The Dark Pictures: The Devil in Me (Video Game 2022) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
16 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
The Castle of Murders
AvionPrince1621 November 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Damn! Is this the same guys who were behind Man of Medan, House of Ashes, little Hope? Damn i really cant believe that is the same people. This game really have a terrific ambience, a great atmosphere. Im pretty shocked: i was not really convinced by the other games like really: i found the characters too much cliché, the story not really engaging, the scares can be resumed by the cheapest jumpscares that i had saw in my entire life.

But this game really engaged me from the beginning: the Story of MR Holmes, his museum, the traps, the serial killers stories; i meant it was really good beyond my expectations.

It really have a nice ambience and atmosphere. We asked ourself a lot of questions trough the whole game and we wondering what will happened next every time. I found the characters much more interesting than their previous games and really helped us to get more in the story and we have our reasons to save them or not. And the choices when they came was pretty hard to really guess what will happened and if we did the good choice or not. The story of Duhmet was really interesting and we were pretty confused about who was really Duhmet but we will learned that much later and found out he was the killer.

I love also how the game try to make our task much more harder by make us seek the objectives and stuff: i didnt feel to be helped and that really make us feel what can feel their characters in the Museum: hopeless, desesperate and try to make a path to get out of the museum.

Even if the game at the beginning take time to really give us the more interesting parts of the game and the story: when we get into the game; its pretty hard to let it go: the choices really make some big surprises about the fates of our characters: i thought that i killed some peoples but we revealed later that they were alive and the reason was pretty logical and i didnt feel that the developpers tried to make it incoherent or something and that really appreciate it.

The story about the first serial killer Henry Howard Holmes was interesting and to know after that guy really existed and known as the first serial killer ever existed is pretty creepy. I enjoyed also to see the bonus where we can find a little documentary about that man and how he created the castle and how he build that house and create some elaborate traps and stuff to kill his victims. Pretty shocking that kind of man really existed and it make the story more engaging and to know more about that man despite his horrible acts

The side story about the officer Munday was really interesting too: i almost searched every corner of the game to have more infos about him and how he became a serial killer: first time in a Dark Pictures anthology that i was so interesting in the side story.

In term of gameplay, the game is pretty correct for that kind of genre: the QTE, the choices, the moment when we need to stay quiet and stuff are still there and feel pretty good and we had also a moment where we need to hide that was pretty new if im not wrong.

When i started, i just wanted to finished it really and its been a long time that a narrative game really engaged me in the story and the characters. Im still pretty shocked by some people who died because i did the wrong choices. I had only Kate and Mark who was alived at the end. Jamie was killed on the boat. I still regret some choices and wanted to act differently. But its too late

The atmosphere and the ambience was really interesting and they added a few jumspcares but it was not too much and not too cheap thats a good point.

Sometimes the movements of the characters are pretty slow and not really responsive like when there was the climbing parts and the riddles sometimes the movements was not really responsive in my opinion but it didnt really waste my experience of the game at all.

The characters have their own particularites, their own gear, their own feeling and stories. And we can have the power to make some decision who can affect their opinions about each other andmi really felt that. Mostly at the end with Kate and Jamie or Kate and Mark.

And we saw at the end that the story of Duhmet is not over and he didnt died at the end. We have also a brief view about our new heroes? I dont really know but it sound pretty exciting for the future of Dark Pictures

I really nothing to say more. Im still surprised about the revelations, surprises of the game and i can really say that game really felt much more interesting than the other games of the dark pictures. Even the side story get me engaged. Nothing much more to say except go play it and feel the immersion trough the ambience, sound, characters, stories, choices, deaths too. My favorite Dark Pictures by far!!!!
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Rushed
savvie-8168815 December 2022
I couldn't wait for this having played the games before but I couldn't fully enjoy it. I felt the overall game was rushed so things were missed such as unrendered backgrounds, clothing popping in and out, the dodgy way the characters look and talk to each other, nobody talks to others with their heads down but still eyeballing you or they'd look everywhere but at the other person. I couldn't enjoy the exploring as much as I wanted with all the jumpscares and interruptions so I missed out on a lot. I wanted so much more story but I felt it was missing. I will say I enjoyed it as much as I could and I loved being able to scene select before completing the game.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Atmospheric yet Predictable Season Finale
kluseba4 May 2023
The Devil in Me is the fourth and final instalment in the first season of video game series The Dark Pictures Anthology and is best enjoyed on a rainy autumn afternoon or on a dark winter night. The story revolves around a group of investigative filmmakers who want to shoot a documentary at a replica of Chicago's infamous World's Fair Hotel where serial killer H. H. Holmes once installed numerous deadly traps to murder unsuspecting tourists. The group heads to an isolated island on Lake Michigan as personal and professional tensions are growing between the characters. Once arrived upon the island, the five characters are left to their own devices and soon realize that the creepy mansion is much more than just a replica since an anonymous killer is menacing to take their lives one by one.

This video game convinces on numerous different levels. For instance, its atmosphere is creepy from start to finish without ever drifting off into exaggerated jump scares. This starts with a particularly strong opening scene that brings to life Chicago in the late nineteenth century and continues coherently in present-day America.

The challenges in this game are decent but not too tough. They blend in wonderfully with the story without becoming frustrating for less experienced players. The video game's final quarter however will make it a challenge for even more experienced gamers to save all five characters from the madness on the isolated island.

The game should take about six hours to complete, meaning that it offers one long evening of perfect entertainment. Playing this game feels like organizing a horror movie night with some friends and is just as much fun for genre fans. Playing this game with friends or completely isolated and alone are both highly recommended options. The game is so addictive that you will feel compelled to complete it in one single setting. The game's replay value is relatively high as there are numerous different ways to live or to die on that gloomy island.

On the downside, this entry in the franchise offers few to no new ideas, so occasional gamers might as well stick to one of the preceding entries. The story of this game is of average quality and at times quite predictable. The characters are decent but previous entries have had more fascinating development in this regard.

At the end of the day, The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil in Me is highly recommended to seasoned fans of the franchise or gamers who appreciate the genres horror and mystery. This video game is not as creative as immediate predecessor House of Ashes but overall stronger than both Little Hope and Man of Medan. The most notable improvement of this game is the more fluid use of quick time events. Its biggest downside is the predictable story. If you are interested in immersing yourself into a mysterious horror movie atmosphere for about six hours, then this game is the best choice among more recent games on the market, so don't hesitate to buy this product for a reduced price for next Halloween.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Amazing story but a bit lacking
sdragonkat22 May 2023
Within the first hour or so of play through I was super disappointed in the graphics and the bare minimum of facial expressions. All of the players looked super dead in the eyes or too smiley at times. Plus in situations where they should have been panicking or screaming there was silence. The previous 3 games were way better so it was a shock to feel like the production on this was cheap. I did really enjoy being able to jog (not walk faster), jump, and have a reliable light source. Playing the game a bit more and the story sucked my husband and I in. I feel like I had some unanswered questions in the end however. Overall, great story but disappointing graphics.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The best DP game in the series so far
phullipsmaxwell21 November 2022
Even though the characters aren't as good as some of the other supermassive games casts it more than makes up for it with the improved gameplay great story and gruesome kills. I feel as if the next game could make or break the series with how outstanding this entry was. With house of ashes they had a more action this one focused on more horror elements and was definitely the scariest in so far in the dark pictures anthology. I hope that the next game will keep up this quality because this is nothing short of a great time. I would highly recommend if you have played the other games in the series. 9/10.
12 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Visually stunning
fungus-8978824 December 2022
The Devil In Me does a great job with creating atmosphere and jumpscares it's also looks photo realistic even though its on unreal engine 4 the characters were pretty good the story was interesting the performances were amazing the gameplay I loved and I hope they expand it with directive 8020 this is also the season one finale of the dark pictures anthology and this is so far the best game in the anthology this game also has one of the best set of the characters in the series and some of the most intense moments in supermassives work that had me on the edge of my seat they closed season 1 with a banger.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Return to form
jasmarks21 November 2022
If you loved Until Dawn and have been disappointed by the titles released since, you're not alone. Thankfully, Devil in Me is the strongest game in the Dark Pictures anthology series to date and lives up to Until Dawn's standards. I am only writing this review because I feel that this game deserves a much higher score. I saw Steam's "Mixed" reviews and was afraid this one would be another Man of Medan, but kept finding myself pleasantly surprised. I have played all of Supermassive Games' titles except for Rush of Blood and The Quarry and personally feel that this one is a comfortable second to Until Dawn. It's the return to form that we've been missing.

I found myself liking the characters pretty quickly, this is definitely one of the best casts and stories presented. It was engaging, exciting and struck that same chord as Until Dawn. It's hard not to reference the first breakout game, they definitely have a lot of parallels. It's a modern day slasher with an emphasis on building atmospheric horror. There is a return to the plot-heavy twists and turns that made the mystery of Until Dawn fun and exciting. The plot is a tangled puzzle that is deepened on collectibles. The terror, or feeling of dread building up to something scary, is also really well done here.

This one was hard. I picked the hardest difficulty and the QTEs were really fast. I played on PC with a GTX 1070, 1440p graphics and Ultra texture qualities. I capped the framerate to 30fps but I'm okay with that. My hardware is showing its age but you definitely need the best performance when playing. If you get choppy framerates you can definitely miss crucial time on a lightning-fast QTE. I did save-scum a couple times on that front, but it did always feel like it was my fault for failing them. I liked the challenge, and surviving through particularly difficult scenes feel rewarding again.

There are a lot of improvements here too. The item inventory mechanic was great, and the running has improved significantly. The running animation is a little bit janky because it blends realism with comfortable stop-and-go video game control, but it's a good fit. There are a lot of items, decisions, collectibles, and choices to be made. Even some of the items in a character's inventory can be equipped and used. Depending on how you use them they can definitely pay off, but I was disappointed that some of them were more-or-less useless and relied on the illusion of importance.

Nitpicking here, those "dark picture" collectibles you find (the short clips of potential future outcomes) are as obtuse and enigmatic as ever. Some of them were especially useful and gave advice on what you should/shouldn't do. Others are really hard to interpret anything useful from them.

Overall, don't skip Devil in Me. It's a fun journey that sticks the landing at the end. Not perfect, but it's the biggest step in the right direction that Supermassive Games has had in years.
5 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The best of the first season.
carmenglosandoval21 September 2023
I really loved all the games in the first season of The Dark Pictures Collection. I know there are some that are better than others, but honestly this is the best of the four. Actually was the only one that managed to really scare me. I don't understand the bad reviews, for me, this should be the one with the highest score.

If you truly are a fan of horror games, you will like this one. The atmosphere in the game and the story make it especially good, as well as having great characters.

It was an excellent season finale and I hope they continue to keep this high level, since after this, I expect nothing less.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A promising foundation, but a lackluster delivery at best
violababe420 November 2022
I have played many Supermassive Games from Until Dawn, to each of the Dark Pictures Anthology installments.

Until Dawn was a supremely fantastic game that I wish I could play over again for the first time. However, what I've noticed about this Anthology series, is that they seem to know how to build up a story and world, but then they fumble with the actual delivery, and most especially the ending.

This, on top of clunky mechanics, several bugs that shouldn't exist in a $40 game, and wonky graphics, makes for a frustrating experience.

The characters for each of these games are generally wooden or plain unlovable and I always find myself not truly caring if they live or die in the end.

The Devil in Me didn't feel like it had any really "high stakes" moments like other games from Supermassive. The game also just sort of... Ended suddenly out of nowhere, and it fell flat, never really reaching a true crescendo.

I love horror games, and this one had the potential to garner the right experience with the setting and the premise alone, and so I'm very disappointed by how dull and bland I feel after finishing it.
12 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The best one so far!
StugLeven23 November 2022
Finally the best anthology story so far in the franchise. After too many monsters (Until Dawn, House of Ashes, The Quarry) and just some hallucinations (Man of Medan, Little Hope) finally a pure classic maniac killer horror story.

The shimmying and climbing felt a little dragged out at some points but the other new gameplay mechanics were a good addition to the game.

I don't understand this game scores so low at many review websites.

I think it is the best story so far and I hope they keep this up for the upcoming season 2 next year.

Highly recommended if you like maniac killer stories for sure.
4 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A great end for season 1
wendystamps23 December 2022
The Devil In Me is the season one finale of The Dark Pictures Anthology and is so far the best game in the anthology the characters are likeable and funny the Gameplay has improved a lot over the previous 3 games the story behind Grantham du met is very interesting the visuals are still absolutely stunning this game has some of the most intense scenes out of all of the supermassive games that I have played especially the scene with Charlie in the incinerator and the furnace some of the jumpscares were actually affecting and the actors did a really great job at the performances this truly was a very fun game.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Good horror
wendystampsws20 February 2023
The Devil In Me is a great addition to the dark pictures anthology and was a good enough close out for season 1 that has a good story good characters and amazing graphics and the new Gameplay mechanics are a welcomed addition to the game the game does an amazing job at creating atmosphere the game feels simple and unique the cast do great performances and have good chemistry towards the end and the ending didn't bother me the killer was creepy when he's on screen he was like Michael Myers in a way and it worked in the game and a whole story about him is done very well and the game had some very intense moments and I can't wait for the next game coming out sometime in 2023.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
A glitchy mess
cdbitesky29 November 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I wanted to love this game so much. H. H. Holmes is such a fantastic serial killer to incorporate into a immesive game. Unfortunately, it's not 5 minutes before that immersion is broken by horribly written dialogue attempting to be "old timey". If it was just the dialogue in the intro piece, I could forgive it, but then we're introduced to a group of some of the most unlikable people to exist. That's fine in a horror movie since it lets you enjoy the killer more, but playing a game of "pick the line that makes you cringe the least" or having the group split up over and over giving you no agency is not enjoyable.a Of course, maybe the main story could redeam it and have an amazing killer, right? Wrong. This game was constantly glitching out. From cutscenes just stopping, QuickTime events working for one person but not my co-op partner, clipping objects, camera randomly zooming in so far you can't see, characters just turning invisible (even during their death scenes). It's just too much.

Then you have absolutely no closure from an unstoppable Jason wannabe.

The only real positives were the setup of the house, the saw-esc kills, and the fact that you can save the dog.
9 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Ugh
sja-awesome12 December 2022
The graphics and the animations look like they are from 2007.. the sync kept going off and the mouths didn't match what they were saying at all lol. What?? The car turned the corner and it was all messed up and not smooth. Did they make this in a week? It's 2022 nearly 2023 and this is acceptable somehow lmao what. The story of hh holmes is pretty cool and different then the other ones which is cool and was a bit jump scary freaky, plus he was so messed up and creepy. But the dialogue from the characters most of the time was really cringe and annoying. It also froze several times when i was selecting quick time events. Yikes.
5 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
More proof Supermassive Games can't tell stories
Nob0dy4 December 2022
Every game in the dark pictures anthology are crap, let's get that out of the way, that is not opinion, that is objective fact, buggy, horribly written games, with worse plot writing than an episode of the teletubbies, which are sold under the pretense of the player having agency in the story and your choices having consequences when they do not. That being said it is quite impressive how they have managed to make each subsequent game even worse than the previous.

Anytime people say valid criticisms people just say " oh you're looking at until dawn through rose tinted spectacles" but they are the ones blindly worshiping despite not being able to provide a single justification for their worship. Until dawn is the oldest game in the supermassive backlog and to this day it remains the best, not from a "fanboy" perspective, but from an objective one to this day it remains :(excuse the formatting here, it is fine when editing the submission box but for some reason warps when submitted)

-the longest
  • which in turn gives the characters the most amount of time to interact with the cast, not just limited to static pairs. Gives them the most time to develop or where applicable unravel and allows the story the most room to breath and grow organically, without feeling like crap is shoe horned in for plot convenience or cheap shock value over actual story telling ( something every dark pictures anthology game is guilty of)
-the most polished -the best performing/ smoothest and least buggy -the most well written ( it is cheesy, but cheesy with a purpose since it's supposed to be a slasher throwback at its core) -the most amount of choices -the story with the most impact from those choices, -the biggest and best written cast -the most amount of endings -the most varied endings -due to the above the most replayable.

By comparison devil in me is the worst because it factually is not what it claims to be, it is a game sold under the context of being an interactive story with choice based story telling, it factually is not that, none and I do mean none of your choices matter. A game with 5 playable characters, navigating 37, that's right, 37 chapters, facing multiple situations where they live or die depending on your "choices" and what does that culminate to? Let me tell you, it culminates to you getting 1 of just 2 endings and both of them are so similar that in reality there is only 1 ending. The game has less gameplay than pacman, less of a story than bananas in pyjamas and is more linear than a COD campaign. And lastly the 2 drops of icing on the cake of this entirely linear game with its 2 static endings? 1:There is no "good" ending, it does not matter what you do, there is no possible ending other than the most cliched ending scene in all of horror because with this latest instalment supermassive have not even pretended to care enough to put in any actual effort.

2: Yet again everything that happens has no rhyme or reason, just cheap jump scares and bad things happening " jus bcos", there's no motivation, no driving forces, no reward, no delusions, no identities are revealed, no face seen, there is literally nothing, a vapid empty shell inerlaced with a few cheap shock value jumpscares and absolutely zero substance to be found. You will find more cohesive stories and more developed characters on a colour by numbers on a childs cereal box.

So I am left wondering who the target audience for this is supposed to be, it's like saw but with even less story, even less character development and more tame gore., it has no choices so it isnt for fans of interactive stories, it only has 2 identical endings so it isnt for people who buy into the "choice" gimmick, so it is a game that caters to nobody and is so watered down from the premise it is sold under that anybody over the age of 7 will see it for how thin it is within the first 20 minutes.

Tl:dr. It basically ticks all the boxes of the lazy slop supermassive has churned out consistently with this "anthology"
  • terrible camera work
  • jank movement
  • buggy controls
  • bug riddled animations
  • predictable, cliche writing
  • "choices" are meaningless
  • "choices" are poorly implemented with some being instakills for no reason
  • no character development
  • lazy ending that is a tired old trope
  • the big bad is always bad, but especially so in this game, no voice, no dialogue, no story, no backstory, no motivation, no reasoning, no development, we don't even see the face, there is no conenction/weight or significance to the character whatsoever, which in turn makes his involvment in everything impotent, there is no twist or reveal or resolution, there is factually and literally nothing. There is a cheap jumpscare involving a crow and that crow is a more compelling creation than the antagonist driving the events of this game. Even in terms of formulaic games, this franchise is sloppy, lazy, predictable, seemingly written by the worst writers in the modern gaming world, poorly made, poorly optimized, poorly animated, awkward cutscenes, disjointed dialogue, interactions that don't come across as even being close to bordering on the possibility of being vaguely similar to how humans interact..... just all around a very low quality and undeniably low effort product churned out for a hollow cash grab.
4 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Blech
nikkiinwanderlust23 January 2023
I was able to play every other game by these creators within a day, most within 5-6 hours. But this one took me about three weeks to shove through.

More than half of the directions you go end in dead ends with no clues along the way or at the end, and they'll give you about 7 different options with only One having One clue. Matt's gameplay is long, boring and just utter garbage, and whoever thought that the stupid coins that you think might be clues were a good idea should honestly be fired from the game making industry all together.

This game was so utterly disappointing, maybe I just had my hopes a little too high, I just wasn't expecting to either be bored or annoyed for 70% of the game play.
1 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed