My Neighbor's Keeper (TV Movie 2007) Poster

(2007 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Average TV Movie
allyatherton14 February 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This is an average fair TV movie.

The story is OK. The acting is average. None of the actors really stole the show, but I guess that's what I'm coming to expect from 'made for TV movies.' This is a bit of a whodunnit and it kind of leaves you guessing right up the end. It's low budget and you can tell. However it did keep my interest all the way through, although the whole movie is instantly forgettable. There's nothing new here. It's all been done before. But it's not terrible. It's watchable but incredibly average.

The ending didn't exactly come as a huge shock and there weren't enough twists in this film to take it higher than 6 stars. I guess it's harmless enough and I've watched far worse.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not bad for a cheap Vancouver - made movie
randy_kay16 September 2013
Warning: Spoilers
I really thought from the onset that this was going to be yet ANOTHER terrible Vancouver movie but it ended up having a few good twists and turns so I would definitely recommend giving it a shot if you happen to run across it. Laura Harring is in it and she's pretty sexy and is a good actress. The main characters were all good. It's too bad though that these Canadian films always try and look like they're made in the U.S., I can understand as they're trying to appeal to the U.S. market which is 10X Canada's but it's just sort of a shame. They went out of their way to show the side of a cop car that said "Seattle Police" on it and the detective is this middle-aged black dude with that sort of American cop swagger and Bronx kind of accent, you know, a hardened American street cop, but at the end of the film, the camera pans across a grave yard and you clearly see a big maple leaf on one of the graves and it's obviously a Canadian war vets stone -- any Canadian would recognize that from a mile away so that was a bit of a blunder. Anyhow, not a bad film.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not Exciting Enough
carolynocean15 May 2021
This movie is just ok , I was intrigued at the beginning , however , as it moved on I began to lose interest .

Perhaps it was the very bland and emotionless acting here , or the fact that we are given too many facts and hints regarding the crime.

That being the murder of Ann , a wife and mother , and the subsequent investigation into her husband Mike , whether or not he is involved .

Their friends and neighbours, Kate and Tim , step in to take care of the children, having none of their own , So it goes from there , but as I said it just kind of drags along, not very much suspense or surprise at any stage , until a fairly predictable and lack lustre finale .

Worth a watch , but don't expect to be too thrilled .

All in all , fairly mediocre , but worth a watch.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Pretty good, creepy
vchimpanzee23 March 2010
Kate and husband Tim want to have children, but they have not been successful. Kate even quit her professional job and started pushing around a cart in a hospital, in hopes that less stress would help. Ann and Mike live next door and have children, but their marriage isn't a happy one. Mike is always working, and his work involves a lot of travel. And he spends too much money--money he really doesn't have to spend.

On Halloween night, Mike is working late, and Ann stays home to give candy to trick-or-treaters. Kate takes Ann's kids out trick-or-treating, and after she returns home, a group of older kids show up, one with a Frankenstein mask. Kate goes outside and notices Frankenstein visiting Ann's house alone. A few minutes later, Mike calls to say Ann won't answer the phone, so Kate goes over to check.

If only Mike hadn't worked late that night ... if only he weren't so obsessed with stuff.

Can Mike raise his kids alone? He may not have to. Kate takes the kids that night, and she helps out a lot when Mike is ready to work again and even travel. Kate's behavior is kind of creepy--she seems to think the kids are actually hers, and Tim isn't too happy over the situation.

The investigation is interesting, and we are presented with some interesting theories.

The ending is quite exciting. I won't say this is one of the better TV-movies prior to the ending, but the actor or actress who plays the murderer does an outstanding job in the final scenes.

It's actually worth seeing.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Is it a spoiler to report this is the *worst* acting I've ever seen??
OneOfSoMany14 March 2010
Warning: Spoilers
My first review and with the warning about spoilers, guess all my reviews here will warn that there might be spoilers.... Anyways, I was stunned to see this written up at mylifetime dot com -- doesn't that mean this is a Lifetime movie?? Usually the people in Lifetime movies know how to *act* or at least pretend like they're acting but NOT in this movie. This could have been a powerful movie that got its message across but the acting was SO bad all I want to do is forget this movie and everyone in it as quickly as possible.

Not only was the acting awful, but the cinematography was totally lifeless and washed out, too. Did they use a cheapie video-cam to shoot this movie? If not, why did they desaturate the colors in the entire movie? It wasn't my TV because the sit-com that came on afterwards looked great.

The whole movie left me shaking my head and wondering what in the world were they thinking - didn't they want people to actually *want* to watch this movie? If so, they completely failed in achieving that goal. :P
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
My Neighbor's Keeper- We've Seen This All Before **1/2
edwagreen21 June 2007
2 couples who knew each other from college days and lived across the street from each other in suburbia are traumatized when on Halloween night, one of the wives is killed. She is the one with the adorable two children. Right away we feel that something is funny because the other friend is childless and is desperate to have children.

We have some real look like others in this film. The widower looks just like John Edwards and a judge at an inquest resembles Bill Clinton.

Other than this, the story is too routine because we soon start to see the evidence mount up on the dead woman's husband. This guy was not such a great fellow apparently as the film goes on. We never meet his lady love who it is claimed has no interest in being a mother to his children.

Naturally, the childless friend becomes very attached to the two children despite being warned not to do so by her husband.

I was looking for conspiracy here. That would have made the film better. Otherwise, it's quite routine.
9 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The Godmother
lavatch6 August 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Kate Powell served as godmother to little Ellie, the daughter of her neighbors, Annie and Mike Harding. But when Annie is murdered on the night of Halloween, it appears that Kate may have the opportunity to play major role in caring for Ellie and baby Logan. Because Kate is infertile and as she was the person to discover Annie's body, Kate is a suspect in the murder case.

The filmmakers were successful in toggling between Kate and Annie's husband Mike as the culprit. But the angelic nature of Kate allows the viewer to recognize that she would never harm the mother of those two beautiful children.

An especially intriguing character was Tim Powell, the attorney husband of Kate, who is often insensitive to his wife. Tim uses his lawyerly logic to urge his wife not to get too attached to the kids because legally they must remain under the care of Mike and the children's grandparents. But Tim slowly comes around to looking at what would be in the best interest of the kids and viewing the situation from the perspective of his wife.

There is a salient moment in the film when Mike asks Tim if he would like to purchase a sailboat with him. The request oddly comes immediately after the funeral of Annie. Was Mike attempting to move on with his life in thinking about the boat? Or, was his desire to purchase the boat an example of the crass materialism at the heart of Mike at a time when he should have been in bereavement?

The actress playing Kate was especially adept in handling baby Logan with loving care and in showing genuine concern about little Ellie. That devotion was the essence of her character. The love and sensitivity of the Godmother was the heart and soul of this film.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed