Kit Kittredge: An American Girl (2008) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
30 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
This movie was beyond my expectations
cklarson-16 July 2008
As a writer of women's history, including World War II, this is one of the few films I've seen which really informs. The settings and clothing were accurate. The mix of people was also true to life. But what surprised me the most was that Kit's family came face to face with the personal dilemmas of the Depression. She was not just a child "voyeur", "do-gooder", or "little careerist" removed from the economic and social pressures which is what I had expected. There were a number of very authentic scenes and interchanges. There were also some very interesting characters such as the mobile librarian.

I spoke to a mother as she came out of the theater with her 5 year old (who liked it). She commented that the movie will give youth of today a view of hardship that most don't understand in our now affluent nation. As a child of Depression-era parents that's the truth: both of my parents' families lost wealth due to small town bank failures. My uncle, instead of going to college, had to join the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCCs).

With that said, however, as a movie I thought the acting uneven. Some of the dialogue seemed a little canned and some words were too contemporary (e.g., Kit: "I was focused on"). But some of that could also just be my first over-reactive impression. I'd have to see it again, to let it all sink in, for as a total historical package it was a lot to absorb, because you have to assess it at several different levels.

But, whether or not you think this is a good or bad movie, in movie terms, this is an important movie for children to see. It is generally fact-based, has depth, and is as authentic a movie as a wholesome, "uplifting" one for 10-year-olds can be. The American Girl phenomenon is true manna from heaven for those of us interested in giving women a place in history.
29 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
About time they made these kind of movies for kids
chufas-631832 July 2008
It's about time they made these movies for kids instead of the shoot-em-up junk that attracts kids nowadays. It's also about time girls were the focus of movies. Where have all the young female role models gone? I just saw Kit and am very pleased at the movie. The historical references are very accurate, the story is accurate as to what was happening the the Depression, and children can learn a lot from this movie. Also, children were respectful to their elders, it's a "clean" movie, but there's a great message and it's about time. No, it's not going to win any Academy Awards, but it might give kids today an idea of what life was like during a particularly troubling period in American history--just like NOW!!!! MAKE MORE of these!!!! I'll take my granddaughter to every one of them--MORE than once! Yes, I took her to see Wall-E, yes, we also saw Indiana Jones, but we need more of THESE MOVIES for kids to balance the imaginations!! GREAT MOVIE!
42 out of 55 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
American girls, including older gals like me, will enjoy this one very much, Breslin shines brightly!
inkblot115 July 2008
Kit Kittredge (Abigail Breslin) is the only child of a Cincinnati couple in the 1930's. An aspiring newspaper reporter, Kit spends some time in her room, tapping out her stories on an old typewriter. Her father (Chris O'Donnell) owns a car dealership and her very pretty mother (Julia Ormond) takes care of their lovely home, where she often hosts garden teas. But, the Great Depression is gripping the nation and soon Mr. Kittredge is out of work and traveling to Chicago to look for a new job. Meanwhile, Mrs. Kittredge is forced to take in boarders to make ends meet, including a dancer (Jane Krakowski), a magician (Stanley Tucci), a mobile librarian (Joan Cusack), an uptight mother (Glenne Headley) and her young son. Also arriving on the Kittredge's doorstep are two young hobos, teenager Will (Max Thieriot) and pre-teen County (Willow Smith). These latter two youngsters will do any odd jobs in exchange for food and Mrs. K. welcomes them over the objections of neighbors. But, will the Kittredge family save their home? Also, will Kit see her fondest wish and get published, all the while solving the mystery of who took her family's safety box of money and other costly possessions? This is a nice, nice film for American families with young girls. Breslin is enchanting in the title role, exhibiting her sweet spunk and contagious enthusiasm at all times. The supporting cast is likewise wonderful, with O'Donnell very fine as the sensitive father and Ormond, especially, doing a terrific turn as the beautiful, courageous mother. All of the other supporting cast members previously mentioned, along with Wallace Shawn as a stuffy newspaper editor, fulfill their roles handily, too, with special mention extended to young Willow Smith for her nice interpretation of the part of a young drifter with a big secret. The film looks sensational, from the Kittredge's gorgeous home and grounds to the costumes to the wonderful cinematography. As to the script, it is a nice combination of history, intrigue, and the triumph of the human spirit, especially the hope and new possibilities that children bring into the world. Even though the direction could have been a bit snappier, the film rolls along nicely, too. In short, this is a lovely film for young girls and their families, with abundant laughs, lessons, and love. Do skedaddle over to the nearest theater and make time for Kit and company. Then, head to the library as well, for the books which inspired the film are very, very fine indeed.
18 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
decent family movie
Willie-126 August 2008
I was able to see this the other day with my child, and I must say I thought it was a decent little family movie. There were some very good lessons taught about acceptance of others, not giving up, and being happy with what you have in life. When it was over, I overheard a little girl say, "I want to see that one again." My child had the same reaction. The only complaint I have comes in the latter part of the film. Without going into details, it seems that the film unravels a bit during the third act. However, it recovers nicely, and hits the right emotional note at the end. Definitely one I'd recommend to parents and their children (both boy and girl).
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Very pleasant movie, set in the 1930s depression era.
TxMike9 November 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Cincinnatti, Ohio, heartland of America, hit hard by the depression. All the small kids knew was that whenever your family resorted to selling eggs, you were about to lose your home.

Cute 11 year old Abigail Breslin is Margaret Mildred Kittredge, 'Kit' for short. She is in an ideal family, until ... dad's business goes under and he has to go find work elsewhere. He goes to Chicago. In one scene after dad has been gone for a while Kit says, "If you are not working in Chicago, why can't you NOT work here?"

Kit's mom is Julia Ormond as Margaret Kittredge, and her dad is Chris O'Donnell as Jack Kittredge.

Kit's mom has to resort to taking in boarders to make ends meet and keep the house from foreclosure. It becomes quite a varied group, with a dancer, Jane Krakowski as Miss May Dooley. A mobile library driver, Joan Cusack as Miss Lucinda Bond. A woman, Glenne Headly as Louise Howard, plus her young son. And a magician, Stanley Tucci as Jefferson Jasper Berk.

Meanwhile Kit is pursuing her ambition to write articles for the Cincinnatti newspaper, where the editor is Wallace Shawn as Mr. Gibson. At first they just laugh at her, who ever heard of a kid writing articles for the newspaper. But she keeps on trying.

There are a couple of hobos, Max Thieriot as Will Shepherd and Willow Smith as Countee Garby. They end up doing odd jobs around the house and get food in return. Plus friendship from Kit and the other kids.

A crisis arises when the lockbox in the Kittredge house turns up missing, and clues lead police to suspect it was a hobo, perhaps even Will. But Kit doesn't believe it and puts her investigative skills, a sort of Nancy Drew approach, to work helping solve the crime.

Overall a good movie, entertaining with some good actors.

SPOILERS: The crime was a product of the magician, his friend, and the mobile librarian. But Kit hides in the car when they go to dig up the buried treasure. In the process she clears the name of the hobos and the Kitredges keep their home. During Thanksgiving dinner dad shows up again.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
I was the wrong audience for this film. If I was only a ten year old girl (especially at heart) I would have loved this
dbborroughs12 January 2009
Warning: Spoilers
If I were a young girl I would have loved this. being a middle aged guy I liked it.

Its a sweet little movie about Kit who wants to be a reporter and the Depression era troubles and the mystery of a stolen lock box. For give the lack of details but it was too sweet for me and while I cared enough to leave it on to let it play to the end I was more into wrapping Christmas presents.

Recommended for any girl/woman reading this who is still 10 years old at heart.

6 out of 10 for old guys like me. 8 Out of 10 for anyone who's a ten year old girl at heart
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Phony and Predictable
kenjha20 July 2008
Inspired by a popular doll, this film about a family struggling to make ends meet during the depression of the 1930s is entertaining if formulaic and predictable. Everybody is so nice and politically correct that it's enough to induce nausea for adult viewers, which is OK because this one is aimed at tweeners and young teens who read the American Girl books. The filmmakers have thrown in every cliché one can think of and the schmaltz meter hits a pretty high score by the time the happy ending (this should not be a spoiler for anyone) comes around. The cast has a lot of familiar faces and Breslin does look like the doll.
7 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
yo, you got to change, bro
doctorsmoothlove17 August 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Last year, older audiences were very excited about the Nancy Drew movie. Finally, parents could share their childhood heroine with their own brood. It never came be, though. The film was full of pre-pubescent musings and left many parents disappointed. So if you fall into this disgruntled group, rejoice! Kit Kittredge: An American Girl is the film that Nancy Drew should have been. It is an inspiring story of tolerance and empathy with other human beings with a mystery backdrop. As it is set it the Great Depression, it may have more contemporary significance than intended.

The film chronicles the life of Kit Kittredge, a young girl with a strong interest in journalism. It's set in Cincinnati. Kit's family is rather wealthy, but everything changes when Kit's father loses his job at some car dealership. The house is in danger of being foreclosed, so Kit's father, Jack, decides to look for work in Chicago. Kit's life worsens even more when her article concerning camaraderie in the hobo community is rejected by the local newspaper because it doesn't appeal to societal perceptions about the homeless. Meanwhile, Kit's mother, Margaret, subleases portions of the house to help pay the mortgage. Several quirky types come to live with them. The residents include: the sultry dance instructor, Miss Dooley (emphasis on Miss), mobile librarian Miss Bond, clever magician Mr. Berk and his assistant-brother, and Kit's classmate, Stirling. Two young "hobos" named Will and Countee respectively visit the Kittredge house frequently.

Several painful scenes of non-plot progression later, the police report a burglary with a single (and extremely obvious footprint) as the only evidence. Whose footprint do you think it is (hint he's one of the only named hobos). Will is later accused but mysteriously not prosecuted (though he is threatened several times). He isn't the criminal, however, as Kit discovers. In actuality, the magician Mr. Berk, his wimpy brother, and the mobile librarian are the perpetrators. They have swindled money from semi-wealthy houses across the Northeast and have framed the local homeless populations for the crimes. Kit coerces Stirling and her other friend Ruthie to help her bring these clowns to justice. They convince Miss Bond that exploiting public disgust of the homeless for personal gain is unethical, and she helps them subdue the Berk Brothers. The movie ends with a heartwarming feast in celebration of Kit's detective skill and her article's acceptance in the paper, and the hobo's innocence. Oh, and Miss Dooley finds a man to seduce in G-rated stylized acting.

Kit Kittredge: An American Girl is an unusual film. It begins as an overly-sentimental drama and finishes as a mystery thriller (sorta). The change is welcomed and allows the film to appeal to a wider audience. Abigail Breslin handles the transition well and channels her character's anger at having her article rejected into locating the stolen money. This change is possible due to Valerie Tripp's screenplay which peppers Breslin's dialog with analytical and humanist phrases. The other characters involved in the crime's undertaking and its solving are not as complex as Kit, so they're free to follow her transition. The screenplay does have a hole it never addresses, though. Kit's father goes to Chicago to find work, but is unable to find any prospects. How does he support himself while there? Maybe Margaret sends him money, but I'm unsure. His character leaves the story and reappears when at the end when his presence isn't necessary.

The opening half of the film is its weakest portion and, to be honest, is probably unappealing to anyone outside of the intended audience. Kit's father and the poverty of her school friends aren't developed within the context of the plot. One must appeal to his/her own understanding of the Great Depression in order to have sympathy for them. It's a bit pretentious. Give me a unique reason to pity the characters, jeez. Seriously though, how many children understand the cultural and economic implications of that time in history? The theft avoids this problem by allowing someone sufficient screen time to acquaint himself/herself with the hobos and care for them. It's an incomplete film but not an intolerable one. An adult will find something admirable in Kit Kittredge: An American Girl. I suspect the adult appeal is the film's underlying message. The vagrants are not inherently evil and they are not entirely responsible for their situation. This movie reminds one of that. In an age of cynical adult-laden innuendo in children's films (see Shrek…), Kit Kittredge: An American Girl provides a welcome and encouraging divergence.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
wonderful movie
cosimdm5 July 2008
I took my grandchild to see this movie and was truly shocked. How could a movie this good come out of Hollywood? The characters were believable, the plot interesting, there were humans instead of androids in this movie, there was no sex, violence, or bad language in it, and this old lady LOVED it. So did my 7 year old grandchild. Why haven't they been making movies like this for years?

Usually when I take a child to the movies, I am saddened by the experience. Where are all the wonderful, wholesome productions of yesteryear that entertained one and educated at the same time? This movie did both. My grandchild knew nothing about the Depression, so I explained the time in very simple terms. She seemed to get it, and loved the way the story had a good ending where the main character had a personal triumph and a family endured adversity.

Take your kids to see this movie. You will be proud and not embarrassed.
57 out of 65 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A surprise like!
donaldricco3 August 2017
My 9 year old would give this 5 stars for sure! For me, it's 3, but it is indeed a good family movie! It's a sanitized look at life during the depression, with job loss, home loss, and the struggle for a family to make ends meet. They also touch on "hobo" life, and how truly hard life was during that time period. This movie has a strong cast that saves some of the flaws, and like I said, my daughter loved it, and I, much to my surprise, liked it!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Poorly plotted children's adaptation
Turfseer15 April 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Kit Kittredge is a 10 year old aspiring journalist who lives in an upper middle-class suburb of Cincinnati in 1934. Through a family connection, she boldly calls upon the publisher of a major Cincinnati newspaper and asks him to publish an article she's written. Somehow I was thinking that it might have been more interesting if the plot had gone in a different direction from the beginning. Instead of being turned down and not getting her article published until the movie is just about over (and that's the way the plot actually plays out), it might have been more interesting if somehow Kit enlists an adult to get herself published and then her articles become a sensation. Kit becomes a young "Cyrano" with her adult friend (perhaps the 19 year old gopher who Kit was put in contact with by her brother at the beginning of the film) attempts to keep the ruse going, with the publisher and the co-workers at the newspaper in the dark until the film's climax. In my 'alternative' scenario, Kit is found out at the end and 'exposed'; she falls from grace but is redeemed after her final article exposes a team of con men who have been preying upon the good members of the community.

As it turns out, The Kittredge 'First Act' is replete with politically correct, anachronistic ideas. The 'hobos' are nothing more than a stand-in for today's immigrants while the kids whose families are lucky enough to escape the ravages of the Depression, mouth platitudes in school about the hobos not working and getting "government handouts". The rich kids are equated with the conservative, right-wing Republicans of today.

The film's second act begins when Kit's father loses his car dealership (it's interesting that he was still able to have a thriving business as late as 1934!). The father decides to pack his bags and go to Chicago to find new employment. Kit's mother is forced to take in boarders much to Kit's chagrin. Here's where the film really starts dragging. Instead of introducing the antagonist, the plot focuses on introducing us to the collection of oddball characters who inhabit the boarding house. The machinations of these characters are supposed to be amusing but they are merely foolish (there are one too many scenes with Miss Bond, the mobile librarian, crashing her truck in the front yard along with the undeveloped character Miss Dooley who happens to be a dancer of sorts). Then there's Mr. Berk, played by Stanley Tucci, who wows the kids with his magic tricks (another scene that did not have to go on as long as it did).

In addition to the boarders, Kit meets two Hobo children, Will and Countee and decides to investigate the Hobo 'way of life'. Implausibly, Kit's mother allows her to go to a hobo camp to do some 'research' for one of her articles, but wouldn't you know it the hobos are a bunch of wonderful people (despite police reports of many robberies committed by various members of their group). Much too late in the story, the Hobo children are accused of stealing all the boarders' valuables which Kit's mother had placed in what she believed to be a 'safe place'.

By Act III, we've finally discovered that Mr. Berk, the magician, his associate and Miss Bond are a bunch of con artists who have been victimizing poor boarding house denizens all over the city. Since they are a bunch of clumsy fools (buffoons), Kit easily figures out (with the assistance of her young buddies) that they're the ones who framed poor Will; he's soon exonerated and the police now arrest the magician and his buddy after they are exposed by Kit and company.

The denouement is unsatisfying as well. Kit's father returns from Chicago and inexplicably hasn't been able to find one job there. So he reassures Kit that he intends to remain in Cincinnati (despite the fact that there is still no work for him there). Finally, the newspaper publisher arrives and announces that he's published Kit's first article. Instead of becoming an exciting muckraker from the beginning, Kit's new found fame comes a little too late in the storyline.

Unfortunately, little Abigail Breslin is once again used by adults for nefarious purposes. In the insufferable "Little Miss Sunshine", she ends up dancing in a sexually suggestive way at the end of the movie (it's supposed to be "cute" but in reality is a cynical attempt by the films' scenarists to promote an elitist agenda—modern day beatniks trumping beauty pageant snobs). Here little Abigail is also used to promote another modern-day form of elitism: the victims of today's economic woes get their shots in at today's fat cats (no doubt Corporate Executive types who get big bonuses). At least here the 'anything goes' philosophy of 'Little Miss Sunshine' is no longer operative but little Abigail once again comes off as overly pushy and aggressive(and certainly not 'cute').

In the end, 'Kittredge' patronizes both adults and children alike. The film's scenarists were afraid to expose children to a dose of reality. The Depression here is reduced to a Hallmark Greeting Card with villains who are buffoons and heroes who can do no wrong. What it needed to be was another 'Wizard of Oz' with a wicked witch antagonist who is actually scary and evil and protagonists (such as Dorothy and her buddies) who have real-life, honest-to-goodness, human foibles.
4 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
history, morals, mystery - all in one!
vamomx22 July 2008
While not being semi-prof. film critics,we know what we like and what is a good movie, worth your time and money. This is not a deep psychological study, but is an intriguing look at an era most people have long forgotten. The story is nimble and keeps your interest while being clearly told from a child's perspective. We all loved the cinematography and the period clothes, cars, etc. The story had universal appeal and was not so childish that adults couldn't enjoy it. It was a real pleasure to see many senior citizens in attendance (even w/o grandkids) as I suspect that they actually lived through the struggles outlined in the movie. There were enough twists and turns and plenty of good, moral messages for old and young alike. Another plus is the 90 min. length! Our family votes yes to taking your kids and your senior citizens as well.
37 out of 42 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The film brings notions of political, moral, and a heroine smart, beautiful and extremely charismatic
fernandoschiavi10 February 2024
The "Great Depression" is today considered the worst and longest economic recession period of the twentieth century. There is nothing new approach in the cinema of that time, which was the background for some stories. A more recent example that speaks so interesting about this troubled and sad period in the world economy and portrays the misery and societal collapse of the 30's movie Cinderella Man released in 2005, directed by Ron Howard and starring Russell Crowe, Renée Zellweger and Paul Giamatti. In this film and others, as well as documentaries about the era are often produced, showing the difficult times, but always looking for great examples of overcoming stress, emphasizing the unity and solidarity will always be the main link in times of crisis.

Produced by HBO Films, and with Julia Roberts as an executive producer, production is based on the Kit Kittredge stories by writer Valerie Tripp, hits theaters more a family drama that has the Great Depression as one of the main characters, who ends up being the thread of the whole story. For the film adaptation, was chosen screenwriter Ann Peacock, who had been responsible for the 2005 adaptation of The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe by CS Lewis. The screenplay by Ann Peacock is unique to a certain extent, because unlike previous films based on the series "An American Girl", some characters in the film are not present in the books. It has its great advantage in bringing a different approach to everything. For the first time, we see a sad period of the 30s being seen through the eyes of a child who goes through transformations arising from the crisis.

Cincinnati, Ohio. Great Depression. In June 1934, Kit Kittredge (Abigail Breslin) is determined to become a reporter, writing articles on his typewriter in his attic. Meanwhile, the mortgage of your home is about to be executed because his father Jack Kittredge (Chris O'Donnell) lost his car dealership and could no longer afford the payments. He ends up going to Chicago, Illinois to find work, while Kit's mother, Margaret (Julia Ormond) need to turn the house where they live on a pension to support the home. Among those guests arriving there the magician Jefferson Berk (Stanley Tucci), a dance teacher, Miss. Dooley (Jane Krakowski), and itinerant librarian, Miss. Bond (Joan Cusack). On site there were reports of assaults and robberies allegedly committed by the homeless. Kit investigates and finds Will Shepherd (Max Thieriot) and Countee (Willow Smith), living in a homeless camp. Kit writes a story about the camp and try to sell it to Mr. Gibson (Wallace Shawn), the editor of the Cincinnati, but he has no interest in the subject. When a closed box containing all the savings of his mother is stolen, and a footprint with a star similar to the Will of the boot is discovered, the boy becomes the main suspect. Will not believing that he could have committed the crime, Kit and her friends Stirling (Zach Mills) and Ruthie (Madison Davenport) come together to gather enough evidence to find the culprits, proving that homeless friends are innocent.

The Canadian director Patricia Rozema is happy to keep that innocent look and adventurous about the events that are gradually changing the lives of an entire city. At the beginning of the film, some neighbors and acquaintances Kity are being affected by the crisis taking its foreclosure. Her father still has his car dealership, walks into a Chrysler airflows, but already beginning to suffer from the new times. When the crisis reaches the Kittredge family, he has to leave the city to try to get jobs in local gold and have to stay away from his daughter and wife. Kit will correspond through letters to his father telling of all the new developments that were taking place while he was away. Detachable here is the work of Chris O'Donnell and his chemistry with the Oscar nominee for Little Miss Sunshine (2006), Abigail Breslin. Chris O'Donnell passes and the figure of a loving father and devoted husband, and Abigail shows all the love you have for that father. The duo is responsible for the most dramatic and exciting moments of the whole film and deliver great performances.

The initial half of the script shows the desire to become a reporter kit and especially the effects of the crisis that affected not only the girl's family, but to everyone in town, including leaving many people with no place to live and struggling to survive. The beginning of the second half shows us a little better to the residents of the board created by the mother of the protagonist. Is remarkable about the cast that director Patricia Rozema could muster. Stanley Tucci is great as always as the magician Jefferson Berk. Jane Krakowski also composes and dance teacher, Miss. Dooley. The highlights will even Joan Cusack, who composed a fun and interesting character, is the peculiar way of driving, the way to run or even to speak. Julia Ormond is perhaps the best presence of the adult cast, passing all the insecurity, suffering, gentleness, goodness and sadness in specific moments. It is the most natural character among adults. Children of fundamental importance in this film are very well on stage, without exception. Besides the already known talent Abigail Breslin, Madison Davenport is important to mention, Zach Mills, Max Thieriot and Willow Smith, daughter of superstar Will Smith. The final stretch is dedicated to the mystery of the theft of the economies of Mrs. Kittredge and solving the mystery and also has an interesting little twist.

Throughout the recreation of the 30s, the crew created the appropriate climate. Photograph of David Boyd, coupled with the art direction of Michele Brady who brought cars, facades of typical houses with large green lawns of the American middle class, and objects were relevant at the time care in every detail. The costumes Trysha Bakker also excels and helps further the composition of the time.

Patricia Rozema knew leave the movie transitions natural and fluid. Earlier Kittredge family yet was struggling. With the crisis, all the characters live in a new time, having to adapt. Kit not only played, but he had to help his mother take care of the pension, having to take care of the clothes and other obligations. Aina touched on the issue of homelessness most severely affected by the economy. Seen by many large and responsible for the robberies and crime due to desperation in which they were, realized through Kit and other children, they were good people, with families and they were just victims of the situation mostly.

Rozema does not matter at any time to hide or minimize the situation of the Great Depression, but not called, aptly. See the secondary characters being affected by the crisis and the transformations all go through. The situation is not only introduced to show the time when the story was going, including being one of the main reasons for many of the actions in the course of the film. The work brings a lighter touch and pleasant, and can even have fun at many other moments. Still brings notions of political, moral, and a heroine smart, beautiful and extremely charismatic. A captivating film with a talented cast and a responsive steering and precise, as done for the whole family, where we laugh, we are moved and still reflect and learn every scene.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Kitt Kittredge: An American Cliché Fest
maris16 July 2008
You can't help but think about how disastrous the current situation in Hollywood is when the umpteenth representative of the infamous category "cliché ridden, sugar coated American cute movies" arrives, and you've got to go see it because your niece is crying about itsince the first announcement. I didn't think Kitt Kittredge: An American Girl could've been an exception to the rule, but I was hoping it kind of would because I thought the atypical scenario, different era and diverse cast could have delivered a rather unique movie. It didn't happen, sadly. Kitt Kittredge is about a little girl in Cincinnati trying to become a great journalist during the Depression, while her parents and the US are struggling to get out of the tragic events that were occurring at that time. Is this movie bad? In short, yes. It's got a talented cast, but their lines and performances are mediocre at best. You can't blame the actors for everything that's wrong in this movie, anyway, because the script certainly didn't help. A really big number of clichés already seen in a thousands other movies, ridiculous gags that make you smile for how bad they are, characterizations that are so stereotyped and dull you won't believe it. This movie pushes itself even further, though, when it kicks the cheap cry pedal. There are a lot of scenes in which you're supposed to cry, but delivery is so phoned and trite you're left wondering how could anyone more than six years old would fall into these cheap Hollywood tricks in which they make you automatically cry via a mix of pompous music, ruffian camera angles and redundant lines. This is how Hollywood typically does it, but it doesn't work here. I'll keep it short: if you want to teach your sons about how the Depression was, read 'em a book, even the American Doll ones will do. Do not waste your time with this really, really cheap product which might very well be the biggest cliché fest Hollywood had produced in years. Avoid it.
5 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
It was the darkest of time, yet the sun came through
aharmas9 July 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Give credit where it is due, and once again Breslin dishes more than a dose of sunshine again over a story that puts the spotlight on one of the darkest times in American History. There is more than just a little girl's perspective here, we are treated to a respectful and heartfelt tribute to the people who suffered the most during the Depression. Although the film is told from the point of view of a budding writer who happens to be 10 year old, with the help of a consistent and very talented supporting cast, the emotions come through honestly and without much of the unnecessary and over dramatized productions that now pass as drama.

Chris O'Donnell is perfectly cast as Kit's father, the perfect prototype of the American family man who is now facing total disaster as his world crumbles around him. He soon realizes things are worse than he expected, but just like the American spirit, he is not going to let this conquer him. His lovely wife played by Julia Ormond, is a tower of strength, but without the histrionics shown in the 80's movie. Anyone recalls those farm movies with Spacek, Lange, and Field? Here is a film where there is strength, humor, and many more emotions shown with restraint and class.

Soon, their home becomes a magnet to boarders and other outcasts of society, and we see some of the era's stereotypes beautifully played by first rate actors like Stanley Tucci, Joan Cusack, Glenne Headley, and Jane Krakowski. There are some intimate scenes where one captures how these people tried to escape the darkness outside by finding strength in each other and humor in whatever little entertainment came their way.

The film is short, yet it is full of detail, courtesy of some fine writing, a fantastic production team, and very lovely camera-work. It deserves to be seen and studied.
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
a perfect Kit, not a perfect film
windypoplar20 October 2009
I actually rented this for my cousin, who's a huge fan of the American Girl line. Having thoroughly loved "Samantha", "Felicity" and to some degree "Molly" it was with great anticipation that we all sat down to enjoy "Kit". About twenty minutes in I saw some rolling eyes and yawns. It's not that this movie was bad, but for a theatrical release it's rather pallid. There isn't a lot of movement and the story isn't all that interesting. It feels rather like Saturday morning cartoons to me. I'm not the target audience here, but my cousin and her friends are, they were rather bored. Sorry to say.

Abigail Breslin did a splendid job at Kit, no complaints there, she was charming, smart and strong. The supporting players were good, though the always terrific Jane Krakowski didn't get enough to do, her amorous dancer deserved more screen time. Kit's friends were okay, a bit generic. This seemed cut from the same cloth as the misbegotten "Nancy Drew" with Emma Roberts. No fault of Emma, but that movie, though having an excellent story, suffered from a poor approach that turned a plucky heroine into an nerd! Kit's no nerd, but she's stuck in a nerds movie.

This was a real shame because the American Girl series provides young women with good role models and strong moral messages. That doesn't mean the movie had to be so dull!! Originally "Kristen" was set for the big screen and perhaps her pioneer story would have played better. "Kit" is just not that memorable.
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Grapes of Wrath, Tree Grows in Brooklyn
georgebush9 July 2008
Kit Kitredge, An American Girl is a classic. This film falls into the category of its a Wonderful Life, Tree Grows in Brooklyn, and Grapes of Wrath. The acting is fine but not formal. The mother of Kit surely deserves an Academy Award. This mom is real and not just another self superior empty mom as played in an empty way in some family films like the mom in Drill bit Taylor. She is the opposite of the mom in Drill Bit Taylor. This mom in Kit Kitredge is wise. She has elegance but is also real in her struggles. This is a mom that anyone could look up to. She reminds me of the strong performances of Andy Griffith. Her final scene was one of the strongest acting moments in film history and I have seen over 8,000 films. She shows the full range of emotion and gives a performance reminding me of Claudette Colbert in the 1944 Since you went Away. The film also has a style similar to the live show Annie.

This film moves at a fast enough pace to keep all ages happy. It reveals the era of the Depression with total respect for the people of the era. My family lived through the depression so I know this is authentic. It is a little like the old Nancy Drew but with tremendous involvement with all the characters. The film takes the high road in which moral decisions are clearly understood. There is also a mystery and it is interesting. All the acting is fine and there are a great variety of actors of all ages.. This film reminds me that movies are not suppose to be aimed at one particular age group in order to improve ticket sales. This is just a good old fashioned movie.

Frank Capra would be proud of this film of the underdog against a series of obstacles. The only sad thing is that it has sold so few tickets. I suspect this film will linger for a long time and rent many DVDs. It is a film that could be shown to people many years from now. I highly recommend this movie. American girl refused to sell out their integrity in order to sell tickets. I hope American Girl makes more films. Great film.
26 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Finding light in the darkness
kokkinoskitrinosmple21 February 2024
It is always interesting when movies establish a dark setting and show it from a child's point of view (for example, La Vita E Bella chooses a concentration camp or The Florida Project chooses a housing project).

In Kit Kittredge, it is the Great Depression. The movie's greatest asset is that it succeeds in capturing the era and the atmosphere accurately. The struggle, the fear of an uncertain future, but also the optimism seen through a child's innocent eyes.

On the other hand, it can't be denied that it is predictable, doesn't avoid the cliches, tries too hard to be politically correct and the ending is too feel-good to be true, but that is to be expected in a movie whose primary target audience is the kids.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Kit Kittredge proves there are a few talented people left in Hollywood
goodguy3095 July 2008
Abigail Breslin is headed for Oscar nomination in this move and I would not be surprised to see this movie receive and Oscar nod for best character set. Let me explain a bit more. Some movies has characters/actors that give very strong performance but do not play well with other characters/actors within a storyline. Yes, Abigail Breslin does maintain a strong presence but without EQUAL interaction with the other characters, the movie would not have played so equal across the scenes.

The story is based in 1934, just a few years into the Great Depression. The Depression scenes plays out it injustice(s) in total disregard to social status, property possessions, job description and of course, the haves and the have not. I've been told stories from people who have lived through the Great Depression and I can tell you that the film comes pretty darn close to reality.

Abigail Breslin and her cohorts has this not so secret clubhouse in the family's yard. Secret initiation ceremonies, secret oath and secret chit-chat dominate the playtime of this secret club. As the movie progresses, we see the club forming ideas to help the less fortunate on the street where they live.

Movies like Kit Kittredge gives me hope that there are a few Hollywood idea men that are left who can present to the world, movies laced with a healthy dose of 'nice' and topped off with a dollop of a kindred spirit.
23 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Head for Potter
JohnDeSando1 July 2008
Although Kit Kittredge: An American Girl is about ten year-old Kit's (Abigail Breslin) family struggles during the depression, I doubt anyone but six year olds will enjoy it. It's been a while since I've seen a cliché-ridden, sentimental film like this---most 10 year olds I know would head for the nearest Harry Potter installment for sanity.

In her faux Nancy Drew act, Kit investigates a series of robberies in the money-short, foreclosure-ridden neighborhood. Even award-winning Breslin seems dazed by the pedestrian plot and plodding direction, which leave no tear- possibility unexplored, no stereotype unexploited (benign hobos, shifty magicians, daffy librarians, lovable kids, bumbling adults—the list goes on).

Those hobos: I don't think Woody Guthrie would recognize their clean clothes and pure hearts, much less a compound that looks more like summer camp than hideout. Joan Cusack's mobile library that she continually drives into garbage cans and fences might appeal to four year olds, not six. Her manic, dense librarian could appeal to three year olds.

But this considerably older critic isn't buying the schmaltz except that Kit Kittredge: an American Girl is an example of American movie-making at its worst. I didn't award it an "F" for fear of being labeled un-American by Dick Cheney.
7 out of 54 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Far Too Heavy-Handed
richievee4 October 2013
"Kit Kittredge" began well, and I was impressed by the nice sense of period that the film invoked. Then, after about a half-hour or so, everything went awry, and I got too large a dosage of heavy-handed screenplay and direction. Let me hasten to say, however, that any shortcomings are not the fault of little Abigail Breslin, who is wonderful in the title role. Chris O'Donnell, who plays her father, is quite believable too, as is a nicely understated Max Thieriot in the role of young hobo Will Shepherd. On the debit side, Joan Cusack overacts by a wide margin as mobile librarian Miss Bond, and so does Wallace Shawn as newspaper editor Mr. Gibson. I suppose the main weakness, as so often happens in the motion picture industry, is the shallow script. It is way too manipulative and predictable. I could guess most all that might happen, with everything being tied up in a nice, comfy package by the final iris. Nope, that is not life, and it is also not effective storytelling. The "bad guys" are portrayed as buffoons, simply comic relief (complete with cartoonish music), and of course the downtrodden folks in the hobo community come little short of sainthood, one and all. If you want a truly great American Girl movie, go instead for "Molly: An American Girl on the Home Front," which is outstanding in every respect.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Touching and educational!
mikewang1116 November 2011
Kit Kittredge: An American Girl is a touching story about a young girl (named Kit) who is living during the Great Depression. The movie follows Kit and her family as they struggle through the tough times of the Great Depression. It is a very moving movie, with several emotional scenes, especially near the end.

This movie introduces viewers personally to the struggles that people had to go through during the time period, and I feel that this is one of the strengths of the movies. Not only is it touching and moving, but it also educates the viewer on what the time period was really like, giving a personal perspective to an important period of history.

In terms of acting, I absolutely loved Abigail Breslin as Kit. She is an amazing actress, and I think this is one of her best performances. All of the other actors give great performances, as well.

This is a wonderful movie that can be enjoyed by anyone, kids and adults alike. It is a movie which both touches the heart, and educates the mind.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Insufferable
RuriGokou11 July 2022
The main girl (not the actress playing her) needed a good smack. I waited the entire film, but nothing. Probably because the dad wasn't there. Kit's personality was just insufferable. She didn't come off as strong or bright. Just entitled, selfish and bratty. Even when Kit's father had to leave to find work, she still kept the same sort of personality. No growth. No change. I thought having to take in boarders would have at least been a shock to her 10 year old ego? Are real 10 year old girls THIS annoying?

I know this movie is for kids, but it felt a little TOO clean and safe. I'm not so sure how accurate of the times it portrayed. I'd guess not so accurate if some children can just walk into a "hobo jungle" (which looked more like a summer camp) and be safe. Kind of makes me want to pick up a book and read about the era though.

The costumes were nice, stylish, cute. Made me wish for the times when the men dressed like men and women dressed like women. In today's age, people can't even define what those are anymore!

I feel like I lost brain cells watching this cliche ridden film. The dialogue is horrible. I couldn't help but just complain and make jokes to myself about it. I'm just going to end here because I'm making a big deal about a stupid movie for dumb kids.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
In the end was a rite choice of movie
senthil-balakrishnan10 July 2008
Just before an hour i happened to see this movie "Kit Kittredge: An American Girl".

I went with my wife and we enjoyed it so much that the movie has taken us back to our kids age. I recommend this movie for kids, this is a soft and sweet story which we all have stopped looking back and appreciate the beauty of it.

I am surprised the theater was empty, hoping its because of the weekday. I like the kids role very much, i have seen her previous movies and a big fan of her. The tree house was a nice touch.

I wish all the very best to this movie makers.
16 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Kit Kittredge-Happy Days Are Here Again Arrive With this Film ****
edwagreen30 May 2009
A vastly under-rated, marvelous film with Abigail Breslin proving that she will be a quite a star as the years go on.

Set in May, 1934 in depression era Cincinnati, the film wonderfully captures the depression period and its effects on the inhabitants of the city. We see people losing their jobs and being evicted from their homes during the day. We see families torn apart as fathers had to leave to find work anywhere. Many never wrote or came back.

With all this, we find Kit, whose family is eventually victimized by the economic collapse. This precocious child wants to be a reporter and goes out to view the residents of tents outside of the city. Was surprised that they didn't use the historical name for these areas- Hoovervilles!

This is a great picture capturing depression era Americana. The story then turns into a stealing caper and as usual, the hobos are blamed until Kit and her brood of friends prove otherwise. They didn't even need Jessica Fletcher to prove that which was not so obvious.
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed