(TV Mini Series)

(2008)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
If only the others in the series had been as good...and as dark
LittleScarletBlue5 February 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Well they definitely saved the best to last in terms of the 'Fairy Tales' series...Jeremy Dyson's re-imagined Billy Goats Gruff was head and shoulders above the other three fairy tales programmes as to almost be from a completely different series.

The first three fairy tales were on the whole inadequate 'Hello' or 'Heat' treatments - light and fluffy, superficial, one dimensional concoctions. 'Billy Goat', in contrast, put one in mind of the weirder Ladybird Book illustrations by way of Edward Gory.

It was strange, dark, funny, imaginative & cleverly questioned our perceptions of the central protagonists - the troll Grettongrat and the boy band Billy Goat. Whereas the troll in the traditional fairy tale seemed to be unquestioningly condemned as the 'villian', in Jeremy Dyson's version the troll was very much the outsider who faced prejudice & ignorance from the boy band and the wider community. Grettongrat became, by the end, almost a noble figure with commendable values.

Its narrative achieved what all good fairy tales have traditionally done - illuminating human nature at its essence - universal and unchanging, thereby questioning what really is ugly and grotesque. In this case, it is greed & ruthless ambition that are the true monsters in 'Billy Goat'. Villainy can come in the form of values that people hold & the prejudices they grasp to...

Bernard Hill was a memorable, even sympathetic troll & all the cast gave committed, convincing performances. Nice to see some of Jeremy's 'reportary company' regulars in there too - Funland's Sarah Smart & Roy Barraclough plus Ted Robbins (Creme Brulee's Tony Cluedo)

Billy Goat was an excellent adaptation - unsettling, weird and darkly amusing with some lovely little touches (the stinging nettles punishment)and gratifying attention to detail - like the 'Almost Orville' poster in Grettongart's office.

It was superb and the saving grace of the 'Fairy Tales'series.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Wonderful script, makes you look for the real "monster" of the tale
madamotaku8 February 2008
Warning: Spoilers
An excellent, excellent modern retelling of a classic Fairy Tale, and the only one in this series to truly explore the possibilities of combining the fairy tale world with the real one. While I found "Rapunzel" fairly cute, "Cinderella" fairly stupid, and "The Empress's New Clothes" a bit on the annoyingly "anvilistic" side with its pro-stay-at-home-mum message, I completely loved "Billy Goat". It had far and away the most intelligent and thoughtful script, taking a fantastical story and making it into a story that actually had interesting things to say about the trap of selfish ambition and the tragedy in the failings of humanity. As in a good folk story, the protagonists of "Billy Goat" are not necessarily heroic all of the time, the story doesn't end the way we might expect, and there's a good moral at the end.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed