The Garden of Sinners: A Study in Murder - Part 1 (2007) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Compelling, but raising more questions than it answers
glumski10 August 2022
After I struggled to find anything likeable about the first movie, I wasn't sure if I'd want to continue watching this odd series. However, I was pleasantly surprised by the second movie.

Unlike in the first movie, the characters in the second chapter are interesting and even likeable, and the story progresses nicely. It still is a very odd movie that doesn't explain much and raises many questions, but I didn't feel half as lost as I did in the first installment. Even though this second chapter is set three years before the first one, it manages to tie in with the first one somewhat well, though it still doesn't answer most of the questions raised in the first chapter either. Maybe the third movie (which is set shortly before the first one) will explain a bit more... From a technical standpoint, this movie is excellent. The visuals are gorgeous, by far surpassing the already impressive first movie. The soundtrack is fairly nice, though perhaps lacking some memorable motifs. The cinematography is very good as well, with perhaps a few odd choices (like the 'shakycam' approach to the training session).

After the first movie made me doubt quite a lot if I'd want to continue watching this series, the second one helped me much more. 'The Garden of Sinners' still remains one of the most confusing series I've ever watched, though; I'd prefer if it followed the more traditional approaches of storytelling. Oh, well...
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
romance with a murderer
fh1476 March 2024
Goddess movie is cute the main guys will link this attempt to become friends with her and she kept getting red in the face because of it and the mirror ankle the murder ankles also sweet but oh this movie is so good I enjoyed it.

What is written here is gonna be the same in all of my 8 reviews all of What is a tob is new.

The Garden of Sinners is a beautiful and psychological anime. That's not really the point because I'm not here for a philosophy. I think it's cool and all but because of it is in English subtitles. I cannot understand it that well, so I had to go back to a different understanding of the characters and story trying to. Let's just say that the Vibes and gorgeous art was what keep me going through this anime.

It looks good. I can't look away because of the dark aesthetic and Moody lighting and because of the movie budget just looks even more gorgeous.

The animation is mostly used for the small details like finger movement and opening an ice cream with legs when only have one arm.

I didn't get completely the story because of the leg of good English skills I have reading but I got the emotional importance and I really like it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
love to the core...transcends the more strongest basic instincts
k_milo157 June 2018
The Kara no kyôkai series transmits dark and gloomy atmosphere, with a twisted beauty and a macabre aestetic. Is a dicotomy between gruesome and beauty, sadness and enjoyfullness...love and dead, that compels to think obout the life's matices.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The Garden of Sinners: Ch. 2 - ...And Nothing Heart (Murder Speculation Part One)
Tweekums26 December 2018
This, the second instalment in the 'The Garden on Sinners' series is set three years prior to the events of the first story. It shows how Mikiya Kokutou meets, and later befriends, Shiki when they are at school. She is a mysterious girl; it is almost as if she belongs in another time as she wears a kimono and lives in a traditional house. There is also something sinister about her as illustrated in a rather disturbing early scene where she comes across the aftermath of traffic accident. That isn't the only violence; an unknown attacker has been killing people in the city. Mikiya learns details about the case from his cousin, who is a detective on the case, and starts to worry that Shiki could be involved somehow.

I really enjoyed the opening film but thought this managed to be even better. We learn much more about the characters of Mikiya and Shiki as the story moves on in ways I didn't expect. These details serve to raise many questions about Shiki that should keep one wondering about her character for some time. Once again the animation is stunning; especially during the scenes in a bamboo forest. It is quite violent at times and the descriptions of what the killer does means that it will disturb some viewers. Overall a great second instalment which fans of the series should really enjoy.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed