Tue, Dec 8, 2020
Host Nev Schulman is joined by special guest, Charlemagne, to solve the mystery of Miracle's strange relationship with Javonni. Miracle has had a tough life. She is a single mother and feels like Javonni is the answer to her prayers. He is sweet and caring and makes her happier than she has ever been. But they are all in for a big surprise when they find out who Javonnis really is.
Tue, Dec 15, 2020
Kelsey has been talking to Brandon for three years. She met him online when she was engaged to another man and they were just friends. When she broke off her engagement, the heartbroken Kelsey leaned on Brandon for support and a strong bond formed. But whenever they plan to meet, something always goes wrong. Nev and Max set out to find Kelsey's "Redneck Romeo" and get to the bottom of why he never shows up.
Tue, Dec 22, 2020
Robert has been in a wheelchair since he was a teenager. He has connected with Ashley over the internet and thinks she is the woman of his dreams. But, even though the feelings seem to be mutual, it is obvious to Nev and Max that Ashley is hiding something. When they do finally bring the two together, the outcome shocks even them.
Tue, Dec 29, 2020
Max is joined by new co-host Kamie Crawford. They meet Red, who has been corresponding with Jalisa for many years. She has finally decided to travel to Los Angeles to track her down. Red's friend is very concerned and reaches out to Nev and Kamie to help. When they find out the whole story, it's even crazier than they expected.
Tue, Jan 5, 2021
Alyssa met Tyler on a dating website. After texting for three months, Alyssa falls head over heels. But she begins to question if Tyler is real after he refuses to meet or videochat. Nev and Max help her untangle the story of the love of her life. Lurking beneath his profile is a massive bombshell.
Tue, Jan 26, 2021
Eighteen-year-old Quentin reaches out to Nev and Max to help him find out the truth about his mom's online love Jose. He thinks she's being Catfished and doesn't want to see her heartbroken. Nev and Max follow the clues to Jose's identity right down a rabbit hole. The final reveal is a shocker.
Tue, Feb 2, 2021
Dylan has been talking to Sevenia for five years since he was fifteen years old. She has been there for him through some very hard times and she is the love of his life. But they have never met. He contacts Nev and Max to help him out. At the same time, Sevenia reached out to them saying that she wants to come clean because she isn't who Dylan thinks she is. In this one, the truth is stranger than fiction.
Tue, Feb 16, 2021
For three years, Shakinah thinks she's been in a relationship with singer Chris Brown. Yes, that Chris Brown. Despite all the red flags, she believes they are madly in love and destined to be together. Nev and Kamie try to prepare this superfan for the worst. But even they do not expect the wild turns this investigation takes.
Tue, Mar 2, 2021
Kaden fell in love with Adriana at fifteen years old when he was on a cruise with his family. That was four years ago. He lives in Salt Lake City, she's in Hawaii. They stayed in contact for a while, but recently she just totally ghosted him. Nev and Kamie help Kaden track Adriana down and get the truth about what happened.
Tue, May 18, 2021
Stephanie has been in a relationship with Danny for ten years. In all those years they have never done anything but text. She's had other relationships over that time, but she always has Danny in the back of her mind. Stephanie is the mother of twin boys and she knows that they need a stable home. It's time to find out the truth so that she can move forward with her life.
Tue, May 25, 2021
Zay has been texting with a woman named Jayda for a few months. What started as a friendship has blossomed into a serious romance. The problem is that Zay is married to Eris. Their marriage has been a bit shaky and she found comfort and support from Jayda. Now she is ready to blow her entire life up to be with her. But she can't get Jayda to meet in person. Zay needs to find out who she is and what she is hiding.