User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Army antics
ShadeGrenade16 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
This 'Comedy Playhouse' was based on a story called 'The General Dances At Dawn' by George Macdonald Fraser, author of the 'Flashman' books. It was adapted by David Climie, whose other credits include 'Wodehouse Playhouse' and 'Backs To The Land'. It is set in a British army regiment based in a Scottish castle. Among the privates is one 'McAuslan' ( the late Freddie Earlle ) and he is not only the dirtiest soldier in the world but also the most incompetent. Rather improbably, he is chosen to go on guard duty...

Earlle was a very funny man who, despite appearing in numerous shows of the period such as 'Yanks Go Home' and 'Clochmerle', never seemed to get the roles he deserved. The other cast members include Allan Cuthbertson, Moray Watson, Jack Watson, and John Standing. At first this looks as though its going to be centred around the character of McAuslan, but then, strangely, the narrative shifts to 'Lt. MacNeil' ( Standing ). During a military parade, MacNeil realises he has forgotten to put the buckle on his kilt, meaning it could fall down at any second. And with royalty present.

Funniest moment - MacNeil imagining his kilt going into free-fall, A sequence straight out of 'Billy Liar'.

Agreeable on the whole, but no series resulted.

Earlle worked with producer with Michael Mills again in 1979 on the ITV sitcom 'Room Service'.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
G M Fraser's McAuslan
david_colbourne17 August 2018
I can remember seeing this production when it was aired back in 1972. At the time I had not read any of GMF's McAuslan stories, but having since done so I can say that the BBC did a first rate adaptation.

The production caught the humour of Fraser's story and it was very well put together. The scenes where Lt. McNeil imagines disasters happening were filmed using fish-eye lenses, giving a distorted image and was brilliantly done.

John Standing was excellent as McNeil, as was Freddie Earle as McAuslan and I really enjoyed Alan Cuthbertson in a rare comedy role as the Colonel.

I would like to think the BBC still has a copy of this and that there is a chance of a repeat, but I'm not holding my breath!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed