User Reviews

3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Neither bad nor boring , but certainly lacking
prodromosregalides3 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Though , you could pass your time nicely watching it , it is certainly lacking and it is obvious it has been created in a haste.

You know , Alexander was not called great for nothing.

And being great as he was, his life, has a lot of elements, that need to be addressed .

His conquest alone of a considerable part of Asia, has not been exhausting only for himself and his people ,

but also for any future historian willing to review his deeds and evaluate the man in depth, and finding themselves frustrated under a ton of information to review and present it to public in an artistic and concise way.

Already through episode 4 , of the series and they seem to have forgotten completely Tyre and Gaza . The series jumps from Issus to Egypt as if nothing has happened.

The series makes no real effort to describe his upbringing and only makes some mentions on the transition of power from his father's death .

It tries to be pragmatic at times to provide some useful insights , on parts of Alexander's campaign and it deserves recognition for this. But it is too little.

Others will also notice the big diresgard on the details and the philosophy of the fighting of the macedonian army, which will pass unnoticed for the bulk of viewers who know little or nothing about Alexander's life.

Alexander's life was crucial to what we are today as a modern civilization , meaning that it was too much for a man to have such an inpact, while it takes centuries and whole nations for such an effect.

Ok , this is an improvement on the attempts of docuseries at Netflix , but they still have a lot of work to do . They do know that they sell on a global audience , the average knowledge of which about Alexander is poor and they probably bet on it to make east profit with less of an scientific and artistic effort.

They don't go as far as to claim that Alexander was a chinese prince from a mongol father and a japanese mother, or a black Apachi in contact with the Aliens(cough cough Cleopatra), but they need futher refinement.

The docuseries does not deserve one star , as many , rightfully disappointed, judged about it, but it is not a gem. Considering , though how many of Netflix's series are one star and touted and advertised as exceptional , Alexander stands out as good.

Let's hope they have not done such a poor job with 3 body problem coming out in March .
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
At Last! The Truth! And Gorgeously Told!
kcrisenphoenix19 February 2024
When I was eighteen I read a book, recommended to me by a new female friend, called "The Persian Boy" by the critically acclaimed author Mary Renault. It was all about a young man in ancient Persia who becomes first the pleasure slave to King Darius of Persia. Then, after being defeated in battled by Alexander the Great. What amazed me was that was discovering that Alexander preferred men when it came to love. I went a did only the tinest bit of research, and everywhere I looked it verified that the two major loves of his life were thus Persian "boy," and Hephaestion. He loved Hephaestion so much in fact that he believed that in a previous life they were one soul. POW!

And now, finally, there comes a docudrama that presents Alexander not only as the brilliant general and conquerer that he was, but as a lover of men. In the first episode we see him show his love, very romantically and tastefully PG, to Hephaestion and my heart soared!

This series shows the history right. The battles right. The way ancient peoples perceived the world right. Religious beliefs right. And the actor chosen to play Alexander was a very good physical choice!

This series, for so many, many reasons is brilliant! Do not miss it!
2 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I like the flow of this historic tale.
thorntonburns15 February 2024
Alexander has a lot going for it straight from the beginning. True , his early years are put aside but not his moments of glory. The earlier films about Alexander covered his youth with the 1950's film with Richard Burton and later version with Colin Farrell in 2004. These films worked better at times but were no great box office hits. In this docuseries we get to see those around him and the workings of a shattered Persian Empire. Outnumbered in many way but the mind set of strategy overcame the obstacles. Thanks to Netflix we get to see a six part series of a Conqueror who knew no bounds and was smart enough to spare and preserve that which he ruled. The added feature is objective views of historians as the story unfolds.
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed