Five O'Clock Tea (1905) Poster

(I) (1905)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Yup. Talkies.... Or Singies, If You Prefer
boblipton20 February 2020
Dranem sings and dances to his music hall hit in this early sound film.

It often comes as a surprise even to well informed film fans like the other reviewer that there were sound films this early. Yet Edison spoke about his plans to meld his sound-cylinders with movies, even before there were any commercial movies. Dickson can be seen in a sound film in 1895, playing the violin while two men dance. There were several sound films around the turn of the century, although those died off quickly. This series was one of several sets in at least four countries (Germany, England, where Hepworth produced 'Vivaphone' shorts, and in America, Edison did about fifteen of the, in 1914, under the label of 'Kinetophone'). The impulse died out with the rise of the First World War, not to be revived until the 1920s.

Why? Technical issues like a lack of good recording equipment and loudspeakers, mostly, and the cost and just general difficulty of synchronizing sound and motion. In the meantime, this and others survive.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Wow...this is amazing!
planktonrules5 February 2010
This one of two amazing shorts that I stumbled upon and they absolutely blew me away, as I didn't know any such films existed. In 1905, long before the first talking full-length film, THE JAZZ SINGER, was released, Alice Guy experimented with talking (yes, I said talking) films! I had thought the earliest talking films were experimental ones with Eddie Cantor done in 1922--but this was 17 years earlier! What makes these films even more enjoyable is that the folks who put this on DVD made sure the film and accompanying record were in sync--something that wasn't always the case when the earliest sound films were shown.

The film consists of a French cabaret singer, Dranem, singing a little song as a motionless camera recorded him. This short and "Le Vrai Jiu-Jitsu" were both made with Dranem and feature the same set, so it's easy to mix them up with the other. The only major difference, other than the actual song, as that at the beginning of "Five O'Clock" Dranem's voice breaks badly--as well as later in the film.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed