It's a Wonderful Life (2007) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
HK Neo Reviews: It's a Wonderful Life
webmaster-301722 July 2010
It's a commercial life…

Ronald Cheng is a funny guy and the latest flick allows him to don the writing hat, directing hat and starring hat into a nicely packaged linear New Year comedy. Yes, it is an extremely commercial film and certainly a film made for commercial stakes. With that being said, Cheng have created a film that is largely entertaining and plainly mindless fun. It is a huge step above the bunch of uninspiring and at times boring – Kung Fu Mahjong 3 and House of Mahjong, just to name a few. Comedies are meant to be made with the ultimate aim of entertaining the audience and somehow HK seems to have forgotten that fact. Luckily, Cheng is a capable comedian and he surely knows how to make us laugh, sure there are sectors of audience that do not appreciate his antics, but Neo do find him more funny than annoying. In turn, Cheng have created an easygoing linear year comedy in an enormously pleasing and mindless fashion.

Sometimes, after a day of stress or whatever, it is refreshing to watch a movie that allows you to switch off your exhausted mind for a couple of hours. This flick succeeds in not being original, but by being funny and mindless at the same time. Criticism will be lay upon some obvious commercialism regarding to product placement, especially by the use of McDonalds in a totally unnecessarily manner. It must be said though that it is better to have sponsors to still support HK movies than none whatsoever. After all, this is a commercial flick and its ultimate aim is to make a profit. In the process, the movie is largely enjoyable and easygoing, making it a plus for both the audience and the filmmakers.

In a reversal of roles, Vincent Kok the director that launched the career of Ronald Cheng's blend of comedies takes the centre stage as the unlikely leading star. It starts of being a questionable casting, but as the movie worn on, that question mark began fade and soon enough, for the first time in his life, Kok is a likable character. His journey through luckless to damn lucky is funny and enjoyable to endure. Ronald Cheng surprisingly takes the second in command and in turn seems to care less about acting than directing. His focus seems more as to what the next shot is, rather than concentrating on his paper thin role. Still, Cheng is funny and his comic timing both on and off screen is steady improving with each film he is making. It is a credible directing debut and certainly making his mark as a capable comedy director. Just to add a couple of comments on the other characters, the Saint Nine chick (Mia Yam) is pretty and innocent enough to overcome her lack of actual acting and Miki Yeung appears here and there, but Kate Yeung once again shines through as a bright new talent on the rise.

All in all, It's a Wonderful Life, isn't original at all and it never strives to be either, as its ultimate aim is to make money and create laughs. In that Ronald Cheng seems to have succeeded in achieving both. It is funny to recall some of the jokes that underline the film. In the scene when Tony Leung Ka Fai is plotting to kill Vincent, the Fung Shui guy said – "let's copy the plan from The Banquet", Leung replies, "what is it?" the guy replies – "it's a movie" Leung answers "but I have never seen it before.", the guy said – "exactly, no one will know of the plan then, because no one have seen the movie." It is probably a joke, but it also an indirect comment about the state of HK cinema. A lot of people have not seen a HK movie like the Banquet; as a result, the filmmakers can copy or use the same idea again for their next movie. Such are the ironies of this flick and with that aside, it is still a movie that have achieved its goal, even if they are not ambitious. It is always important for comedies to entertain and not bore the audience to death and in this situation, Ronald Cheng have succeeded and for that Neo is appreciative of his efforts. Sure it is extremely commercial, but it is probably as enjoyable as it gets…

I rate it 7.75/10.

  • www.thehkneo.com
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Very different...
xlovexpopx9 August 2007
The first few minutes into this movie I was thinking, "Wow...This looks kind of lame." Well, I changed my mind throughout the movie. For some strange reason it caught my interest. -It's A Wonderful Life- is quirky but the story isn't bad at all. It's basically just a look at family life from another person's perspective. Mix in some Godly powers and you have a different way of understanding how other people can help solve problems. This movie really kept me entertained...It was just something unique and new for a comedy drama type of movie. It probably could have been better, but most movies can. So it isn't that big of a deal. If you're looking for an odd and funny Chinese film, check this one out.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Out Of This World-Literally
crossbow010623 June 2008
This film is, in a word, zany. Its hard to describe, but here goes: A God called Thunder helps out a fat kid, who is being bullied by a gang in the beginning of the film. The film then fast forwards to where the kid is now a married man with kids. He works in a department store. Both in his personal and professional life he is a doormat and Thunder looks to help him again. Obviously, this bears no resemblance to the Jimmy Stewart classic, but its not bad. The script itself shows some invention. Not anything essential, but pleasant and full of slapstick. Lots of things happen, but the whole thing is about making Ding Don (the adult) realize his full potential and get treated with more respect. The film succeeds in that sentiment, but its not perfect. Its a little way out at times, but if you like these kinds of films, watch it. I liked it, it was pretty good.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed