropper with the opening scenes. She nearly drowned in the tube she was trapped in. Ace finally emerges clutching Excalibur as the Lady of the Lake. Warmsly, Ancelyn, Brigadier Bambera are there to witness it.

The Doctor needs is still on the ship trying to evade the ship's defence system before being helped out by Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart.

Morgaine has sent her son Mordred and their knights to take Excalibur and kill anyone who gets in the way. Morgaine takes no prisoners but she restores Elizabeth Rowlinson's sight.

The third episode is uneven in tone. There are bits that is modern Doctor Who. Ace and Shou Yuing inside that circle and getting psychological pressured that results in a racial outburst from Ace.

The other bits feel like the anniversary celebrations of Season 25 as the Doctor and Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart reunite. There is also the return of Bessie.

The weak spot is some of the acting. Mordred has been campy but McCoy is the weak link. His acting when he tries to be angry or assertive is pure ham.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Mehh.
Sleepin_Dragon24 February 2020
The Brigadier does what he always does, and attempts to rescue The Doctor, Morgaine sets about getting hold of Excalibur from Ancelyn.

I can understand why some like it, but I think my issue with it is the tone, it's so light and breezy, belonging to an earlier series, what was to come was so superior, this one has always seemed such an oddity.

Jean Marsh continues to stand out, and in so many ways her vast talent is wasted. The subtle flirting scenes between Bambera and Ancelyn are very funny. Mordred is a bit too much of a Mummy's boy .

I quite like The Destroyer, a similar design would be seen in Fenric, but looks effective. The music is grating, particularly during the fight scenes, it doesn't work.

The references to the show's rich history are great, Bessy is back, the mention of the need for Silver bullets.

It's tolerable. 5/10
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed