"Air Crash Investigation" Cold Case (TV Episode 2010) Poster

(TV Series)

(2010)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Aviation Disaster
jon-klockman2 November 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This episode depicts two air disasters with similar outcomes. The cast and crew portrayed these disasters with authentic accuracy and great professionalism. Excellently done.

The one important thing to remember with any air disaster is to learn from mistakes. I applaud Canada in paving the way with what the North American aviation industries did to prevent future disasters. Not only with the make and model of aircraft in question, but with all aircraft in a cold environment.

Aircraft perform differently in various weather climates and this episode shows what happens in extreme cold and snow conditions. Airline policies can affect decision making. Weight requirements of passengers and cargo, and the simple weight of fuel, all play a role in any flight. Converting fuel from gallons to pounds or gallons to kilos, last minute changes, pressing flight schedules, in-climate weather, personal issues, all weigh heavily on pilots in command.

Overall, the episode was meticulous and accurate. Great job people.

For those of you flying, think twice before you complain about a delay, the pilot(s) may have saved your life by being cautious.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Seriatim.
rmax30482323 September 2016
A US Air flight attempts a mid-winter take off from La Guardia in New York and plows into Flushing Bay. The narration takes us on a flashback to a similar incident in remote Dryden, Ontario.

An Air Ontario Fokker F-28, having waited for an hour for clearance, takes off from the small field in a snow storm and about one hundred yards later, waddles and lands in the trees. Most of the passengers survive but 24 do not.

The culprit: Several unfortunate coincides, an impatient pilot and a layer of snow and ice on the wings; not the leading edges because they're heated internally, but the rest of the wings' upper surfaces. Too much ice, too little lift, so the flight couldn't get airborne.

The design of the Fokker F-28 made them particularly vulnerable to "wing contamination" so the investigators, knowing there were hundreds of the same model in general use, issued an interim warning. It didn't reach the US Air flight at La Guardia fifteen months later. The US Air flight had been de-iced but was delayed at the runway for 35 minutes, which was enough. The accident left 27 dead. The links between the two crashes were finally discovered and corrective measures employed.

These episodes are well written. The technical details should bother no one, and the computer-generated images are so precise that at times it's difficult to separate the newsreel footage from the fakes. This episode is also notable for its use of Shauna Bradley as the actress who plays the role of the flight attendant. Hold, thou art so fair.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed