The First Fallen (2021) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Requiered
lso-soares29 January 2022
Warning: Spoilers
The First Fallen, 2021, 107 minutes.

Continuing the home cinema marathon, I checked out another film from the 25th Tiradentes Film Festival. I really appreciate the work of actress Renata Carvalho. Reading the synopses of the films available on 01/28/2022, I saw that she was in the movie The First Fallen. It was my immediate choice.

The film has a script and direction by Rodrigo de Oliveira, shot entirely in Espírito Santo, with locations in Vitória, Guarapari and Domingos Martins. The cast includes Renata Carvalho (Rose), Johnny Massaro (Suzano), Clara Choveaux (Suzano's sister) and Vitor Camilo (Humberto).

For me, it was a film rescue of recent Brazilian history in relation to the beginning of AIDS in the country, when no one had much information about treatment, transmission, experience, generating a series of prejudices towards the first infected, especially gays, prostitutes and injecting drug users. As far as I can remember, there were no films that dealt with these anxieties as directly as in The First Fallen, especially about its beginnings on Brazilian soil.

The story takes place in the time frame between 12/31/1982 and 01/01/1984. Rose is a transvestite, a singer in gay nightclubs, but who also prostitutes herself at night in Espírito Santo. Humberto is a cameraman who makes a video about Rose, accompanying her in her performance on New Year's Eve 1982/1983, is shy and has his first homosexual relationship precisely at the turn of 1982/1983. Suzano lives in France, but is passing through Brazil visiting his sister and nephew Muriel, who has him as an idol. The three discover that they are infected and, fearing the reaction of society, take refuge in a place, where they will experience all aspects of the disease, receiving, by mail, medicines every fortnight from Suzano's boyfriend who lives in France, and having hope about their future and that of the new generations to come. All duly documented on video by Humberto.

There are very impressive scenes, especially in the final forty minutes of the film, when actors Renata Carvalho, Johnny Massaro and Vitor Camilo give a show of interpretation. Rose's speech looking into our eyes is a punch to the gut. Required.

There is a scene at the Genet nightclub, in 1983, where a happy crowd dances to the song Linda Juventude (14 Bis), while Suzano purposely drops several photos of his body with Kaposi's sarcoma. An interesting connection between the joy of the moment of that golden youth and what awaited her in the not too distant future.

It is a powerful film that talks about friendship, solidarity, fear, anguish, prejudice and, above all, hope, made explicit in its last scene.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Hope?
BandSAboutMovies24 February 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Directed and written by Rodrigo de Oliveira, this movie goes back to 1983 and a young biologist named Suzano (Johnny Massaro) coming home from studying in France and feeling like something is wrong with his body. This is the start of the AIDS crisis and he is amongst the first wave of the epidemic in his native Brazil.

The story of the film comes from his sister Maura (Clara Choveaux) and nephew Muriel (Alex Bonin) who come to terms with his death and discover how he spent his last days documenting his decline with Rose (Renata Carvalho) and cameraman Humberto (Victor Camilo). While that sounds like this is going to be a depressing film - and yes, it has moments of sheer sadness and pain - there is light inside this film.

At this point, AIDS didn't even have a name. I remember when it was called a gay cancer and worse. This movie brought up those memories and made me thankful that we can talk about it now and that there are ways that people can survive with HIV.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Remembrances of a Terrifying Time
brentsbulletinboard7 October 2022
It can be terrifying to know that something is wrong but not know what it is. So it was for many in the LGBTQ+ community in the early 1980s with the onset of the AIDS crisis, a disease that didn't even have a name at the time but was simply referred to as "the gay plague." In writer-director Rodrigo de Oliveira's latest, the filmmaker examines this issue from the standpoint of three friends afflicted with the illness in the Brazilian city of Vitoria. The first half explores their growing undefined uneasiness, while the second chronicles their struggle once their worst fears are confirmed. Oliveira accomplishes this by employing a variety of storytelling techniques, some of which definitely work better than others. The picture's second half is undoubtedly the stronger portion of the film, addressing the characters' anguish in gut-wrenching detail and providing them with a platform for waxing hauntingly philosophically about the symbolic nature of their illness, story elements effectively brought to life by the superb performances of Johnny Massaro, Renata Carvalho and Victor Camilo. It's unfortunate, however, that all aspects don't work equally well, especially those in the first half, where the protagonists' uncertainty about their status is sometimes treated a little too subtly, even cryptically, leaving viewers wondering exactly what's going on with them. That's particularly true when metaphorical sequences intrude on the primary narrative, needlessly muddying the waters. Considering the impact this devastating disease has had on the world for four decades, this story represents a significant milestone in the emergence and unfolding of this crisis, a scary time when little was known and the future impact of this scourge could not be foreseen. It's regrettable, though, that this film doesn't quite do it justice in those regards as effectively as it might have.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Masterpiece Brazilian Tribute
andressasilva-4797520 August 2022
This movie is certainly going to compose the history of brazilian cinematography. The script is really well design and the acting of Renata Carvalho and Johnny Massaro deserves many awards. I describe this film as a sensitive and brilliant masterpiece. We went to tears watching it. It is a must watch!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed