User Reviews

Hands down the best episode since 9x04 the acting, the script, the music, everything in this episode it great. 1984 is one of the best ahs seasons and no one can tell me different.

4 out of 5 stars.

A fun couple of new cameos with actors from previous season. Making this a fun killer thriller.

The whole plot and story line of this season has been pretty dismal to be honest and is definitely the worst season so far! I personally can't see how any horror/slasher movie fan could like this season it's basically just making a mockery of many films I loved during childhood! However AHS have had poor seasons or story arcs within seasons before but the one thing they have always had in the past is the highest caliber of actors to get them out any hole but obviously not until this episode! The return of Lily rabe just goes to proove how having good actors can make any story shine no matter how bad it is and not only that it makes the more mediocre actors shine too! I mean that Leslie Grossman she the wrong sort of actor for a season like this she just makes me cringe every time she is on screen! Billie lourde has been pretty good this season but has definitely been let down by the characters around her! The creators had obviously watched stranger things while making this season since them going out of their way to mention neverending story they probably should have paid more attention on how they managed to portray the 80's in stranger things and stole that! This season could have been great they had so much to choose from in that era its a shame!

By far the best episode of the season for me. Don't want to say it's because of Lily Rabe, but if the shoe fits..... This episode just seemed better directed, written, and acted than it's predecessors. Dialogue between the characters was meaningful and actually had strong emotions attached to it. This episode was more 'serious' in tone as well which was a big plus for me as I want to be able to believe what's happening on screen no matter how bizarre it is. Lily Rabe really showed off her talent this episode and the emotion/realness behind it is something I think this season has been lacking. Not to put any of the other actors down as they've all been fine, but I honestly can't imagine any of them being able to pull off a performance like Lily Rabe did this episode. Rumour has it that this was the role Sarah Paulson was supposed to play and she would have been perfect as well, but I'm glad we get to see Lily Rabe whose been more on the back burner for the last couple seasons. I really enjoyed the scenes between John CL and Lily Rabe and Angelica Ross & Emma Roberts. Was also nice to see Dylan McDermott return, though was it really necessary? I don't think so, but I'm glad it was there as those scenes were very well done too. It's odd to think there's only two episodes left, so it'll be interesting to see what new twists they manage to pack in as clearly, if this episode is any indication, they're not stopping any time soon.

Overall, I enjoyed every second so a 10/10 for me.

Not going to spoil it but Lily Rabe's return is amazing. She takes on her Ahs roles so naturally and as a result improved this episode dramatically. This season is turning into one of my favourites.

Lily comes to save the serie. Ins't to bad at This time, but wasn't emotional. Now with Lily, the emotional comes with fierce and powefull perfomance of her. As mysty, as Mary Eunice, as Montgomery, she always hold the stick and elevated the material.

Great episode! I was absolutely enjoying every second. Lily Rabe is always incredible but this may have been her most impressive outing with AHS yet. She blew me away. Loving this new badass Emma Roberts. This episode alone made me excited about this season again--for the first time since the pilot episode grabbed my interest.

Been watching this show since the beginning. I haven't enjoyed every season, and this isn't an exception.

The plot of this season is an absolute mess. Very poorly written, twists and turns thrown in at every junction that are not entertaining and just cheap and absolutely ridiculous. This episode takes the cake in that regard.

I expect to suspend my disbelief watching a show like this, but this is asking far too much.

I expect the finale of this season to be just as bad as last seasons.

Not much else to say except that David Carroll Lynch is the only saving grace of the season.

Lily Rabes' performances in AHS are always amazing. In this season, she steals every episode she's in. AHS is at its best when it brings back original cast members in new and exciting roles. The longevity of the series, in my opinion, is certainly attributed to this.

Loved this episode. The best episode in this season so far.

BOBBY!!!! YOU KILLED MY BOBBY!!!! Little bit too much of an overact on the opening to me. Good to see Lily Rabe back tho. -1 Star

Nurse Rita rescues Brooke....

Goof. California licence plates on Donna's car are not from 1980's -1 Star.

Jingles gets capped by the ghosts. And then tells them about when BOBBY DIED!!!

Some good stuff with Brooke. And Jingles gets an update from his mother, Lavinia. Jingles is ready to confront Ramirez. +1 Star for being ready to face Satan!!!

4/10.