"Seven Worlds One Planet" South America (TV Episode 2019) Poster

(TV Mini Series)

(2019)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Tremendous skill at every level gives breathtaking result
jrarichards14 December 2019
Warning: Spoilers
As a veteran watcher - and regular critic - of what we used to call "nature programmes", I'm always afraid I've become too jaded to expect to see or learn anything new. But in this company I need have no fear!

Watched on a big-screen TV (essential equipment here), this episode resembles the others in the series in being a colourful treat for the eye. But it is of course far more than that, having been crafted with a very great deal of thought.

To be gained here is a perfect balance of the emotional and the cerebral, of the scientific and the artistic. And even within the domain of its closer subject-matter, somebody clearly spent a great deal of time wondering about - and then achieving - a correct (nay perfect) blend of the environmental and the ecological. If the episode were all doom and gloom it would be too much of a switch-off. If it was all pretty pictures that would be wrong too. But here the message is that there is still such majesty out there that there is something left to play for - even as the threats grow greater with each passing day. The protection within the Torres del Paine NP in Chile has allowed the puma to rebound, but deforestation in Colombia leaves tamarins in isolated pockets of forests surrounded by vast herds of cows, while the "turning of the tap" at the multitude of giant dams along South America's rivers has impacts on baby swifts kilometres downstream.

Here again, we score marvellously, as grand-scale ecology about tectonics, volcanoes and so on interweave with stories on the scale of whole forests or landscapes, and then again with mciroscale ecological interactions at microcosm level.

Of course, for any story told here, there are 10,000 more. So this vignette of South America could have been a random choice - e.g. based on what could actually be filmed; or it could have been a supreme effort to find things both supremely engaging and properly representative of so much more.

It was the latter that was achieved, and congratulations to all for that!
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Better and better
paulsarah-1406917 November 2019
This series gets better and better and the filming and photography is out of this world and you can do nothing but praise the crew in getting the footage they do. Add to this Sir David's commentary and you have a pure blend of nature at it's best. I will be buying the boxset once it comes out. So informative and you wonder how the BBC can top this.
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Rich in species, rich in illumination
TheLittleSongbird9 March 2020
"South America" had a lot to live up after two truly exceptional previous episodes of 'Seven Worlds, One Planet', one of 2019's biggest jewels. Will admit to not being surprised by that the series was of such high quality, seeing as David Attenborough is such a national treasure and his work spanning decades is so remarkably consistent (ranging between good to brilliant, rare). His best work being documentary milestones, of which 'Seven Worlds, One Planet' is not quite but goodness isn't it close.

Alongside the previous episode "Asia", "South America" is one of the series' most varied episodes and perhaps the most unique of the seven. Being an episode to have at least two rare sights/occurances (incredible ones at that that make such big impact), which is what made it such a fascinating episode as well as a brilliant one. It doesn't matter at all that the locations featured and South America itself are seen a lot in documentaries and not an unfamiliar continent for Attenborough, what matters is that it's well made, one learns a lot and one feels something from what they learn, all three the case with "South America" and the series overall.

The episode can't be faulted visually, the photography being quite breathtaking in sequences like the heart-stopping attempt by a puma mother taking down a guanaco. The landscapes expectedly are really quite gorgeous, the Amazon for example shown in its vivid glory and having not lost its magic (despite being featured in so many documentaries overtime). The music is grandiose without being over-powering and add a lot to the emotional scenes.

It is also well worth seeing for the rare sighting of a hunting mother puma alone, with a story that is the joint closest the series comes to have a very human story (the other episode being "Australia"). Any mother would relate most likely to the puma mother's determination and instinct in the fight for survival, also one is amazed that a scene as shocking as the take down of the guanaco (also rare) was ever filmed in the first place, have found that a lot with Attenborough documentaries.

But of course there are familiar creatures seen too, like the anacondas. Not to mention seeing the ingenious methods of the puma mother hunting and the poison dart frogs' protection of their tadpoles.

No fault can be found with Attenborough's delivery. Sincere, enthusiastic and purposeful, in that wonderfully distinctive never-tiring-of vocal tone of his. Knowing what to say and how to say it.

Overall, beautiful. 10/10
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed