One Man's Treasure (2009) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Review from Mormon Times
jazzfinder2 April 2009
Warning: Spoilers
I haven't seen this movie yet but I've found an interesting review from Mormon Times here:

http://www.mormontimes.com/arts_entertainment/movies/?id=5973

================================ (This review contains spoilers) ================================

'One Man's Treasure' absorbing flick By Sharon Haddock - Mormon Times Monday, Jan. 26, 2009

"One Man's Treasure" certainly isn't a perfect film. The acting is a little stiff, with lines delivered somewhat woodenly, and there are a few problems here and there in the logic behind the story development. But it's well-done enough that when the picture on the screen started to break up and digitize, people in the audience were quite unhappy.

Everyone wanted to know what happened and see the cast of missionaries find the treasure.

This Candlelight Media movie -- created and directed by John Lyde -- tells the tale of a half-dozen missionaries sent off to serve in a wasteland area.

One uptight elder about to finish his mission (played by Darin Southham) is majorly disappointed to be assigned "to babysit" three other missionaries in a place no one had been for years. His reaction to his plight is to tighten the reins and attempt to force his laid-back companion, played ably by Charan Prabhaker, to strictly obey the rules and meet a minute-to-minute regimen.

He has no time for nonsense, yet he joins in the game left to the elders by the last missionaries to serve in Bristol, Penn. (or American Fork/Salt Lake City judging by the signs for Tracy Aviary and the American Fork Library).

Sister missionaries played by Chantel Flanders and Shalaina Fotheringham and the companionship made up of Dustin Harding and Paul Hunt round out the cast which spends P-Day (a remarkably long and sunshiny P-Day) tracking down clues and finding the hidden treasure.

The story is entertaining and, again, absorbing enough that it's very disconcerting to be pulled off-track not only by a scratched disc but by the occasional cinematic mistake.

For instance, the town of Bristol, purportedly a desolate, trash-laden hamlet, suddenly has a beautiful tree-lined cemetery and gorgeous sunlit streets.

Missionaries dressed in clean white shirts and beige sweaters can somehow climb into dusty basements and under a stage to emerge without a smudge.

A tarantula crawls about in the dark and spooky Pennsylvania basement. Not sure tarantulas are native to Pennsylvania, but it's good video.

And the elders somehow expect there to be food on the open shelves in an apartment that's been abandoned for years.

A British missionary used to driving on the left side of the "motorway" drives without disaster on a Pennsylvania freeway.

Clues left here and there -- stuck in books, door jams and behind mailboxes -- are intact.

(It's amazing as well that elders who have only just arrived in a new area, know where the bakeries and cemeteries are and can get there on their bicycles in pretty good time.)

There's also time along the path to the treasure trove to, let's see, change a flat tire, help an old man move a bunch of cement blocks, fix an overheated car engine, set up 200 chairs in a cultural hall, find a select bakery, tour a bird aviary, change clothes, do some laundry and teach a discussion -- all in a single afternoon.

But if one can put aside these logistical problems, it's a pretty good movie.

It won't ever make the big time, but for a light comedy and a story with some spiritual value, it's all right.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Watch it, I dare you.
joemcdonne117 April 2009
Just totally, stupendously terrible. Never watch this film. It's incredible to think that good money was spent in the making of it. There's a full orchestral score, which sounds like it was played live - that can't have been cheap!

Disastrous is too generous an adjective. The acting is worse than "School Play," the script is choke-on-your-tongue guff and the direction is just bloody appalling.

Why did I watch this at all? Because I was practically catatonic after two days on the sauce, and it was hilarious! Probably not the intention of the film-makers, but that's what got it the single mark out of ten.

Advise a long, cold shower after giggling like a mindless child at this dross.
10 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Poorly disguised movie about religion
raypdaley1828 April 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Don't let the title fool you like it fooled me, also don't let IMDb.com's suggestion that it might be like National Treasure fool you either.

All this movie contains is a very poorly disguised tuition about the Mormon lifestyle and their religious practices. The "Treasure Hunt" may initially sound interesting but once all the clues start to turn out to be Bible references you should be able to tell you were being conned and this is just a movie about Mormons & Morminism.

To save you watching it - The Treasure is a family who want to be baptised. It's a SUPER weak ending to a really awful movie with incredibly bad acting and I wouldn't be surprised to discover that if you looked a bit further into the details of the distribution company they are almost certainly linked to The Church Of Mormon.
6 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Small movie equals to small result
jordondave-2808518 April 2023
(2009) One Man's Treasure ADVENTURE

The Mormon Christian equivalent to "National Treasure", the "DaVinci's Code" or the CBS show the "Amazing Race" in which one of the so-called elder Christians inadvertently discovers a piece of a clue, and are then paired into three different groups to compete to what lurks to the end. Like a made for TV movie of the week.

The director of the film, by the name of John Lyde, is also credited for four other positions as well according to imdb, he is also credited for 'the story', 'co-producer', 'cinematography' and for 'film editor'. It's quite a lot for a small movie.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Nice- sweet- nothing more than what it was meant to be
sguphx24 August 2009
When I watch a movie, I do take into consideration

the budget given it. To me, it is the story that matters most,

and this is a very nice Mormon story. The acting was not as bad as

reviewers lead us on to be. Have you ever watched a Keanu Reeves picture?

This is as good , acting wise. John Lyde always does a fine job with

what little financing he has to work with. I have seen huge budget

movies which are pure trash. This, by contrast, is a very sweet movie

for a very specific audience. I liked it!! It would be nice to see what John Lyde could do with a large budget, As long as it is not one of his action movies.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not a great film, but enjoyable as light entertainment
jalapenoman13 April 2009
Mormon cinema attempts to create it's own version of National Treasure (a team of people following clues to find hidden treasure) in this movie.

Okay, the acting is not the best and the story is not the greatest. It was, however, better than some of the really bad Mormon cinema (Out of Step, The Home Teachers, Church Ball) and not as good as others (The Singles Ward, The Errand of Angels, The Best Two Years).

The craft needs time to grow and develop and movies like this are going to come out in the process. It can make for an enjoyable Family Home Evening, but will never win any Oscars.

Understandably, you are going to hate this film if you are not LDS.
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Opinions!
jaybs12 April 2009
It is good that we are allowed to express personal opinions, never have I seem one so biased against a new movie than the first published here in IMDb.

One Man's Treasure is a real enjoyable movie and the young actors/actresses do a superb job (okay I can fault the false English accent used by one of the cast, but that is a typical American perception and so wrong) I have purchased every one of the Producer JOHN LYDE'S movies, he started with real short movies first and they have all been so well produced and they have introduced many good young actors, most of them not being full time professional.

If you purchase the DVD which I recommend, there is a making of feature and John Lyde is totally honest of how limited the budget is on a production like this, but you would never know unless you are going to be over critical. By the way I am not a member of the LDS Church.

Well done John.
9 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Experience Of The Hunt
bkoganbing18 February 2012
Although the plot is somewhat hokey, I rather enjoyed One Man's Treasure because I got an insight into the Latter Day Saints young missionaries and their shared experiences. For what it is supposed to do it is an effective teaching tool about the faith. Having actually had a couple of Mormon missionaries over at my house a couple of weeks ago, One Man's Treasure was a nice insight to their private lives.

Three pairs of missionary young people stumble on to a cryptic message in a locked cellar of their new home in Bristol, Pennsylvania. Two pairs are men and one pair are young women and all are intrigued by this message which says there is a great treasure to be found at the end of the search.

The primary focus is on two of them who just don't cotton to each other. Darin Southam and Charan Prabhakar just don't get along, Southam is the head of the household and one who believes in the rules, Prabhakar who is from Pakistan has a more laid back attitude. During the course of the film we learn about both of them from the others and the experience of the hunt binds them closer.

My favorite scenes in One Man's Treasure are the domestic ones, the missionaries in an around their own house seeing the various rules of their faith they deal with. I wasn't converted by any means, but it was a great insight into the Mormon missionary experience.

As for the treasure and the experiences that make Prabhakar and Southam the people they are you have to watch the film. And if you are not an LDS member and are willing to approach it with an open mind I think you can enjoy this film on a certain level. It's a lot better than some of the Christian evangelical films I've seen and reviewed.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Definitely a must-see
ben_thurber3 April 2011
Warning: Spoilers
SPOILERS: There have been many other films that have tried to highlight the work of an LDS Missionary. These films have shown these young folks in more of a comic or a dramatic twist, but this one is different.

The fact is that mission work isn't all just comic or enjoyable romps. There are times it's very hard.

Like in this movie. Sure, from the standpoint of someone outside the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, it might seem rather dull or not make much sense.

Knowing that the film revolves around two particular missionaries as their district (group of missionaries in a particular area) goes on a treasure hunt, and how they end up serving people they run into, and learning about each other makes this more of a personal story and a story of these two as they look for the best kind of treasure any missionary could look for, someone ready and willing to listen to the testimonies of their work.

If you watch, don't watch to see them get gold or money, for, in the mission work of the LDS church, that doesn't matter. The treasure hunt is a treasure hunt for missionaries by missionaries.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Cool, Upbeat Movie
richardmcelrath28 November 2021
Neat movie, a lot of good lessons, and a lot of good interaction among the characters. Several of the actor were pretty good. The SJ / NP conflict between the two main characters was spot-on!. That's the kind of realisticOn top of everything else, the scenery in Bristol is gorgeous.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed