Erik: Portrait of a Living Corpse (2010) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Great interpretation of Erik that brings the story to a whole new level
janeshon110624 February 2013
it is almost like a diary entry written by him and manages to keep his identity a mystery but yet clarify certain parts of his character that makes the film more like a documentary. Unlike Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical version, Erik contains more dialogue, that is conspicuously well written. Therefore, it manages portray the characters from a much more realistic perspective with twists that the original story never does.

To add on, the film score is well done too! It reflects the traditional 19th century romantic music which is the actual historical setting of the piece. Also, its different from that of ALW's score so its definitely worth watching. If you are expecting to see a movie just like the musical, I best recommend the 2004 movie because this movie is more dialogue based. However, if you originally love the story and are interested in seeing a unique interpretation of the story, Erik is just right for you.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
This is basically a glorified Fan Film.
jjobie196921 January 2015
I'm sure the filmmaker's heart was in the right place, and there are a few fun things here and there in "Erik: Portrait of a Living Corpse," but overall this is really just a Fan Film, no different than the ones you've seen people make based on Tolkien's Characters or Batman.

It's curious, because I've seen interviews (well, at least one) with the director and he seems very, uh, "self-assured," shall we say; but he's still a kid, after all, and he's got a long way to go before his skill level matches his confidence level... so maybe it's not entirely fair to judge what he's done here on professional merit, because it's really nowhere near professional quality.

As I said, it's basically a Fan Film.

Still, if at some point he is able to more realistically appraise his capabilities (and find himself some better actors with more refined technique, presence, and instincts) he could make good things happen in the future.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
More than Good
scndform8 December 2013
Warning: Spoilers
It's taken a long time to get around to purchasing this film and I'm sorry I waited so long because it really is quite good. In fact, when you consider this is an independent film made by a group of kids still in their teens, with no budget, and very limited experience it is outstanding.

Portrait of a Living Corpse is mainly the project of 19 year old Ryan Bijan who wrote, directed, and played the part of Raoul, and while the movie is far from perfect I think Bijan has a bright future ahead of him in the filmmaking industry and I won't be at all surprised to see his name one day associated with major motion pictures. This young man clearly has not only vision but the incentive to make a dream into reality. Making an independent film is a daunting task in itself- to make one that's any good and to do so at the age of 19 is almost too incredible to believe.

Bijan's Phantom does what other Phantom films do not- it makes a very good attempt to stay true to Gaston Leroux's Phantom of the Opera. Most refreshing was the famous graveyard scene complete with skull rolling. No other Phantom film as ever included this part of the book and it was delightful to see it included. Also worth noting are the very cool and beautiful black masks, which in my opinion are the best looking I think I've ever seen in any Phantom film and the wonderful original soundtrack which set the mood perfectly.

Particularly impressive was Bijan's ability to build tension and suspense in many scenes and I must say that the Erik Bijan has created is truly frightening while managing to keep his humanity. Erik is most definitely a dangerous, criminally insane man who shows no emotion while Punjabbing, bludgeoning, or breaking someone's neck, yet you still manage to feel compassion for him. My favorite two scenes in the film are one in which Erik is seen reading the story "Beauty and the Beast." This scene beautifully sums up Erik's own perception of himself as a beast who yearns for a true love to turn him into a prince. My other favorite is when Erik falls to his knees in prayer not only for forgiveness but to be allowed to have a wife and live like any other man. This scene is only about 30 seconds in length but it is heartbreaking to realize the monster behind the mask is also a human being with the same need to appeal to God to be loved as anyone else. Well, done, Ryan.

It should be noted that this film only tells the story up to the unmasking of Erik by Christine- and you don't even get to see the actual unmasking or Erik's face as the film ends abruptly with the final shot that of Christine's hands moving in to snatch off Erik's mask. The plan was for there to be a part two and continue from there-probably in order to raise funds from which to proceed, but its been three years now since the first part was made so I'm not at all sure the second part will ever pan-out but I do hope so. Bijan is about 23 now and I would like to encourage him to somehow complete the second half of his film. As impressed as I was at what he could do at 19 I'd love to see what he could do now that he has some experience under his belt.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed